I know. I said some people Someone further up the thread seemed to think it would be an idea to consider.
New Manager Ideas
- Thread starter NewcastleTiger
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
I know. I said some people Someone further up the thread seemed to think it would be an idea to consider.
Sorry got the wrong idea of this thread, thought we were looking to provide Tim (new manager) with some ideas seeing as he's got none of his own.
I didn’t say that Chazz. I asked you for some positives from the last few games to help me try and see why Walter could be the man after all.
It was a genuine question, but never mind.
The positives are there as Jim keeps pointing out
We won three games playing really well
There you go
Although and it’s only a small although, we should have been 3 down at qpr
Yes I’m asking for specific positives about how we have played since those wins.
It worries me that outside of those three wins (which I’m not trying to take away as a wins a win) we’ve not really looked like winning any other game. I’d be happier if we seemed to still be getting better but we don’t.
You never started with that
we were all over Portsmouth
How about that
Should have been out of sight
but nope it’s all **** and no positives
Crack on
This was my first post to you.
I did mean in the last 5 games, which I thought was fairly obvious even if I didn't spell it out.
I'm not trying to be negative Chazz, I was genuinely asking you about what the positives were since our last win to try and see it from the other point of view.
We've tightened up massively in defence ove the last 3 games. That's a positive for me
Agreed, on the whole, although I think the second half on Saturday wasn’t the best showing for our defence.
Thank you.
Why do you reckon Moyes will be back at West ham soon? Lopetegui has only had 10 games, give him time.
We didn't play "really well" in those wins, we conceded about 50 shots but managed to take our chances. Pandur kept us in the qpr and Cardiff games.
Last 8 games we've had 3 convincing wins, 3 draws that we've failed to capitalise on winning positions & good control of each game, plus 2 defeats (1 against team at top of league).
I would say we've shown lots of positives during those games, but granted also quite a lot to work on and improve.
The pile on Tim on this board is totally out of proportion. Yes, there is a lot to do to get the consistency required to climb the table but I think we've got gradually better as the season has progressed. The first half v Pompey was pretty good, but goals change matches and the players had to show more mettle in second half and they sort of bottled it, not helped by our fans reaction which was very poor (but Tim shouldn't have said so publicly!)
I personally don't think the defence was the issue second half, it was everything in front of them, even the goal came from daft individual mistake yet again.
Another positive for me is that against 2 of the best teams in the league we matched them and at times looked better than them.
Saturday another positive was the speed of transition at times in the first half
Hughes has been a positive across all his games
They're just of the top of my head
Im not sure I agree with you about the Burnley and Sunderland games. I thought we did match them but I still thought we looked far too patchy and not fluent enough in terms of the team working together. I came away from both thinking they were strange games on the whole and not a massive step forward from the start of the season. But the defence and Hughes were significantly better so I’m with you there.
If we’d have stepped up a bit more against Portsmouth I’d probably look back on them a bit more fondly - but I guess Saturday only strengthened my thoughts that we weren’t quite doing as well as I’d hoped.
But you can’t have it both ways I guess and if we pick up in the coming games then I’ll be happy to chalk up Portsmouth as more of a blip.
Portsmouth laid the blueprint on Saturday. The second half they just pressed much higher up the pitch, so we didn’t have time or space to pass out from the back, we couldn’t consistently pass through the high press. That in itself highlights a limitation of the current system. I’m sure if bottom of the league Portsmouth can do it, so can any other side.