Match Day Thread General matchday thread.
- Thread starter Libby
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
I think that makes him a very good footballer - without question ...
But would Napoli have won the students without Maradonna? - would that Argentina side have win the World Cup? - can't prove it - but doubt it very much - that's a world class player ... Maradona, Zidane, Cryuff, Messi, Ronaldo, Pele, Eusebio, Fat Ronaldo, Ronaldinho, Beckenbauer, Bobby Moore, Bobby Charlton, Gullitt ... are you really suggesting Harry Kane walks in that company? ...
Let's just say our parameters are very different...
Mate you didnt just list World class players there.
You listed the best players to have EVER graced the game
To me, world class, means he can perform on the world stage, ie for the top teams in Europe, for his country and in the Champions League.
I think Kane proved beyond doubt that he can do that.
The players you listed are a class above....well everybody, really.
And no Kane hasnt entered that group, maybe because his career doesnt have the passion and romance of the players you listed and the multiple great sides they all played in, and the comps they all won, but that wasnt the question, the question was "Is Harry Kane world class", and for me yes, a player who can be inserted into any team in the world and grab 20+ league goals a season AND perform in Europe AND perform for his country, has to be considered world class.
Mate you didnt just list World class players there.
You listed the best players to have EVER graced the game
To me, world class, means he can perform on the world stage, ie for the top teams in Europe, for his country and in the Champions League.
I think Kane proved beyond doubt that he can do that.
The players you listed are a class above....well everybody, really.
And no Kane hasnt entered that group, maybe because his career doesnt have the passion and romance of the players you listed and the multiple great sides they all played in, and the comps they all won, but that wasnt the question, the question was "Is Harry Kane world class", and for me yes, a player who can be inserted into any team in the world and grab 20+ league goals a season AND perform in Europe AND perform for his country, has to be considered world class.
So just like Lukaku then - minus the honours?
Lukaku's just the hod carrier mate - never gone past a player like Harry does in his life ...
It's a difficult one and probably a lot played on words... Is Kane a world class player, yes....but...he needs to fill that club or national trophy void. Hopefully he will pick up a trophy with Bayern next season and we can rest this argument once and for all.
No, Lukaku had one good season at Everton, and two good seasons at Milan.So just like Lukaku then - minus the honours?
H e has done **** all else in the other 10 or so season of his career.
Maybe you could have argued at his peak Lukaku was world class, but that didnt last very long
Mate you didnt just list World class players there.
You listed the best players to have EVER graced the game
To me, world class, means he can perform on the world stage, ie for the top teams in Europe, for his country and in the Champions League.
I think Kane proved beyond doubt that he can do that.
The players you listed are a class above....well everybody, really.
And no Kane hasnt entered that group, maybe because his career doesnt have the passion and romance of the players you listed and the multiple great sides they all played in, and the comps they all won, but that wasnt the question, the question was "Is Harry Kane world class", and for me yes, a player who can be inserted into any team in the world and grab 20+ league goals a season AND perform in Europe AND perform for his country, has to be considered world class.
In some ways I'm just playing with you mate ... much as I did with the lightweights previously ... although I do honestly think he's short of World class - last Englishman I'd put in that category would be Gascoigne... have to admit, got great hopes for Bellingham 'tho ... different gravy
Lovely bit of play by the winger for the equaliser.
Matches like this always produce, far better than when you see two big guns face off.
Matches like this always produce, far better than when you see two big guns face off.
So just like Lukaku then - minus the honours?
You must log in or register to see images
The fella who did it (sorry can’t remember his name) step sister, Natalie, lived next door to my mate. She was offered ridiculous amounts of money by the press for her story
The obvious definition of world class is someone who could be seriously argued to be in a World XI which Kane at least at one point if not now was.