Assessment of Monk

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
ValleyGraduate12

ValleyGraduate12

Aberdude's Puppet
Forum Moderator
Aug 3, 2012
30,380
15,004
113
A number of us (myself included) have waited to get to the 10 game marker to asses Monk. How does everyone think he's doing so far? Has he been what you expected or exceeded expectations? Anything still of concern?

15 points from 10 games is a great return, but thinks could be so mch better with fair refs and substitutions at the right time. A fair rub of the green from refs and Monk getting his subs at the right time correct and we could be in for a great season.
 
Exceeded expectations for me, and improving steadily though still needs to get up to speed with his subs, but that will come!...............<cheers>
 
ValleyGraduate12 said:
A number of us (myself included) have waited to get to the 10 game marker to asses Monk. How does everyone think he's doing so far? Has he been what you expected or exceeded expectations? Anything still of concern?

15 points from 10 games is a great return, but thinks could be so mch better with fair refs and substitutions at the right time. A fair rub of the green from refs and Monk getting his subs at the right time correct and we could be in for a great season.
Click to expand...

Valley - you beat me to it, I was thinking of putting up a similar thread.

After the Villareal match, there was (understandably) some angst and concern about how the season would pan out.

Anyway, after 10 games, we have our best ever start to a PL season. With a bit of luck, it could have been even better.

Anyway, can't be complacent, but at least we have a solid foundation to build for the rest of the season. 25 points needed from 28 games.
 
Much as expected.

Slow to learn from his mistakes and we have lost points because of his tactics and substitutions.
 
Good job so far I think. We've had a fairly balanced schedule of fixtures - not too hard but not easy - and managed to get a 50% points return. Do that all season and 40 points will be easily surpassed.

I agree with Valley that Monk is still learning with his decision making regarding subs, and we've clearly got a disciplinary issue whether that is his fault or not. Its unusual for us, at least, and wasn't a problem until recently. Still we've also been denied several points by **** refs and IMO Monk has done a good job overall though there are areas to improve. Of course some on here think we are in ****ing crisis unless we win every game, but that's what happens when you have a fanbase split over such an issue.
 
cant complain as we have not been out of the top 8 all season. he is still learning and has to fail at some things for him to get better....he gets not a 10 from Len but an 8 from Dai....<ok>
 
Not sold or unsold on Monk 10 games in, in limbo basically .Happy with our points , just dont know how we got them really.Ill wait till christmas to draw any conclusions
 
All I've got to say is 10 games in and only 2pts from 3rd! If you're unhappy then your expectations are greater than what's realistically possible. Basically you're never going to be happy are you!

What a fantastic season, and if anyone's grumbling about possession, in games like today it's simply wasn't in our game plan, today we was solid and organised waiting for the right moment to counter. Great display and I think Gary is being sensible and choosing the right tactics in the right games.
 
We cant argue with our points tally so far and with a bit of luck and maybe some better use of subs it could so easily have been 19 from 10
 
swan_and_only said:
All I've got to say is 10 games in and only 2pts from 3rd! If you're unhappy then your expectations are greater than what's realistically possible. Basically you're never going to be happy are you!

What a fantastic season, and if anyone's grumbling about possession, in games like today it's simply wasn't in our game plan, today we was solid and organised waiting for the right moment to counter. Great display and I think Gary is being sensible and choosing the right tactics in the right games.
Click to expand...

The grumbling is about poor play in our previous games. Position fine and points as expected from the teams we've played in the form they are in - Everton remember have a home record of won 1, drawn 2, lost 2.
 
PLUS:

Defensively much more organised. One of the best defences in the League prove that. <applause>

MINUS:

Poor subs and poor timing of them. Reactive, not proactive.
Poor discipline. Monk's stance on diving may be frustrating the players?
Inability to keep the ball. Our quick, accurate, short passing game seems to be disappearing in some games. 'Smack it up to Wilf' seems to becoming more prevalent.

Overall 7/10 for me. Some positives but a lot to work on. Better position than I thought we'd be at this stage though.
 
Dragonborn said:
PLUS:

Defensively much more organised. One of the best defences in the League prove that. <applause>

MINUS:

Poor subs and poor timing of them. Reactive, not proactive.
Poor discipline. Monk's stance on diving may be frustrating the players?
Inability to keep the ball. Our quick, accurate, short passing game seems to be disappearing in some games. 'Smack it up to Wilf' seems to becoming more prevalent.

Overall 7/10 for me. Some positives but a lot to work on. Better position than I thought we'd be at this stage though.
Click to expand...

That was true of Paulo Sousa too - having the best defence also means we aren't scoring many goal +3 s OK but when a foreigner produces those stats without a striker he is ridiculed and written out of our success story.

Given the teams we've played and where they are and the form they are showing I would have expected 5 points more. & I'm not alone http://bwinbetting.com/leagues/premier-league/swansea-good-start,63153.html?
 
aswan_dam said:
9/10. Doing a fine job.
Click to expand...






Hell he's in your good books then aswan?.............<laugh>






I'd just like to say a big well done to Monk, we may not be as clinical in front of goal yet, as we would like, but Monk has started to regain our defensive strength which is so very important, Sousa would be very pleased with that defensive display!.............<ok>
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back