How does creating a tie help? Sorry new to your version ofthe game.
Well if we suggest a tie and someone tries to alter the voting to keep someone out it gives us clues as to patterns between people.
Off Topic mafia 5: game thread
- Thread starter moreinjuredthanowen
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
- Status
Well if we suggest a tie and someone tries to alter the voting to keep someone out it gives us clues as to patterns between people.
- May 22, 2011
- 73,772
- 25,704
- 113
How does creating a tie help? Sorry new to your version ofthe game.
You guys got any ideas?
This tends to be the way things go on this board (and the fact Gerrez is always up for suspicion then avoids It last minute
)Interesting to see how you and the other Newkie lads would approach this and if you have any other ideas that haven't been mentioned yet.
Ok cheers
Think I need to read over everything again to get a better sense of any specific views.
I'm tempted to change my vote to IBWT, something doesn't smell right with him.
Talks tactics and is a pool fan..... However, i think for now its probably better to get rid of the quiet ones mainly just to make this game more interesting. Can't have people not contributing or talking or not involved whatsoever...
Talks tactics and is a pool fan..... However, i think for now its probably better to get rid of the quiet ones mainly just to make this game more interesting. Can't have people not contributing or talking or not involved whatsoever...
The masons will know that each other is innocent too. I think.....but since we, and more importantly, AFC, dont know who the masons are yet, AFC cannot rule them out of his enquiry, unless they come forward, which would not be advised at this early stage.
On ours everyone was trigger happy with random 'reasons' to accuse. More of a blood bath with lots of innocents killed. You lot seem to think it through more.You guys got any ideas?
This tends to be the way things go on this board (and the fact Gerrez is always up for suspicion then avoids It last minute
Interesting to see how you and the other Newkie lads would approach this and if you have any other ideas that haven't been mentioned yet.
- May 22, 2011
- 73,772
- 25,704
- 113
- May 22, 2011
- 73,772
- 25,704
- 113
On ours everyone was trigger happy with random 'reasons' to accuse. More of a blood bath with lots of innocents killed. You lot seem to think it through more.
Sounds like our first couple of games to be fair
Plenty of lynching people because of their name and not the game
I've been working in a hot office all day.... not my fault if I smell a little
Are you sure its because you haven't been to busy walking into all those Pizza shops and racketeering our lovely townsman
Who hasn't said anything at all this thread and is playing?
- May 22, 2011
- 73,772
- 25,704
- 113
Are you sure its because you haven't been to busy walking into all those Pizza shops and racketeering our lovely townsman
Who hasn't said anything at all this thread and is playing?
I was thinking of ordering a dominos tonight but thought that might look a bit suspicious
From what I can see, Magic hasn't said anything... RHC has come on voted Swarbs then changed and that's about it. Valley has said 1 or 2 things and might be catching up and Nozzer came on early, voted me and hasn't been seen since...
- May 22, 2011
- 73,772
- 25,704
- 113
Soooooo if we vote to make it a tie is it possible that we inadvertently pull in a fellow townie and get them lynched? Not only that but would then be up for suspicion due to voting for them hence potentially losing 2?
Alternatively not voting at all is deemed suspicious so it's all a gamble. Is that right or have I misread?
7:15pm table:
IBWT - 1 vote - by Nozzer
No Lynch - 3 vote - by bobbyD, Danilo, RHC
Gerrez -1 vote- by AFCFTW
Danilo -1 vote- Swarbs
BobbyD - 2 vote- by Astro, Real Morgan
Astro - 1 vote - by IBWT
Billy - 1 vote - by Gerrez
Less hope than neville - 1 vote – by Bodanki
Goonercymraeg - 2 vote – by mikey, real mrgan freeman
no votes:
Bodanki
RHC
AFCFTW
mikey
magic
Gerrez
Nozzer
Valley
Obi wan
real morgan freeman
Swarbs
IBWT - 1 vote - by Nozzer
No Lynch - 3 vote - by bobbyD, Danilo, RHC
Gerrez -1 vote- by AFCFTW
Danilo -1 vote- Swarbs
BobbyD - 2 vote- by Astro, Real Morgan
Astro - 1 vote - by IBWT
Billy - 1 vote - by Gerrez
Less hope than neville - 1 vote – by Bodanki
Goonercymraeg - 2 vote – by mikey, real mrgan freeman
no votes:
Bodanki
RHC
AFCFTW
mikey
magic
Gerrez
Nozzer
Valley
Obi wan
real morgan freeman
Swarbs
Just pick someone from his four, just following an ordered vote from the proven town isn't that helpful as it's an easy way for mafia to just follow the crowd and blend in, picking from a selection at least keeps it to an approved list whilst showing people's patterns and motives in who they actually pick.
On ours everyone was trigger happy with random 'reasons' to accuse. More of a blood bath with lots of innocents killed. You lot seem to think it through more.
True but we also had to suffer Less Than's one page diatribe and JPF's random rule changes.
- Status