Dalglish and Keegan were out the game for years though when they returned though, Brownie's been gone a few months. Huge difference.
Also, as far as I'm aware all three resigned too, Brownie was sacked unfairly. He has a huge point to prove, and I'm confident that a large percentage of City fans would love to see him do it.
Fair point, but to say Brown was sacked unfairly is opinion. Looking at his run upto his sacking it was pretty torrid, nearly anyone manager in the prem would have been sacked for a similiar run, so to say it was unfair is up for debate (for the record i didn't want him sacked at the time either, just giving an opposing view).
Also the point that Browny has a huge point to prove is irrelevant, that's no reason to hire anyone as it should be based on ability. What ability has Browny shown since leaving? OK Preston was dead in the championship before he took over but in L1 he underperformed given the playing staff he had and again was sacked after a dire run of form.
Lastly to say that you're confident a large percentage of city fans would love him do it is a complete guess (assuming by 'it' you mean return), if you'd put IMO at the end i might have mistaken you for Tickler. I think it's more likely to divide the fans than anything else IMO
So given the examples then this is what we have,
Keegan & Dalglish - both club legends out of the game for AGES and fail on their return
Pulis - Stayed in the game and has success coming back (spending the type of money we can only dream of)
Kendall - Returned twice, both times achieved nothing leading to resignation (but ok that was ****ing ages ago so pretty irrelevant)
My verdict - give the job to the man who deserves it most based on what they've proven recently in their managerial careers. Browny therefore comes in as a contender but his Preston record and latter stages of his Hull record probably count against him too much. Clark, Abbott, Holloway & McCarthy all appear as better options and for me it's a case of getting one of them in if at all possible.
Shame it won't be McCarthy or Ollie
[NSFW]PS yes i only added Ollie because i knew it would piss you off

[/NSFW]