Erskine Bridge closed!

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

EDGE.

Official POTY 2011, 2014, 2015, 2018 & 2023
Jun 8, 2011
38,232
47,064
113
93
Anne Marie’s Facebook
8 June 2013 Last updated at 15:10 [h=1]BBC Trust upholds complaint about Rangers Football Club[/h]
You must log in or register to see images
Ally McCoist is the manager of Rangers Football Club



Stories about Rangers Football Club on the BBC website were not precise enough, rules the Trust.


A committee partly upheld complaints about how accurately BBC Scotland differentiated between the Glaswegian football club and the company that owned it.


The ruling concluded that the BBC had breached 'due accuracy' guidelines, but had not 'knowingly and materially misled its audience'.


The two complaints, filed separately, alleged 'that a number of reports on the BBC's website were inaccurate in giving the impression that Rangers Football Club, rather than the company which had previously owned the club, had gone into administration/liquidation'.


The Trust agreed that some of the language used in reports was imprecise and would need to be tailored depending on the audience and whether it was a business story or a sports story.


In some output the BBC had referred to 'old' and 'new' Rangers in items about the football club when in fact the club - in existence since 1872 - had not changed just because its administrator had.

=============================================================================

<party> <party> <party>

 
Oh dear...

In its evidence to the Trust, BBC Scotland had stated: "We remain of the opinion that due accuracy was achieved."

It said: "A football club, once incorporated, is indistinguishable in Scots law from its corporate identity.

"If the club was separate it would need its own constitution, committee members, trustees, etc.

"Rangers Football Club does not have that because it is incorporated."


BOOM
 
StereoTypist:4897187 said:
Someone complained to the BBC over this? <laugh>

"They called us old Rangers!" <wah>

Dignity FC indeed.

It was an internal complaint...Jabba or Chic?
 
"Rangers fans are of the view that the club remained a separate entity..This is not a universal view, and carries no legal definition"-BBC"
 
"Lord Nimmo Smith&#8217;s reasonings were included in a report...His reasonings do not represent the view of company law"-BBC Scotland"
 
2011: Bring on the Hearts the Hibs the Rangers

2012: Bring on the Hearts the Hibs...

2013: Bring on the Hibs.
 
Oh dear...

In its evidence to the Trust, BBC Scotland had stated: "We remain of the opinion that due accuracy was achieved."

It said: "A football club, once incorporated, is indistinguishable in Scots law from its corporate identity.

"If the club was separate it would need its own constitution, committee members, trustees, etc.

"Rangers Football Club does not have that because it is incorporated."


BOOM

It was an internal complaint...Jabba or Chic?

"Rangers fans are of the view that the club remained a separate entity..This is not a universal view, and carries no legal definition"-BBC"

"Lord Nimmo Smith’s reasonings were included in a report...His reasonings do not represent the view of company law"-BBC Scotland"

A-HAHAHAHA, 4 posts in about 8 minutes! three of which were in a row! he must have been reading through an article, saw something that gave him an erection so copy-paste-post then went back and saw something else copy-paste-post and so on.

don't care though eh? I wonder what the reaction would have been if this and the ASA decision (along with all the others) went "their way"? gospel i'd imagine...

they think they're laughing at us too, one day they might see it.
 
2011: Bring on the Hearts the Hibs the Rangers

2012: Bring on the Hearts the Hibs...

2013: Bring on the Hibs.

2015: Welcome back rangers, maybe we'll fill celtic park a couple of times this season...

Liquidation went our way <ok>

did it? not really, if it went your way there would be no team and ibrox would be a tesco etc but keep telling yourself that sunshine.
 
Tina:4897811 said:
TMTS stylin' as per <party>

If only I could quote Chappers last post I'd highlight his bit about only listening to people if they agree with your point of view....then post quotes from their owner, current chairman, former captain and current head of communications on how Rangers died...

But I've done it before so no real need to show Chapper up again
 
Beautiful thread, Edge.

Obviously it has been derailed by tims that are still beelin' about our teams existence.

It's getting a bit boring now.
 
Chapmeister...:4897916 said:
2011: Bring on the Hearts the Hibs the Rangers

2012: Bring on the Hearts the Hibs...

2013: Bring on the Hibs.

2015: Welcome back rangers, maybe we'll fill celtic park a couple of times this season...

Liquidation went our way <ok>

did it? not really, if it went your way there would be no team and ibrox would be a tesco etc but keep telling yourself that sunshine.

2014 Goodbye Sevco
2015 Hello Third Rangers

Liquidation still going our way <ok>
 
If only I could quote Chappers last post I'd highlight his bit about only listening to people if they agree with your point of view....then post quotes from their owner, current chairman, former captain and current head of communications on how Rangers died...

But I've done it before so no real need to show Chapper up again

haha, you never have and never will show me up.

but yeah, a couple of momentarily disgruntled/twisted comments to a journo beats decisions by various recognised bodies and a judge of the Supreme Courts of Scotland

Beautiful thread, Edge.

Obviously it has been derailed by tims that are still beelin' about our teams existence.

It's getting a bit boring now.

indeed, i predict a slight decline of the next couple of years followed by an almighty eruption crica 2015/16