Transfer Fees for Players

Okay, I'm shamelessly stealing this from the Liverpool board!
Could you please put an honest transfer evaluation on the following players. Don't take into account length of contract or anything like that, just how much you think they're actually worth and what's a fair price based solely on ability and potential.

1 GK Heurelho Gomes
2 DF Alan Hutton
3 MF Gareth Bale
4 DF Younes Kaboul
5 MF David Bentley
6 MF Tom Huddlestone
7 MF Aaron Lennon
8 MF Jermaine Jenas
9 FW Roman Pavlyuchenko
10 FW Robbie Keane
11 MF Rafael van der Vaart
12 MF Wilson Palacios
13 DF William Gallas
14 MF Luka Modrić
15 FW Peter Crouch
16 DF Kyle Naughton
17 FW Giovani dos Santos
18 FW Jermain Defoe
19 DF Sébastien Bassong
20 DF Michael Dawson (vice captain)
21 MF Niko Kranjčar
22 DF Vedran Ćorluka
23 GK Carlo Cudicini
24 MF Jamie O'Hara
25 MF Danny Rose
26 DF Ledley King (captain)
27 GK Ben Alnwick
28 DF Kyle Walker
29 MF Jake Livermore
30 MF Sandro
31 MF Andros Townsend
32 DF Benoît Assou-Ekotto
36 DF Bongani Khumalo
39 DF Jonathan Woodgate
40 MF Steven Pienaar
— GK Brad Friedel

 

One thing to note - there is always two valuations for a player - the value that the world thinks and the value that the selling club thinks!

You say not to take things like length of contract but they do make a bit of difference.

However, to humour you and as it wastes a bit of time....

1 GK Heurelho Gomes £7m
2 DF Alan Hutton £5m
3 MF Gareth Bale £40m+
4 DF Younes Kaboul £8m
5 MF David Bentley £6.5m
6 MF Tom Huddlestone £12m
7 MF Aaron Lennon £14m
8 MF Jermaine Jenas £5m
9 FW Roman Pavlyuchenko £10.5m
10 FW Robbie Keane £4m
11 MF Rafael van der Vaart £17.5m
12 MF Wilson Palacios £8m
13 DF William Gallas £3m
14 MF Luka Modrić £40m+
15 FW Peter Crouch £8m
16 DF Kyle Naughton £7m
17 FW Giovani dos Santos £3m
18 FW Jermain Defoe £12m
19 DF Sébastien Bassong £7m
20 DF Michael Dawson (vice captain) £10m
21 MF Niko Kranjčar £6m
22 DF Vedran Ćorluka £6m
23 GK Carlo Cudicini £2m
24 MF Jamie O'Hara £5.5m
25 MF Danny Rose £8m
26 DF Ledley King (captain) N/A
27 GK Ben Alnwick Free
28 DF Kyle Walker £11m
29 MF Jake Livermore £4m
30 MF Sandro £15m
31 MF Andros Townsend £8m
32 DF Benoît Assou-Ekotto £13m
36 DF Bongani Khumalo ?
39 DF Jonathan Woodgate Free
40 MF Steven Pienaar £6.5m
— GK Brad Friedel N/A


I'm sure my fellow supporters will chip away at those prices, I'm wearing Daniel Levy boots at the mo

 

(prices over-inflated for English players as per media protocol)

 

I agree with Shelf's for the most part, although I'd knock both Kyle's down by £4/5mill and Pienaar up by the same

 

Yeah I was incorporating potential which was not to be included

Amended

 

1 GK Heurelho Gomes - £4m
2 DF Alan Hutton - £4m
3 MF Gareth Bale -£28
4 DF Younes Kaboul -£8m
5 MF David Bentley - £5m
6 MF Tom Huddlestone -£9m
7 MF Aaron Lennon - £15m
8 MF Jermaine Jenas - £5m
9 FW Roman Pavlyuchenko - £13m
10 FW Robbie Keane - £6m
11 MF Rafael van der Vaart - £22m
12 MF Wilson Palacios - £9m
13 DF William Gallas -£7m
14 MF Luka Modrić - £30
15 FW Peter Crouch - £5m
16 DF Kyle Naughton - £3m
17 FW Giovani dos Santos - £8m
18 FW Jermain Defoe - £16m
19 DF Sébastien Bassong - £7m
20 DF Michael Dawson (vice captain) - £11m
21 MF Niko Kranjčar - £10m
22 DF Vedran Ćorluka - £8m
23 GK Carlo Cudicini - £500,000
24 MF Jamie O'Hara - £5m
25 MF Danny Rose - £12m
26 DF Ledley King (captain) Hard to put a price on him...maybe £6m because on injury but a fully fit king would be worth £22m-ish
27 GK Ben Alnwick - £700,000 Still young
28 DF Kyle Walker - £10m
29 MF Jake Livermore £3m
30 MF Sandro - £23m Because of his potential
31 MF Andros Townsend - £8m
32 DF Benoît Assou-Ekotto - £10m
36 DF Bongani Khumalo - £4m
39 DF Jonathan Woodgate - £2m Like King would be worth about £15m if fully fit
40 MF Steven Pienaar - £5m

If they all had at least a year or two left on their contracts, this would be my opinion

Comes to about £335m

 

1 GK Heurelho Gomes £6m
2 DF Alan Hutton £A Wispa bar and a pack of Quavers
3 MF Gareth Bale £30m
4 DF Younes Kaboul £10m
5 MF David Bentley £4m
6 MF Tom Huddlestone £12m
7 MF Aaron Lennon £12m
8 MF Jermaine Jenas £4m
9 FW Roman Pavlyuchenko £14m
10 FW Robbie Keane £8m
11 MF Rafael van der Vaart £22m
12 MF Wilson Palacios £7m
13 DF William Gallas £6m
14 MF Luka Modrić £34m
15 FW Peter Crouch £8m
16 DF Kyle Naughton £4m
17 FW Giovani dos Santos £5m
18 FW Jermain Defoe £10m
19 DF Sébastien Bassong £7m
20 DF Michael Dawson (vice captain) £10m
21 MF Niko Kranjčar £9m
22 DF Vedran Ćorluka £6m
23 GK Carlo Cudicini £3m
24 MF Jamie O'Hara £2m
25 MF Danny Rose £6
26 DF Ledley King (captain) Would have to be a free
27 GK Ben Alnwick £A firm handshake
28 DF Kyle Walker £9
29 MF Jake Livermore £4
30 MF Sandro £14
31 MF Andros Townsend £3
32 DF Benoît Assou-Ekotto £14
36 DF Bongani Khumalo ?
39 DF Jonathan Woodgate Free
40 MF Steven Pienaar £5
— GK Brad Friedel ...

I'm quite gald I'm not Levy... I fear I'm undervaluing most of them.

 

Incidently Ubiq, are you doing this on every team's board?

Would surely be easier to take the FM valuation?

 

Solidspur, are you saying Hutton is just worth the lunch he eats every day?

 

A scotch egg and a deep fried mars bar more like.

 

Followed up by a pint of Whiskey

 

And then a kicking for his 'da!

 

Doesn't that technically count as training, a bit of cardiovascular?

 

1 GK Heurelho Gomes 7-9m
2 DF Alan Hutton 4-6m
3 MF Gareth Bale 40m+
4 DF Younes Kaboul 8m
5 MF David Bentley 7-9m
6 MF Tom Huddlestone 12-15m
7 MF Aaron Lennon 15-18m
8 MF Jermaine Jenas 4-7m
9 FW Roman Pavlyuchenko 10-12m
10 FW Robbie Keane 4-7m
11 MF Rafael van der Vaart 18-24m
12 MF Wilson Palacios 5-7.5m
13 DF William Gallas 6m
14 MF Luka Modrić 50m+
15 FW Peter Crouch 8-12m
16 DF Kyle Naughton 3-5m
17 FW Giovani dos Santos 6.5-8m
18 FW Jermain Defoe 10-14m
19 DF Sébastien Bassong 5-7.5m
20 DF Michael Dawson (vice captain) 10-14m
21 MF Niko Kranjčar 6-9m
22 DF Vedran Ćorluka 6-8m
23 GK Carlo Cudicini 1m
24 MF Jamie O'Hara 4-7m
25 MF Danny Rose 4-8m
26 DF Ledley King (captain) N/A
27 GK Ben Alnwick Please, take him away!!!
28 DF Kyle Walker 6m
29 MF Jake Livermore 2-4m
30 MF Sandro 20m+
31 MF Andros Townsend 4-6m
32 DF Benoît Assou-Ekotto 8-12m
36 DF Bongani Khumalo 2-3.5m
39 DF Jonathan Woodgate N/A
40 MF Steven Pienaar 7-9m
— GK Brad Friedel N/A