What, finding out what the legal position is?
Go and read one of the extensive threads on here covering the subject and save yourself some embarasment.
I suppose the swans would have taken their standard approach and given them 5p in the pound.![]()

Why should we pay more ? 
I suggest you brush up on your contract law.
Sparks can this thread be tidied up and kept on subject?
Its going to go to the wire in the Championship.
Think Leeds will do it.
It would be funny to see Villa fail but id rather them not be in the Championship next season.
Threads often go off the subject, that's what makes it so interesting. Tidying up is another way of getting rid of difficult side issues raised, and not having to deal with them. They don't go away, however, so best dealt with.
I don't feel embarrassed at all.That post was my first comment on the very sad Sala affair.
When I heard that the plane had gone missing, my FIRST thought was, who's player is / was he, and how many lawyers were now pouring over contracts to find out the level of responsibility, etc.?
I didn't post my questions, lest they were seen in bad taste.
However, things have moved on.
Cardiff had to announce him as their new signing, the fans' demanded such.
Sala had been paraded wearing the shirt, holding the scarf, and tapping his head in the moronic way that only Cardiff fans' can appreciate, or even understand.
For all intents and purposes, he was a Cardiff player.
Had anyone associated with that Club possessed a modicum of intelligence, or awareness of the realities of players being signed by Welsh Club's, they would have held back, until such time as the transfer WAS RATIFIED BY ALL THE RELEVANT ORGANISATIONS. Then produce him tapping his head.
Time has moved on, and Sala was not in fact a fully signed up player for Cardiff City, and NOW they are contesting the validity of the deal. No surprise there than, at least to me, who saw it coming, from day one.
Warnock stated that " Cardiff would do the right thing, and pay the £ 15 million ". He went up in my estimation when saying that, but I doubt that he had discussed it with his employers beforehand.
I also saw your "5p in the pound" coming. Predictability, it's so predictable.
Perhaps Cardiff could use that as a reason to avoid their responsibilities to Nantes in this unfortunate matter.
" The Swans' only pay 5p in the pound ".Why should we pay more ?
PS. I don't feel embarrassed, but perhaps you should - NOW !
I don't feel embarrassed at all.
I agree that the timing of the announcement may have been premature, but most / all clubs (including yourselves) will have announced signings before they have been ratified. Also, many contracts will have been modified and resigned after those players have been an ounce, we just don't hear about it as there is no need.
What is unprecedented in this instance is the unfortunate loss of life and the unbelievable timing. A week earlier he'd defi.itely have been a Nantes player, a week later defintely a Cardiff player.
As has been written numerous times, but you obviously can't be bothered to read the correct threads, comes down to insurance.
If he is shown to be a Cardiff player, we pay Nantes and we claim on our insurance, neither club out of pocket.
If he is shown to be a Nantes player, they claim on their insurance. Neither club out of pocket.
If we pay Nantes and he's a Nantes player, we can't claim on the insurance and we're £15M out of pocket.
As for the 5p in the pound comment, predictable yes (and about which YOU should be ashamed), but there again, people in glass houses.......
Why should I be ashamed of something I was not involved/had no say/influence, in ?
What a silly thing to insinuate.
I used to live in Cardiff, does that mean I should be ashamed of this Nantes affair ?
Using your logic, why should I be ashamed of something I had no say or influence in?
Rather a flawed argument.

Get this thread back on topic and moderate the ill educated tosh from the third worldThreads often go off the subject, that's what makes it so interesting. Tidying up is another way of getting rid of difficult side issues raised, and not having to deal with them. They don't go away, however, so best dealt with.
Get this thread back on topic and moderate the ill educated tosh from the third world


My fault.Didn't look in much on here yesterday with our game and other Easter matters going on, but I see a couple of calls for moderation on this thread. I don't like the moderation (deletion) of comments per se having personally suffered at the hands of "The Vicar" on another forum for no reason other than it didn't fit the doctrine he laid down.
Having said that, it's a valid point that this thread was broadly being kept on topic and was a fair exchange of views on the intended subject. For some reason it has been skewed away from it's purpose to discuss unrelated matters that have been well covered elsewhere.
I would simply ask those who are disrupting the discussion to desist from now on and we can all carry on discussing the vey exciting end to the Championship season over the next few weeks.
I thank you all.![]()
My fault.
Appologies.

No apologies requested nor needed - the problem started with post [HASHTAG]#197[/HASHTAG].
Thread disruption is a problem, but not necessarily life threatening.![]()


Not that it matters very much, but the disruption started a bit earlier when the price of Easter eggs was mentioned.
But , hey, I've got broad shoulders, so you can just blame me.
It's all a bit sad when people complain about something so trivial as having to deal with two subjects in a thread. Concentration, coupled with a modicum of intelligence, would clearly assist the complainer.
It's make one wonder how he copes in the real world, where real problems abound.
Have a nice day.![]()
