Is this a "I am not sure he is good" line or a "Hey, he hasn't played a competitive game yet, so we don't know what he can do" line?
If it is the first variety, I think it's a bit harsh. I'm not sure what a player can do to convince someone after a few weeks of training and a couple of friendlies.
It's the latter of course. I think it is slightly harsh on other players if a new signing just walks straight into the team. Especially in the position where we are most spoilt.
