Off Topic MAFIA GAME - 19th June

By the same token not having votes in the lynch is a problem .

 

Agreed. I think everyone knows I'll not expect to be defended or defend someone else. Yes, it's a team game but it's also every man for them self when it comes to the lynch

I wouldn't mind being on the sane team as you actually. Not been the case other than when we're both town which doesn't really count

 

True but as I've just said in my last post, I wouldn't vote in line with the team anyway, not until the last few days. This you should know from the last game when we were both mafia

 

yeh but Swan if active could just have voted to save himself - hardly makes him look suspicious
on your general point i agree we just left him out there & hoped for the best otherwise could lose 2.

 

absolutely.

first man in on the lynch IMO. It is a looooonnngg day voting but imo the worst thing you can do is wait to get on a lynch

I'd deffo hang you anyday

Its just purely whats the tactics, whats your lie, your back up lie, your risky strategy and lets go do this.

once my lies won't clash with your lies and we can line up that they pass some muster on the mafia board then whats to talk about offline.

 

He must have taken advice from Tennis

 

Yeah. I'm not saying it's better to have inactives on your team. I'm saying is not always a major problem. Certainly would have helped there.

Best to have a variance imo

 

in fairness Obi ended up the perfect inactive. the rules stated he killed who the Gf said he would.

If bobby had died n1 i would have promoted another mafia to GF due to inactivity and rinsed and repeated.

its hardly ideal. the only possible way would be to have a post counting at end of each day and say end of day 3 no posts i kill you off... something like that.

 

ideally though the difference between sign up and playing would not be so long.

 

Some would post their vote only. We still have some they rarely comment even when active.

 

true but that's self policing too. some folks focus o nthe quiet ones.

Its more of just a means to tidy up somehow.

As gamesmaster i know whos genuinely active and not. and have to say nothing. Ideally I suppose i should have swapped obis role for one of the others roles and just went ahead but the issue really is mafia were down a vote.

Had they not got an ANY on their team i would have had to.

 

Thanks for game MITO was fun whilst it lasted.

Think if I hadn't been whacked then Mafia would have won as my voting for Swanny made me clear non Mafia role and would have made big difference to Mafia early doors. Unfortunately Mafia killed me at same time I was going to join them so we will never know.

Agree best moment in game was ACS and Jonjo's tete a tete especially as wasn't Chippy's fault...this time.

Always fascinating to read the after game thoughts of all those claiming to have "won" the game.

Prefer this type of game where bad guys have facility to hide and helps with "random" roles as opposed to VT roles.

 

Yeah I think that was crucial. I think they should then have had enough votes with witch to win.

 

I wish people would stop giving the mafia credit for killing Groot. I only managed two kills as it was anyway thanks to Tennis!!!

 

lol i know, you can't blame the mafia for killing Trev, it wasn't us, so no own goal there at all

 

As long as i can take the credit for getting Neville killed who cares

 

Just didn't want No Chance getting the credit and if MITO says it was the Mafia that's fine by me.