90% right, but you're letting your (understandable) bias get the better of you if you're lumping Matip in the the same bracket as Lovren. There were times in that second half that Matip was dealing with every high ball on his own.
But as to Windy - I didn't like heading the ball when I was a full back at schoolboy level: our sports teacher just blasted balls at me for weeks every lunch break, rail hail or shine, until I got over it. No matter what system you use for defending set pieces, you can not legislate for a professional footballer closing his eyes and flinching - cowardly and pathetic. And Firmino was not better for their first - the problem with zonal marking is that the attacker gets to pick who he's up against, and he was hardly likely to match up against Matip or Lovren when, if the cross was good enough, he could run against Bobby or Windy. Bobby didn't even jump - he flinched and gurned an action face circa Goal! in 1972. Lamentable.
Do you really think he never did it in training.. that was the first time he did that?
It is unbelievable to me they put a short are at the front post area. Nonsense

.