Mafia Game: Day 2

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
Going to put this one out there...

Why would the cop reveal himself, obvious target for the killers if he is the cop, wouldn't make sense not to kill Forza next night phase.

Either:
1) Forza didn't realise this
2) He is really one of the killers and is covering RR the other killer by proclaiming him innocent...


Just a theory
 
Paco Montoya said:
Either:
1) Forza didn't realise this
2) He is really one of the killers and is covering RR the other killer by proclaiming him innocent...


Just a theory
Click to expand...


I revealed myself as the cop because:

1. The doctor can ensure I stay alive so we can all find the killer
2. EternalMSC was lying about being the cop

You say that I could be covering RoadRunner - I was suspicious of RoadRunner as I mentioned in the day one thread - that's why I chose to investigate him. I investigated BLS on the first night and found he wasn't a killer, I can't be covering for both of them.

Paco Montoya said:
obvious target for the killers if he is the cop
Click to expand...

and yet, you are the one suspecting me.

You want me dead but you know you can't kill me because the doctor has the power to save me. Instead you are trying to convince others to have me killed. I'm changing my vote from Julius Ceasar to you.


Julius Caesar said:
You voted Nazara as well. You can't pin that on me.
Click to expand...

My point was that you were the one who first said it, although looking back on the thread it was actually Paco who said it. Sorry.
 
Currently the votes are:

Paco Montoya - 1
EternalMSC - 2
The Iceman - 2
Fred - 1

Please guys, change your vote to Paco Montoya
 
I wont deny i have had the same thought as Paco. In theory it would be a brilliant plan. First you protect your partner then just say everyone you investigated is a fan to cover yourself, only the cop and doctor would then have any reason to question you (and if the doctor revealed himself he wouldn't last long) so it would become a case of which cop do you believe. It would be risky to say the least so i have it down as quite unlikely, but it doesn't pay to be blindly trusting.

Not accusing you of anything i should stress, just saying that Paco posting that is not proof of anything since he's not the only one to think that it could be possible and i know for a fact that i am not guilty (investigate me if you want to)

On the other hand i did suspect Paco anyway...
 
We still need to find out why Manny was lying about being cop. He's not answered my question about that which is why I voted him. I don't like people that lie in this game. As for "acting strange" you have to make the assumption that everyone could be the murderer and you have to pry to try and find flaws in arguments etc. Because apart from the cop, none of us have anything to go on.

What we know for sure is that these people are innocent:

RoadRunner
Forza
BLS

The rest of us are all suspects right now.
 
I think we've got 8 players, and assuming Forza can count, we've had 6 votes cast. It's a tie at the moment, so I suppose we have to hang on, but how much longer would people like?
 
DHCanary said:
I think we've got 8 players, and assuming Forza can count, we've had 6 votes cast. It's a tie at the moment, so I suppose we have to hang on, but how much longer would people like?
Click to expand...
I'd say the first to 3 votes to go? That seems fair to me.
 
DHCanary said:
I think we've got 8 players, and assuming Forza can count, we've had 6 votes cast. It's a tie at the moment, so I suppose we have to hang on, but how much longer would people like?
Click to expand...

Fine, if I have to vote I'll say.........................No-one!

EDIT: Just found JC changed his vote which means I don't have to!
 
And im about to be unhelpful and change my vote from Fred to The IceMan. (since it appears to be down to two and i suspect him more) Which i think leaves Paco Montoya with the casting vote or Forza if he changes his mind.
 
I can see EMSC making the kind of error such as lying about being the cop, as such I have to vote The Iceman

Obviously I may be very wrong in that judgement <laugh>
 
Ok, well as it stands, I believe the decision has been made. I'll give it a couple of hours longer in case someone wants to make a desperate survival plea (and I'm busy right now) and then round things off later tonight.
 
I think you guys are making a mistake choosing Iceman. Not that I think Eternal is a killer, but to save Iceman I'm changing my vote to Eternal. This still leaves Iceman dead though:

EternalMSC - 3
The Iceman - 4

Come on somebody, change your vote!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom
Back