Saturday's referee

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
he never left the pitch no but he ran towards the govan stand with his finger over his lips before being pulled down by his own players. It's definitely a booking I know it is, unless they've changed the rules?

anyway, the kick at aluko is a straight red all day long. you cant kick someone who hasnt got the ball

Players do that all the time. It's no yellow.

I haven't seen the alleged kick so can't comment.
 
Celtic had two players booked at Ibrox same game for scoring , neither left the field . Petrov and Bellamy
 
Fifa rules state that a player must be cautioned when:

In the opinion of the referee, he makes gestures which are provocative derisory or inflammatory

What was inflammatory about Bellamy dropping to his knees, Petrov getting scudded or Broon standing still.

Rangers players running into the net giving it a big "up yeez" to the Celtic end is fine though?
 
All that means is that Black never acted in a 'provocative derisory or inflammatory' manner in the referees opinion.

Can't believe your running with this Trev.
 
Did that Hibs player Griffiths no recieve 2 seperate bans for making gestures to fans this season? I'm sure he did

The ref had a shocker on saturday as did the ref at Ibrox 2 weeks ago but it's no even worth bringing up anymore, as we've seen on this thread we just get the usual replies from Celtic fans but when these sort of decisions were going against their team it was conspiracy this and conspiracy that. To be honest I'm totally disheartened with watching Rangers games these days, we're playing for **** all so it's hard to get yourself up for them but some of the decisions given against us recently have been amazing
 
UN

What decisions?

McCullouch threw himself to the ground. It was never a penalty.

And Goian was all over Webster. Definite penalty.
 
Did that Hibs player Griffiths no recieve 2 seperate bans for making gestures to fans this season? I'm sure he did

Yes, he did - one was to his own fans and one was to you delicate souls who are never offended, apparently.

The ref got both the penalty calls correct IMHO.

The Rangers TV commentator was fooking hilarious - and, since you're all moaning about the ref, why wasn't Goian red carded twice?

"McCulloch has been booked for walking away. Incidentally, we don't do walking away."

"A game summed up by the utter, utter incompetence of the man in black - a tale of the penalty that never was that was and the penalty that was that never was."

<laugh>
 
Fifa not SFA <whistle>

All the games mentioned were under the jurasdiction of the SFA.

I'm just pointing out that Rangers players "gesture" frequently and hee haw gets done about it and players are frequently booked at Ibrox for scoring and either standing still, dropping to their knees 20 yards away from any touchline or getting skelped with cups.

From what I saw, Black ran to the Hearts fans did he not? Any gesture he made was totally missed by me.
 
UN

What decisions?

McCullouch threw himself to the ground. It was never a penalty.

And Goian was all over Webster. Definite penalty.

How many times do you see defenders and opposition players pulling on eachother at corners? Happens all the time. How many penalties do you see given for it? About 1 in 50 in you're lucky. Of course it all comes down to the ref and what he actually saw but I don't think one Hearts player appealed for a penalty, that tells you all you need to know, no **** knew what the ref had gave

It's not just the big decisions either though, the Kilmarnock game the other week and saturday's game, I lost count how many times our players got hacked down and **** all got gave. The last few games at Ibrox we've not been good enough but the decisions haven't helped
 
So, he told the baying mob to weesht!? RAAAAAAAGE! <grr>

Wasn't aware of your uproar when Naismith was doing it to Celtic fans in the 4-2.
 
Yes, he did - one was to his own fans and one was to you delicate souls who are never offended, apparently.

The ref got both the penalty calls correct IMHO.

The Rangers TV commentator was fooking hilarious - and, since you're all moaning about the ref, why wasn't Goian red carded twice?

"McCulloch has been booked for walking away. Incidentally, we don't do walking away."

"A game summed up by the utter, utter incompetence of the man in black - a tale of the penalty that never was that was and the penalty that was that never was."

<laugh>

Why were you watching the game on Rangers TV? Obsessed much?