Which player(s) need to be sold to allow the club to either play in the premiership or challenge for the tittle next season? I personally feel Devit, Dawson and Harper should all leave.
Why Devitt? Dawson is alright. Agree with Harper. McShane, Duke, ***an and Kilbane needs to find another club
Agree with all of the suggestions you made. Devitt- sorry but he is ****, tries hard but no quality! Dawson- need a left back to take his role feel this is his last season as he should end on a high if we get promotion
Devitt can cover on both wings, is determined and will serve as a good utility player. Dawson isn't awful at Championship level and will make decent back-up. Harper would also be decent back-up. Keep 'em all!
i'd like us to keep devitt i think the lads got something hes got abit of pace the odd trick an lets not forget that this is his break through season an hes still a youth,i feel pearson will get the best out of him in the years to come an if he dont progress the NP wil **** him off....we all know he aint shy in doin that. heres who i'd like to see out the door;bullard,mcshane,kilbane,featherstone an olifinjana
Mcshane, Bullard, and Kilbane are taking up the wages of about 20 better players for the future that we could sign so they need to go.
Olafinjana has not shown any class in any game for City to date. (ok, apart from one shot vs Stoke) His second touch is a tackle and he has the turning circle of a double decker bus. There is no way he should be described as class
Hopefully Harper, McShane, Garcia, Cullen, Bullard and Kilbane (and maybe Duke) on permanents. Atkinson and Devitt on loan (I pissed myself on saturday when he was chasing the ball down and was flung into the air like a skydiving Bambi by the LB). Also, Gardner and Ghilas depending on contracts and, in AG's case, who we bring in at CB.
Well first we nee to get rid of the big earners left - McShane, Bullard, Oli, ***an (not as much as the other two but will still be on a quite big wage) and Ghilas. Next goes the deadwood - Duke, Kilbane and possibly Harper if we bring in enough depth into the midfield. A couple of the younger ones could benefit from going out on loan - Cooper (League 1 side), Cairney (League 1 side), Cullen (League 1 side), Oxley (League 2 side)
Atkinson, Duke and ***an have effectively gone already. Bullard, Olofinjana, Ghlias, McShane and Kilbane will top the list of those the club want to offload(a deal for Kilbane may well have been done already). Personally, I think Harper and Mclean aren't good enough, but I can't see them going anywhere(and I'd keep Devitt). I think there's a decent chance that Garcia won't take up his one year offer and I also think someone may come in for Koren. I don't think we'll offer an extended deal to Belaid and we won't offer a deal to Amoo, I haven't managed too see Akpan play yet, so I've no idea about him.
Garcia is a good player to have as he can play anywhere! Belaid has got some prospect so I think deserves a deal. Amoo still to prove himself?
I agree with the above to be honest of the three which the original post sugggests i hope we get rid of none. Dawson to start for me, Devitt stil young and shows promise, Harper good squad player to have for next year- you would be happy to see him fill in for someone without doubt.
