That's very negative and one-sided. They didn't say that at all. Those were merely the points against him. They were easily outweighed by the many good points, so they said why not give him a go..?
I know that, they were heaping a lot of praise in the first part of the discussion, Robbie Savage in particular, but they are probably right, he won't get selected for all of the usual reasons, if anyone deserves a cap it is Rickie.