Season Ratings

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Dangerous Marsupial

Dangerous Marsupial

Well-Known Member
Jan 24, 2011
3,386
54
48
33
Coventry
All very high, but I think that reflects our epic season!

Ruddy - 10
Steer - 7
Rudd - 6.5
Rusty 8.5
Naughton - 8
De Laet - 6.5
Barnett - 6.5
Ward - 6
Ayala - 7
Whitbred - 7.5
R Bennett - 8
Tierney - 7.5
Drury - 7
E Bennett - 8.5
Crofts - 6
Fox - 8
Howson - 8
Johnson - 8
Hoolahan - 7
Lappin - 7
Surman 7.5
Pilkington 8.5
Vaughan - 6.5
Morrison - 7.5
Wilbraham - 7
Jackson - 7.5
Holt - 9.5
 
Dangerous Marsupial said:
All very high, but I think that reflects our epic season!

Ruddy - 10
Steer - 7
Rudd - 6.5
Rusty 8.5
Naughton - 8
De Laet - 6.5
Barnett - 6.5
Ward - 6
Ayala - 7
Whitbred - 7.5
R Bennett - 8
Tierney - 7.5
Drury - 7
E Bennett - 8.5
Crofts - 6
Fox - 8
Howson - 8
Johnson - 8
Hoolahan - 7
Lappin - 7
Surman 7.5
Pilkington 8.5
Vaughan - 6.5
Morrison - 7.5
Wilbraham - 7
Jackson - 7.5
Holt - 9.5
Click to expand...

Steer 9 (one game, brilliant performance)
De Laet 5 (distinctly average, we sent him back for a reason, too many costly mistakes)
Ward 6.5 (how can you rate him lower than De Laet?)
Ayala 8 (when fit, he was class, except for the MK Dons debut)
Tierney 5.5 (injured most of season, hardly deserves 7.5 for not doing anything)
Drury 10 (the veteran, amazing season for his age, could always be relied on, true club legend)
Hoolahan 8.5 (many game-winning performances, our own David Silva)
Vaughan 5 (played so few games, absent for 99% season while injured)
Wilbraham 9 (did his job to the letter of Paul Lambert's orders, even scored a goal - worth an extra point!)

My Take on the erroneous ratings :smiley:
 
Goldeneye175 said:
Steer 9 (one game, brilliant performance)
De Laet 5 (distinctly average, we sent him back for a reason, too many costly mistakes)
Ward 6.5 (how can you rate him lower than De Laet?)
Ayala 8 (when fit, he was class, except for the MK Dons debut)
Tierney 5.5 (injured most of season, hardly deserves 7.5 for not doing anything)
Drury 10 (the veteran, amazing season for his age, could always be relied on, true club legend)
Hoolahan 8.5 (many game-winning performances, our own David Silva)
Vaughan 5 (played so few games, absent for 99% season while injured)
Wilbraham 9 (did his job to the letter of Paul Lambert's orders, even scored a goal - worth an extra point!)

My Take on the erroneous ratings :smiley:
Click to expand...

So Steer deserves 9 for two (Three?) games, but Tierney doesn't deserve a high score for many more?
 
Dangerous Marsupial said:
All very high, but I think that reflects our epic season!

Ruddy - 10
Steer - 7
Rudd - 6.5
Rusty 8.5
Naughton - 8
De Laet - 6.5
Barnett - 6.5
Ward - 6
Ayala - 7
Whitbred - 7.5
R Bennett - 8
Tierney - 7.5
Drury - 7
E Bennett - 8.5
Crofts - 6
Fox - 8
Howson - 8
Johnson - 8
Hoolahan - 7
Lappin - 7
Surman 7.5
Pilkington 8.5
Vaughan - 6.5
Morrison - 7.5
Wilbraham - 7
Jackson - 7.5
Holt - 9.5
Click to expand...

Think Whitbread has contributed a lot more than Bennett and would give Whitbread a 9, Bennett and Ayala 7.5.

The rest probably spot on maybe Fox 8.5
 
Carra_Rud said:
How does Ruddy get a 10, yet Holt only gets 9.5?
Click to expand...

Quite simply, except for Yakubu's goal, and possible one or two Manchester City scored past him (And only possibly) John Ruddy was absoluteness flawless this season. Holt has been epic too, but not flawless hence 9 and a half.
 
Dangerous Marsupial said:
Quite simply, except for Yakubu's goal, and possible one or two Manchester City scored past him (And only possibly) John Ruddy was absoluteness flawless this season. Holt has been epic too, but not flawless hence 9 and a half.
Click to expand...

He has led this club with his 15 goals in Premier League, scoring against the majority of the top teams

Just because a striker doesn't score in every game, doesn't make him flawless...a solid 10 IMO
 
Goldeneye175 said:
He has led this club with his 15 goals in Premier League, scoring against the majority of the top teams

Just because a striker doesn't score in every game, doesn't make him flawless...a solid 10 IMO
Click to expand...

9.5 is good enough IMO, although I can't believe we are arguing we should be celebrating. At the end of the day, he was coming on as a sub for a reason, maybe your opinion is tilted more towards recent games?
 
Dangerous Marsupial said:
Quite simply, except for Yakubu's goal, and possible one or two Manchester City scored past him (And only possibly) John Ruddy was absoluteness flawless this season. Holt has been epic too, but not flawless hence 9 and a half.
Click to expand...

Ruddy has been immense, but he's made more mistakes than that.

Did Holt need to score 20 Premier League goals to get 10? I tell you this, if we lost Holt for the season, we would of gone down, but if we'd lost Ruddy, we would of still stayed up.
 
Carra_Rud said:
Ruddy has been immense, but he's made more mistakes than that.

Did Holt need to score 20 Premier League goals to get 10? I tell you this, if we lost Holt for the season, we would of gone down, but if we'd lost Ruddy, we would of still stayed up.
Click to expand...

Ok, that's your opinion. And no, of course I'm not judging Holt on goals scored, hence I have given Jackson/Morrison the same rating despite Morrison scoring more, I am judging it on performance. My ratings are my opinions only, and in my opinion, Ruddy's season had shaded Holt's and that is reflected.
 
Dangerous Marsupial said:
Ok, that's your opinion. And no, of course I'm not judging Holt on goals scored, hence I have given Jackson/Morrison the same rating despite Morrison scoring more, I am judging it on performance. My ratings are my opinions only, and in my opinion, Ruddy's season had shaded Holt's and that is reflected.
Click to expand...

Of course its your opinion and you are entitled to it. However, you are probably in the minority of one who thinks Holt doesn't deserve 10 out of 10 after everything he's done this season.
 
Carra_Rud said:
Ruddy has been immense, but he's made more mistakes than that.

Did Holt need to score 20 Premier League goals to get 10? I tell you this, if we lost Holt for the season, we would of gone down, but if we'd lost Ruddy, we would of still stayed up.
Click to expand...

Obviously it depends on the replacements but generally I agree.Holt 10 for me.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back