OT: Mafia game thread starts Sunday 8pm 14/9/14

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
afcftw:7071792 said:
How bloody long does it take to get information? <laugh>

You may want to change your vote to Astro to keep him in the running with you.

I change my vote to skylarker

I suspect Sky is mafia so I'm sticking with him. If I'm voted out then so be it, you all won't be any closer to finding the mafia and you lose someone who can change the game in your [towns] favour. Whether you believe me or not is up to you, either way I speak the truth.
 
Morning, ****hounds of Satan. I haven't got time to read through 35 ****ing pages, so can someone provide a synopsis of where we're up to with this maniacal bollocks?
 
I think Magic might be Don. 4/7 chance he is mafia by odds of roles alone.

Combine with fact no conversion last night and Magic missing.

Astro either did a really bad town tactic or is guilty. Don't think Astro is Don though.

More to gain taking out Magic. 2nd cop could add Sky to list to check him it tonight... or check someone else suspicious like.


3/7 chance Magic is innocent and important though. :(

How was it a bad town tactic? My vote changed it from a 2-way between RHC and Bodanki, to a 3-way including Gerrez. RHC was actually innocent, so it was only a bad town tactic if Bodanki is mafia. So if you think I am mafia you must think he is also mafia and probably a more important mafia than me.

I am innocent. If Bodanki is innocent he should KNOW he is innocent in which case he KNOWS I was not trying to protect HIM, which is the only reason a mafia would have made the vote. So why the **** is Bodanki voting for me at the moment? Is he is actually mafia after all (my accident) and trying to go along with an early "easy target"?

So in that case, no matter what, if you think I am mafia you must think Bodanki is a more important mafia and vote for him.

But anyway I am not proposing that because I think someone else is more likely to be the Don. It's based on no information except the following;

Last night there were no mafia conversions/hits and no vigilante kills and no appearances by Magic until right after the night ended. The vigilante only has 2 kills and needs to rest in between kills so it makes sense for him to wait until he is fairly sure. But the Don has inifinite conversions/hits so there is no reason to not use one every single round. The game is won by the mafia by increasing numbers so it is a wasted extra guy (or 2 for a conversion) by not acting.
 
Billy sounding like a mafia with his current comments... Distancing yourself from everyone to avoid suspicion?
 
We really need a send off for rhc, those who knew him well thought he was a snail and a lizard man fight.... Or king soloman. Others simply felt he was well dodgy.

Whatever you thought you are all bartards for stringing him up
 
How was it a bad town tactic? My vote changed it from a 2-way between RHC and Bodanki, to a 3-way including Gerrez. RHC was actually innocent, so it was only a bad town tactic if Bodanki is mafia. So if you think I am mafia you must think he is also mafia and probably a more important mafia than me.

I am innocent. If Bodanki is innocent he should KNOW he is innocent in which case he KNOWS I was not trying to protect HIM, which is the only reason a mafia would have made the vote. So why the **** is Bodanki voting for me at the moment? Is he is actually mafia after all (my accident) and trying to go along with an early "easy target"?

So in that case, no matter what, if you think I am mafia you must think Bodanki is a more important mafia and vote for him.

But anyway I am not proposing that because I think someone else is more likely to be the Don. It's based on no information except the following;

Last night there were no mafia conversions/hits and no vigilante kills and no appearances by Magic until right after the night ended. The vigilante only has 2 kills and needs to rest in between kills so it makes sense for him to wait until he is fairly sure. But the Don has inifinite conversions/hits so there is no reason to not use one every single round. The game is won by the mafia by increasing numbers so it is a wasted extra guy (or 2 for a conversion) by not acting.

Himm good point. If Astro is mafia and was saving Bodanki because he's also mafia then Bodanki voting for Astro doesn't make much sense.

Bodanki if innocent should know if Astro is innocent so will be interesting to see if he sticks with that vote or not..?

All getting very confusing <yikes>
 
Himm good point. If Astro is mafia and was saving Bodanki because he's also mafia then Bodanki voting for Astro doesn't make much sense.

Bodanki if innocent should know if Astro is innocent so will be interesting to see if he sticks with that vote or not..?

All getting very confusing <yikes>

Of course, if they're both mafia, they could have planned it thus (including Astro's post earlier in the day explaining his tactics) in order to have an alibi. Bodanki could be voting for Astro in the hope that we want it to go to a tie, so vote for other people to be on the same amount of votes as Astro. Then, at the last minute, he could change and save Astro. It would then look dodgy as anything, but could buy time for a conversion or kill, since one of them would then almost certainly be lynched the next night. (That said, Bodanki was certain he'd be lynched tonight, and so far he's looking good.)
 
Himm good point. If Astro is mafia and was saving Bodanki because he's also mafia then Bodanki voting for Astro doesn't make much sense.

Bodanki if innocent should know if Astro is innocent so will be interesting to see if he sticks with that vote or not..?

All getting very confusing <yikes>

Not quite sure how I would know if Astro is innocent or not.

I will probably change my vote at some point, Astro was just an early buzz name.
Do you really think I would go after another innocent if I was mafia, especially after I was pretty much the ring leader in RHC's demise, which backfired spectacularly on me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.