Tony Mowbray...

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
It's my theory that most good managers were centre backs or defensive minded midfielders, not sure why it's the case.

If they've got a flair for attacking football maybe it's because they spent their career either watching their team attack from a distance or figuring out how to stop the opposition scoring and have plenty of ideas about it by the time they retire.
 
It's my theory that most good managers were centre backs or defensive minded midfielders, not sure why it's the case.

If they've got a flair for attacking football maybe it's because they spent their career either watching their team attack from a distance or figuring out how to stop the opposition scoring and have plenty of ideas about it by the time they retire.
I'd go along with this. He will know the defensive qualities needed to keep it tight but also he will know what defenders hate so can exploit it.

Most defenders/defensive midfielders are more team players imo, whereas flair/attacking players are more selfish and will do their own thing. Messi or Ronaldo won't be managers, where as I think Jordan Henderson will be.
 
It's my theory that most good managers were centre backs or defensive minded midfielders, not sure why it's the case.

If they've got a flair for attacking football maybe it's because they spent their career either watching their team attack from a distance or figuring out how to stop the opposition scoring and have plenty of ideas about it by the time they retire.

Cloughie
Just the exception to prove the rule...
...perhaps
 
How can a centre half by trade be so attacking minded?...

Maybes hes sick of hearing about defending haha.
No idea but so far hes been faultless mate so long may it continue.
It was funny hearing him say hes personal friends with Dyche aswell and they both have been communicating throughout the window. It goes to show hes been in this game a very long time and is respected by fellow managers
 
Cloughie
Just the exception to prove the rule...
...perhaps

I think that's true, if you look at the current prem all the top managers used to be either defenders or deep lying midfielders. It's just an observation but it seems to be fairly accurate.

Man U, Chelsea, City, Liverpool, Arsenal, Fulham, Spurs, Saudi FC, all managed by defensive minded ex players.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OldNewtown
I still struggle to fathom how someone who is defensive by nature is so attacking in management.
I thought Steve Bruce had an eye for good attacking players and we were quite attack minded under him. All his tactics and ideas.

KS seems to be leading how we play, so he'll have told Mowbray that he must play attack minded football and be on the front foot. Defensive footy wont be accepted under these guys.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FellTop
I thought Steve Bruce had an eye for good attacking players and we were quite attack minded under him. All his tactics and ideas.

KS seems to be leading how we play, so he'll have told Mowbray that he must play attack minded football and be on the front foot. Defensive footy wont be accepted under these guys.

Don't know why
I'm survivin' every lonely day
When there's got to be no chance for me
My life would end
And it doesn't matter how I cry
My tears of love are a waste of time
If I turn away
Am I strong enough to see it through?
Go crazy is what I will do
If I can't have you
I don't want nobody, baby
If I can't have you, uh-huh-oh
If I can't have you
I don't want nobody, baby
If I can't have you, uh-ho-oh-oh-oh
Do-da-da-da-da-da-da-da, hey
Do-do-do, do-do-do-do (ahh)
Can't let go and it doesn't matter how I try
I gave it all
So easily
To you, my love
To dreams that never will come true
Am I strong enough to see it through?
Go crazy is what I will do
If I can't have you
I don't want nobody, baby
If I can't have you, uh-huh-oh
If I can't have you
I don't want nobody, baby
If I can't have you, uh-ho-oh
Oh, if I can't have you
I don't want nobody, baby
If I can't have you, uh-huh-oh (no, nobody)
If I can't have you
I don't want nobody, baby
If I can't have you, uh-ho-oh (not at all, at all)
If I can't have you
I don't want nobody, baby
If I can't have you, uh-huh-oh (nobody)
If I can't have you
I don't want nobody, baby
If I can't have you, uh-ho-oh
If I can't have you
 
Don't know why
I'm survivin' every lonely day
When there's got to be no chance for me
My life would end
And it doesn't matter how I cry
My tears of love are a waste of time
If I turn away
Am I strong enough to see it through?
Go crazy is what I will do
If I can't have you
I don't want nobody, baby
If I can't have you, uh-huh-oh
If I can't have you
I don't want nobody, baby
If I can't have you, uh-ho-oh-oh-oh
Do-da-da-da-da-da-da-da, hey
Do-do-do, do-do-do-do (ahh)
Can't let go and it doesn't matter how I try
I gave it all
So easily
To you, my love
To dreams that never will come true
Am I strong enough to see it through?
Go crazy is what I will do
If I can't have you
I don't want nobody, baby
If I can't have you, uh-huh-oh
If I can't have you
I don't want nobody, baby
If I can't have you, uh-ho-oh
Oh, if I can't have you
I don't want nobody, baby
If I can't have you, uh-huh-oh (no, nobody)
If I can't have you
I don't want nobody, baby
If I can't have you, uh-ho-oh (not at all, at all)
If I can't have you
I don't want nobody, baby
If I can't have you, uh-huh-oh (nobody)
If I can't have you
I don't want nobody, baby
If I can't have you, uh-ho-oh
If I can't have you
You OK Tees?
Quite worrying that mate.
Diana Ross....Ha'way man.
 
You OK Tees?
Quite worrying that mate.
Diana Ross....Ha'way man.

Dancing with tears in my eyes
Weeping for the memory of a life gone by
Dancing with tears in my eyes
Living out a memory of a love that died
It's five and I'm driving home again
It's hard to believe that it's my last time
The man on the wireless cries again
It's over, it's over
Dancing with tears in my eyes
Weeping for the memory of a life gone by
Dancing with tears in my eyes
Living out a memory of a love that died
It's late and I'm with my love alone
We drink to forget the coming storm
We love to the sound of our favourite song
Over and over
Dancing with tears in my eyes
Living out a memory of a love that died
It's time and we're in each other's arms
It's time but I don't think we really care
Dancing with tears in my eyes
Weeping for the memory of a life gone by
Dancing with tears in my eyes
Weeping for the memory of a life gone by
Dancing with tears in my eyes
 
Dancing with tears in my eyes
Weeping for the memory of a life gone by
Dancing with tears in my eyes
Living out a memory of a love that died
It's five and I'm driving home again
It's hard to believe that it's my last time
The man on the wireless cries again
It's over, it's over
Dancing with tears in my eyes
Weeping for the memory of a life gone by
Dancing with tears in my eyes
Living out a memory of a love that died
It's late and I'm with my love alone
We drink to forget the coming storm
We love to the sound of our favourite song
Over and over
Dancing with tears in my eyes
Living out a memory of a love that died
It's time and we're in each other's arms
It's time but I don't think we really care
Dancing with tears in my eyes
Weeping for the memory of a life gone by
Dancing with tears in my eyes
Weeping for the memory of a life gone by
Dancing with tears in my eyes
Love a bit of Ultravox
 
Interesting Thread.

Curiosity took me to the list of former Managers.
Defenders predominate and most of these were Centre Half's, when playing.

Alan Brown, George Hardwick. Bob Stokoe, Jimmy Adamson, Billy Elliott, Len Ashurst, Lawrie the Enemy, Dennis Smith, Mick McCarthy, Steve Bruce, Sam Allardyce. David Moyse, Chris Coleman,
 
Interesting Thread.

Curiosity took me to the list of former Managers.
Defenders predominate and most of these were Centre Half's, when playing.

Alan Brown, George Hardwick. Bob Stokoe, Jimmy Adamson, Billy Elliott, Len Ashurst, Lawrie the Enemy, Dennis Smith, Mick McCarthy, Steve Bruce, Sam Allardyce. David Moyse, Chris Coleman,
Could also reflect a pay differential between strikers and defenders making more defenders have to keep on earning?

Certainly something that will be more applicable in the last 10 years or so.

Overall I'm more inclined to go with central defenders organising the whole defence, working out the opposition's attacking play and trying to counter it.

Defensive midfielders will do a lot of this, but rather than organising the defence they will be covering in front of them.
 
Really interesting question this.

My sense is defenders see the whole of the game all of the time. Everything ia in front of them. They should therefore always be the most aware whilst on the pitch. A captain at the back is always the way to go for this reason in my opinion. No excuse for not seeing anything. Also worth expoloring how many captains become managers, because in general they will be part of the managers inner circle.

Here is anothet theory, based only on my experience with players. Centre halves and centre mids are really unselfish and they want to listen all the time. Those more creative sorts, or goalscorers, have less interest in the overall tactical side of the game. That is a generalisation I know. I am coaching a centre back currently who has missed academy football for some reason. He is 16 and I am getting him into mens semi pro and he is flying. All because he is listening and has a great brain on him. Be amazed if in 4 years he isnt playing in the pro game. He just wants every last bit of info.

My last thought is everyone wants to see lovely football. Defenders are often players that fancy themselves as beckenbauer. Why not get rid of their inner frustration of a playing career by producing something you really want to watch.