Off Topic The Politics Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

Should the UK remain a part of the EU or leave?

  • Stay in

    Votes: 56 47.9%
  • Get out

    Votes: 61 52.1%

  • Total voters
    117
  • Poll closed .
I would understand this line of argument if all current residents in the UK were allowed to vote (thinking of EU nationals who may have been here 10 years etc) if this is a vote about what happens to those living in the UK.

Equally I'd understand allowing UK subjects abroad the right to vote and excluding EU citizens, if this is a matter for UK subjects alone about the future of the UK.

I don't understand not allowing either. All a bit pointless after the event, but just trying to find the logic in either argument.
Not pointless if there is another Referendum or for future General Elections.
 
No not at all, anyone who is British should have a say on the future of THEIR country.
The high court yesterday threw out a legal challenge from a group of ex-pats who said that the result of the referendum should be overturned because they weren’t allowed to vote, I believe the only people who were not resident at the time of the election who were able to vote were forces personnel.
 
My eldest left at 3years old
My youngest was born abroad and has never been back to britain
Both have British passports
My wife was born in nz but has a British passport
Are they British enough to dictate your future life
Assuming they vote on the winning side of a referendum that is
They could theoretically ask British citizens living abroad to give documentation of actual connections with the UK, but practically it would be impossible. I guess most British citizens who have no actual connections with the UK (apart from passport renewal!) would probably not bother to vote anyway.
 
They could theoretically ask British citizens living abroad to give documentation of actual connections with the UK, but practically it would be impossible. I guess most British citizens who have no actual connections with the UK (apart from passport renewal!) would probably not bother to vote anyway.
How many of voting age actually living in the UK couldn't be bothered to vote
Most expats given the chance probably would
The remoaners only needed a million foreigners to beat the brextards
 
In one poll in November. Sadly average of polls not showing that:

https://whatukthinks.org/eu/questions/if-a-second-eu-referendum-were-held-today-how-would-you-vote/

Good place to track it.

Here's another one, conducted this month, which shows a 12% lead for Remain. Individual polls mean little of course, but Kellner maintained that there had been a general shift in recent weeks. If this is borne out by more polls like this one, I would say that it is significant.

https://www.bmgresearch.co.uk/independent-poll-dec-18-brexit/

The article gives notes of caution, pointing out that the shift is coming mainly from people who didn't vote last time, rather than a lot of people changing their minds. But the thing is, this trend is likely to continue surely, with Remain-supporting young people turning 18 and older Brexit supporters 'Leaving'.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: QPR Oslo
Here's another one, conducted this month, which shows a 12% lead for Remain. Individual polls mean little of course, but Kellner maintained that there had been a general shift in recent weeks. If this is borne out by more polls like this one, I would say that it is significant.

https://www.bmgresearch.co.uk/independent-poll-dec-18-brexit/

The article gives notes of caution, pointing out that the shift is coming mainly from people who didn't vote last time, rather than a lot of people changing their minds. But the thing is, this trend is likely to continue surely, with Remain-supporting young people turning 18 and older Brexit supporters 'Leaving'.

I very much hope you're right :-) For me, would need to see a few more polls, consistently over a few months, but can appreciate there appears to be some movement.
 
I have just realised that this is not the first time May has blown out something. I don't know if any of you remember but I posted some time ago that I got invited (by my Tory mates) to have dinner with May and then she was doing an after dinner speech on immigration. She was Home Secretary at the time. I really wanted to go as it had a few top Tories going but sadly I had to cough up £50 and I believe it clashed with a QPR game so I declined. Anyway at the last minute she herself blew it out. So i reckon she does have a track record of this? :1980_boogie_down:

And when we got home we accidentally found the original copy of the bible ... which was nice
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stroller
So let's take your bullshit apart then. "I've always said that we have to give something to the 48%" By playing hardball?. Do you honestly believe that she has not tried this and failed. We all should have backed the Tories to stand their ground. 1 Why? 2 What guarantee would the 48% have had that that by doing so, all of a sudden they would have been compromising? 3 You have a great belief born out of nationalist arrogance which is misplaced that we are stronger than we are and the world listens and obeys when we speak. Wake up man and jump forward two centuries. The only power the UK has wielded over the last 30 years has come from acting as shotgun to the Americans.

I have little doubt that in the last 2 years of rhetoric from TM that she has tried those tactics and crashed into a brick wall. So now you want them to be generous to us after all the insults and accusations from gobshites and politicans alike? What you reap you sew. The Brexit camp poisoned the atmosphere and made it clear that the UK wanted all its cake and now. So come on Johnny Foreigner chop chop.

I've read you several times when you've said that you realise that there will be some pain but you'll be alright because you've planned for your future and will survive and the victims should have as well . How ****ing arrogant and self-centred. Many people never earn enough to be able to save and invest for a rainy day. People on the whole do not choose to be made redundant or lose their jobs. They are victims and there will be plenty among those who are lucky enough to still be in a job who have struggled for years getting steadily worse off under austerity from your Tory government. In case you think I have forgotten your claim that you are not on the Right. I haven't . Either you are kidding yourself that you are open minded or you are lying. Your posts speak volumes.

Therefore I acknowledge what you post, occasionally have agreed with a small part of it but on the whole reject it. It's not a vision for the future which I share and frankly don't really want to be a part of the future as you see it.

Brexiteers were too focused on their big win and generally still think that winning by a 4% margin then holds. Two years have slipped by since then and it’s very clear nationwide that the true feeling does not reflect that result

If it does come again the the vote imo will carry a 20% swing to remain. The remainers choice hasn’t changed it’s solid I believe The Brexiteers contained a massive protest element within and now the problems are clear to all it itself is divided

No deal will not be allowed to go ahead plus still waiting for any Brexiteer to spell out exactly what their vision of the future exactly is

Stay in Europe and reform the concerns from within should be right way to go. The UK can lead the EU from within. It is very clear it could not by being a sovereign nation both NI and Scotland are clear remainers as our all our major cities

Plus we have a system of politics that itself is clear needs change
 
  • Like
Reactions: QPR Oslo
So let's take your bullshit apart then. "I've always said that we have to give something to the 48%" By playing hardball?. Do you honestly believe that she has not tried this and failed. We all should have backed the Tories to stand their ground. 1 Why? 2 What guarantee would the 48% have had that that by doing so, all of a sudden they would have been compromising? 3 You have a great belief born out of nationalist arrogance which is misplaced that we are stronger than we are and the world listens and obeys when we speak. Wake up man and jump forward two centuries. The only power the UK has wielded over the last 30 years has come from acting as shotgun to the Americans.

I have little doubt that in the last 2 years of rhetoric from TM that she has tried those tactics and crashed into a brick wall. So now you want them to be generous to us after all the insults and accusations from gobshites and politicans alike? What you reap you sew. The Brexit camp poisoned the atmosphere and made it clear that the UK wanted all its cake and now. So come on Johnny Foreigner chop chop.

I've read you several times when you've said that you realise that there will be some pain but you'll be alright because you've planned for your future and will survive and the victims should have as well . How ****ing arrogant and self-centred. Many people never earn enough to be able to save and invest for a rainy day. People on the whole do not choose to be made redundant or lose their jobs. They are victims and there will be plenty among those who are lucky enough to still be in a job who have struggled for years getting steadily worse off under austerity from your Tory government. In case you think I have forgotten your claim that you are not on the Right. I haven't . Either you are kidding yourself that you are open minded or you are lying. Your posts speak volumes.

Therefore I acknowledge what you post, occasionally have agreed with a small part of it but on the whole reject it. It's not a vision for the future which I share and frankly don't really want to be a part of the future as you see it.

Let's take this crap one step at a time:
1) I haven't always said we should give something to the 48%, I have been won over to that opinion by reasoned debate.
If you ever acknowledged anything anyone said you'd know that
2) No, I don't believe that May, Ollie Robbins or any of the remainers at the top of the political elite ever tried to negotiate with a tough stance. They never, ever intended to honour the result which is why leave supporting brexit secretaries had to resign.
I believe that a good deal would have been forged by being serious about leaving with no deal and preparing for that outcome from day one.
Instead they all capitulated to ensure the empasse we have today.
3) Yes the EU would have comprimised if they believed we were serious about walking away. They knew we weren't.
4) I am not an arrogant nationalist, I am a patriot. There's a world of difference, but I wouldn't expect you to ever understand that. I do believe that we are a force in the world. We are the world's 5th largest economy and it's financial centre.
5) Please show me where I have said the following that you quoted, "I realise that there will be some pain, but I'll be alright because I've planned for my future so I'll be alright and the victims should have as well".
This is pure bullshit made up by you. I've never said I've planned for the future, other than I was prepared to take a small financial hit for a principal that I believed in. I never called anyone a victim or said that they should have prepared for disaster. I've never believed it would be the Armageddon being predicted by the scaremongering from remain.
If you read what I'd said you'd know this, but you're too arrogant in your own views to do that.
6) It's not my Tory government, I didn't vote for them at the last election.
Again you lie by saying I've said I'm on the right. I've always said I'm centre right.
Again you ignore what people really say in order to slag them off.
So, in conclusion and without further ado.....


Get your ****ing facts right before making personal attacks on me.
Get your head out of your Tory hating arse and see that there are more opinions than just your warped view of this country and the world.
 
Wake up man. We have become an increasingly intolerant society and foreigners of any sort or those with different skin colour are increasingly being harassed. But that's alright. It has nothing to do with Brexit or the surge in nationalism. I really don't expect someone with left wing views to ignore or excuse what's going on. But then again, given what is happening in the Labour party at the moment I suppose I was being naïve.

I would actually say we as a society are more tolerant than you might believe, at least down south (can't talk for up north as never lived there).

So with your Labour Party comment are you insinuating that I’m anti Semitic ? Bit harsh if you are.
Yes I am a member by the way
 
  • Like
Reactions: rangercol
Simon Coveney, Irish spokesman today- "We will not be renegotiating the withdrawal agreement which was hard won...."

Says it all. When May came back with her terrible deal, the EU felt they had won.

May has to go NOW
 
Just as a factoid, it was Brexit supporters on here who started using insults like "muppet" as a form of reasoned debate. Ask Ellers. Just sayin'
Dipper :emoticon-0136-giggl (sorry but that always makes me laugh). I didn't really use 'Muppets' in this debate. From my memory I have used "remoaners", "EuroFreaks", "enemy within". I really only used muppets in football talk. I don't believe I have used it in quite a long time. In fact, after Tramore warned me over this I have refrained from using it personally. So not sure why you used me as an example.
 
Tots of ex Brit's living in nz oz or sa might one day wish to move back
Can they vote too
Is there a time limit
I was thinking this only yesterday after hearing that MP wanting all EU residents living here to be able to vote, all 3 million of them (yeah right). In that case we should include all Australia New Zealand... I know which way they would vote. :emoticon-0105-wink:
 
  • Like
Reactions: kiwiqpr
Simon Coveney, Irish spokesman today- "We will not be renegotiating the withdrawal agreement which was hard won...."

Says it all. When May came back with her terrible deal, the EU felt they had won.

May has to go NOW
I would also remember all of these countries that are making this hard for their own gain? When we get rid of May and get in a strong Brexitier leader in the tables will turn.