Okay here's my thoughts...
Tentative town circle; Astro - aggressively identified and pursued town's best win strategy on day 1, Billy - has played bafflingly but I can wrap my head around him being a reckless town slightly more than a mafia, Nozzer - random read but seemed to have a town angle on day 1 posting the vote tallies and whatnot though not provided much since so slipping off, Bodanki - a cheap one but MITO openly encouraged pressure on him early in the game to spur things along and given how he GM'd last game not sure he'd do that to a mafia.
So as a result my **** list (i.e. people I'm OK to lynch) is Bobby, TRMF, Valley, afc and IBWT. Got nowt on Bobby. I haven't liked Trev being quiet again but like him putting out why Billy could be innocent, he's an easy cheap lynch which I think mafia would be gently nudging towards as it would be easy to justify. Valley was fairly quiet again early and since hasn't actually submitted much of substance to the game, kind of seems like posts for the sake of appearing active and don't know what the **** the vote on Astro is about. Haven't got much on afc not seen much from him other than his amusing late arrival for the first lynch, hard to compare to last game where he was pushed into a dominant role. IBWT has seemed faily similar to last game, getting a slightly different vibe which has me wary but not too supicious, he's also the only remaining person who could be mafia to explain Billy's Gerrez vote, I voted IBWT fairly late to try and push him into a tie with Tobes and Gerrez so maaaybe if both he and Billy were mafia that prompted the panic Gerrez vote but don't think that's too likely just paranoia.
We can't gleam much info from the lynches as there seems much more blood on town's hands than mafia's, and as for Obi Wan the only motive that could link him to someone would be that he was all over Valley from the off, but no-one was really giving it much heed so don't see why if Valley were mafia they'd choose to kill him and risk actually incriminating Valley, so think it's more likely it was a random kill or they got some read on him as detective from somewhere, but the Valley thing is worth bearing in mind.
These aren't hard and fast just sharing my current thoughts and would encourage others to do the same although obviously doesn't have to be as comprehensive, just like your top 3 towns and top 3 mafia, at the moment we're going on luck, waiting for the detective to be a hero, or just hoping for a miracle. The more info we get out there the more we can go on as at the moment we've got **** all and we're just stumbling through blind lynches whilst allowing the mafia to skirt through without having to offer opinions which can be scrutinised.
Tentative town circle; Astro - aggressively identified and pursued town's best win strategy on day 1, Billy - has played bafflingly but I can wrap my head around him being a reckless town slightly more than a mafia, Nozzer - random read but seemed to have a town angle on day 1 posting the vote tallies and whatnot though not provided much since so slipping off, Bodanki - a cheap one but MITO openly encouraged pressure on him early in the game to spur things along and given how he GM'd last game not sure he'd do that to a mafia.
So as a result my **** list (i.e. people I'm OK to lynch) is Bobby, TRMF, Valley, afc and IBWT. Got nowt on Bobby. I haven't liked Trev being quiet again but like him putting out why Billy could be innocent, he's an easy cheap lynch which I think mafia would be gently nudging towards as it would be easy to justify. Valley was fairly quiet again early and since hasn't actually submitted much of substance to the game, kind of seems like posts for the sake of appearing active and don't know what the **** the vote on Astro is about. Haven't got much on afc not seen much from him other than his amusing late arrival for the first lynch, hard to compare to last game where he was pushed into a dominant role. IBWT has seemed faily similar to last game, getting a slightly different vibe which has me wary but not too supicious, he's also the only remaining person who could be mafia to explain Billy's Gerrez vote, I voted IBWT fairly late to try and push him into a tie with Tobes and Gerrez so maaaybe if both he and Billy were mafia that prompted the panic Gerrez vote but don't think that's too likely just paranoia.
We can't gleam much info from the lynches as there seems much more blood on town's hands than mafia's, and as for Obi Wan the only motive that could link him to someone would be that he was all over Valley from the off, but no-one was really giving it much heed so don't see why if Valley were mafia they'd choose to kill him and risk actually incriminating Valley, so think it's more likely it was a random kill or they got some read on him as detective from somewhere, but the Valley thing is worth bearing in mind.
These aren't hard and fast just sharing my current thoughts and would encourage others to do the same although obviously doesn't have to be as comprehensive, just like your top 3 towns and top 3 mafia, at the moment we're going on luck, waiting for the detective to be a hero, or just hoping for a miracle. The more info we get out there the more we can go on as at the moment we've got **** all and we're just stumbling through blind lynches whilst allowing the mafia to skirt through without having to offer opinions which can be scrutinised.
