Summer Transfer Window

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Youtube scout report please

You must log in or register to see media

I think the issue regarding the Barbosa signing won't be his skill level but more an attitude issue. Kids treated like royalty in Brazil and loves the limelight away from the pitch as much as on it, which is something I think we're trying to stay clear from. I have a sneaky feeling this may the signing Staveley referred to when she said they had one done which they pulled out of due to reports off the field.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Munson.
He's really not, but regardless it's a team effort and now they don't have restraints.

The time to start judgement was January and so far recruitment has been excellent.

There's a few fans think they know better than the scouts and the club, but we all know 2 thirds of **** all tbh.
Ahh, the "mysterious fans" cropping up again.

Do you know who they are so that we can have a "word" with them? If you know what I mean.

:)
 
Who’s to say Nickson isn’t a brilliant scout that was just misused under the previous regime/tyrant. If he had anything to do with the January signings then he has done a brilliant job under the new owners. Equally how do we know he didn’t recommend big Joe as a midfielder but Bruce and his “coaching” staff ignored him
 
  • Like
Reactions: Munson.
Who’s to say Nickson isn’t a brilliant scout that was just misused under the previous regime/tyrant. If he had anything to do with the January signings then he has done a brilliant job under the new owners. Equally how do we know he didn’t recommend big Joe as a midfielder but Bruce and his “coaching” staff ignored him


You must log in or register to see images
 
  • Like
Reactions: Givemeursaltytears
Who’s to say Nickson isn’t a brilliant scout that was just misused under the previous regime/tyrant. If he had anything to do with the January signings then he has done a brilliant job under the new owners. Equally how do we know he didn’t recommend big Joe as a midfielder but Bruce and his “coaching” staff ignored him

I'm going to guess the answer to that one is quite probably the fact that Joelinton had never ever ever ever ever EVER played in midfield before EVER. He played as a left sided forward in a front 3 for Hoffenheim.
 
I think the issue regarding the Barbosa signing won't be his skill level but more an attitude issue. Kids treated like royalty in Brazil and loves the limelight away from the pitch as much as on it, which is something I think we're trying to stay clear from. I have a sneaky feeling this may the signing Staveley referred to when she said they had one done which they pulled out of due to reports off the field.
I’ve seen a bit of him in the Copa Libertadores, Tim Vickery the commentator is not a fan of him. Tore into him during one match because he was sulking after not winning a penalty, basically it was a character assassination calling him weak mentally and thinking he was a big time Charlie……I’d stay well clear if that’s the case, that type of signing is where we don’t want to go, we need to avoid big time Charlie’s and mercenaries, we need good honest pros like Burn, Targett, Pope etc mixed with a few hungry ambitious lads like Bruno
 
  • Like
Reactions: Munson.
I’ve seen a bit of him in the Copa Libertadores, Tim Vickery the commentator is not a fan of him. Tore into him during one match because he was sulking after not winning a penalty, basically it was a character assassination calling him weak mentally and thinking he was a big time Charlie……I’d stay well clear if that’s the case, that type of signing is where we don’t want to go, we need to avoid big time Charlie’s and mercenaries, we need good honest pros like Burn, Targett, Pope etc mixed with a few hungry ambitious lads like Bruno

Thats kind of strange because I'm sure it was the very same fella that said what I just wrote before about him. That being said he didn't think very much of Bruno either if I remember correctly .
 
  • Like
Reactions: Givemeursaltytears
I’ve seen a bit of him in the Copa Libertadores, Tim Vickery the commentator is not a fan of him. Tore into him during one match because he was sulking after not winning a penalty, basically it was a character assassination calling him weak mentally and thinking he was a big time Charlie……I’d stay well clear if that’s the case, that type of signing is where we don’t want to go, we need to avoid big time Charlie’s and mercenaries, we need good honest pros like Burn, Targett, Pope etc mixed with a few hungry ambitious lads like Bruno

Targett was another nixon wanted years ago..
The list of players he wanted but Charnley didn't cough up for is extensive.
 
I'm going to guess the answer to that one is quite probably the fact that Joelinton had never ever ever ever ever EVER played in midfield before EVER. He played as a left sided forward in a front 3 for Hoffenheim.
You’re probably right but there’s more to scouting then picking players based on the position they play in. Remember Shearer started as a GK until someone saw something else in him. I’m not saying factually that Nickson recommend Joe as a midfielder but who knows, maybe he saw the attributes and physicality of a guy who could play there but meathead wouldn’t listen to him. I’m willing to give Nickson a chance to prove himself.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Munson.
Isn’t recruitment different to scouting albeit linked so you can have a head of recruitment and a head of scouting. Would guess the head of recruitment is the one with the biggest say on signings though.


He'll have a bigger say, but it's really a team effort. They've all done very well since the tyranical rule of Ashley and Charnley ended.

Funny that isn't it...
 
  • Like
Reactions: magpie290761
Thats kind of strange because I'm sure it was the very same fella that said what I just wrote before about him. That being said he didn't think very much of Bruno either if I remember correctly .
It sounded very personal when he tore into him, I wonder had Vickery something to do with recommending him to Milan and got burnt in the process.
 
You’re probably right but there’s more to scouting then picking players based on the position they play in. Remember Shearer started as a GK until someone saw something else in him. I’m not saying factually that Nickson recommend Joe as a midfielder but who knows, maybe he saw the attributes and physicality of a guy who could play there but meathead wouldn’t listen to him. I’m willing to give Nickson a chance to prove himself.


Graham Carr got blamed last time but I'm sure he'd have done fine without the arseholes that were running the club at the time.

The fans blamed Ashley for everything, but never spared a thought as to how hard it would be working under such a tyrannical arsehole.

If the scouts asked for a mars bar they were given a chomp
 
Isn’t recruitment different to scouting albeit linked so you can have a head of recruitment and a head of scouting. Would guess the head of recruitment is the one with the biggest say on signings though.
It’s more a title really, most head of recruitments will have spent years working as scouts. Nickson I think initially began as an u21 scout for us
 
  • Like
Reactions: magpie290761
Graham Carr got blamed last time but I'm sure he'd have done fine without the arseholes that were running the club at the time.

The fans blamed Ashley for everything, but never spared a thought as to how hard it would be working under such a tyrannical arsehole.

If the scouts asked for a mars bar they were given a chomp
Exactly!! Nickson once recommended Tomiasyu but we ended up with Krafth, now thanks to good coaching from Howe and Co Krafth has improved but that’s an example of how Ashley and Charnleys minds worked
 
  • Like
Reactions: Munson.