Shoulld I have done it?

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

St. Luigi Scrosoppi

Well-Known Member
Mar 26, 2011
11,980
8,184
113
Southampton
On Saturday the very lovely Mrs Godders:emoticon-0115-inlov returned from town laden down with shopping bags and declared she had finished all of her Christmas shopping.

She put the bags in the spare room and on Sunday when she went to church I had a rummage and to my disgust I found a copy of Always Managing: My Autobiography by Harry Redknapp.

Now that could only have been a present meant for me so I took it out of the bag along with the receipt and yesterday I took it back to Waterstones and got her money back.

I then used the money to buy a copy of Seventeen Miles from Paradise and put that in her bag instead.

I am now feeling very guilty.

Should I have done this?

Should I tell her what I have done?

Or should I pretend I know nothing about it?
 
You do know that Seventeen Miles from Paradise is mainly a book about Pompey? And how are you going to pretend you know nothing about it. Should never rifle through other people's things as you may find something you don't like. Not sure this story is true...who finishes their Xmas shopping in October :)
 
You do know that Seventeen Miles from Paradise is mainly a book about Pompey?

Don't tell me you have read it Fran.

Sun Tzu said that if you know your enemies and know yourself, you will not be imperiled in a hundred battles.

Not sure this story is true...who finishes their Xmas shopping in October?.

I do hope you are not suggesting for one moment that I would tell an untruth.

And how are you going to pretend you know nothing about it.

Stay Calm and deny everything. That's what I usually do.

Should never rifle through other people's things as you may find something you don't like.

I thought everyone takes a sneaky peep at their Christmas presents.
 
Is she likely to actually notice? If she is astute then you perhaps should have mentioned it. If she won't notice (!) then just pretend she bought it. My rule of thumb is always lie if you can get away with it.
 
You should not have done it. I once got a Jeremy Clarkson book for xmas (I assume I got it because I occasionally like to watch Top Gear; but I watch it in the knowledge that JC is a ****er). I smiled and pretended to like it. You should have done the same, it's what xmas is all about.
 
You should have carefully removed the binding from the original and inserted the pages from replacement, and vice-versa.
You off the hook completely.

Of course, some other Waterstones customer will have their Christmas entirely ruined, but there is always the possibility they might be a Pompey fan.

So it's a win-win for team Godders, really.
 
You should have carefully removed the binding from the original and inserted the pages from replacement, and vice-versa.
You off the hook completely.

Of course, some other Waterstones customer will have their Christmas entirely ruined, but there is always the slight possibility they might be the Pompey fan.

So it's a win-win for team Godders, really.

Slight correction