When is too early to judge a player??

Just interested to know the opinions of others...
How many games/seasons should it realistically take before being able to label a new player as useful or useless??

 

Despends on their age. Also some players develop a lot faster than others.

 

I admired Nani since the day he joined United. But people decided criticises him, we all know he wasn't performing well. It takes quite a while for a player to adapt to the Premier League. Obertan will be a start at United next season, mark my word.

 

Nani was just inconsistent where as i've seen nothing at all from Obertan. I agree that he should stay but next season should be his final chance.

 

Does it make you cringe when you see nani go down clutching his face when he clearly hasn't been touched there?
Not wumming,maybe to make a change,just interested

 

A bit. he was fouled though.

 

Nani's always being fouled, that's not something new.

 

Yeah, makes me cringe. Wish he'd cut it out.

 

You have to overreact nowdays however to get a free kick. I remember something about a referee actually saying that to the players. Nani could do it less obviously but as long as its not a dive it isnt that bad.