Cherry-picking one game in order to prove a thesis is not a logical or scientific approach. We all do it at times, of course, because none of us is as logical or scientific as we like to think we are.
Match Day Thread Today's Games
- Thread starter ThaiCanary
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
Except those who place great faith in statistics or the hyperboles of a single BBC reporter who may have his own prejudices.
A 6.6 score indicates a satisfactory performance but nothing to shout about, though Hanley did win more aerial contests than any other player. At 6.78, he's Scotland's second highest player over 3 Nations League games.
Last edited:
I would suggest that a players value to a squad should never be judged on their performance in a single game or indeed half . All players have good & bad periods of play whether that be a series of games or part of a game. Whilst often the devil is in the detail that does not mean the bigger picture should be ignored. Only highlighting negative points whilst ignoring any good ones makes a person biased and therefore their contribution less valid. Consistency over a sustained period of time is much more valuable than the odd fantastic performance, particularly in someone in a leadership position.
2-2 now as Rowe has just scored the second equaliser after Cantwell's goal earlier. Most players got 30 minute stints by the end.
Norwich City XI: Gunn (McGovern 46), Byram (Aarons 31, Mumba 61), Zimmermann (Hanley 61), Gibson (Tomkinson 61), McCallum (Giannoulis 61), Sorensen (Gibbs 61), Lees-Melou (McLean 61), Cantwell (Sinani 61), Dowell (Hernandez 31, Tzolis 61), Rachica (Springett 31, Rowe 61), Sargent (Hugill 31, Pukki 61)
You must log in or register to see images
Norwich City XI: Gunn (McGovern 46), Byram (Aarons 31, Mumba 61), Zimmermann (Hanley 61), Gibson (Tomkinson 61), McCallum (Giannoulis 61), Sorensen (Gibbs 61), Lees-Melou (McLean 61), Cantwell (Sinani 61), Dowell (Hernandez 31, Tzolis 61), Rachica (Springett 31, Rowe 61), Sargent (Hugill 31, Pukki 61)
Last edited:
Finished 2-2. Good result as this is Regenburg's last pre-season match so they're well ahead of us on fitness and training. Great for Jon Rowe to get his first goal for the senior team and as Dunc says Cantwell seems to be working hard to get back in the side.
Match Report:
https://www.canaries.co.uk/content/city-come-from-behind-twice-to-draw-in-germany-friendly
Match Report:
https://www.canaries.co.uk/content/city-come-from-behind-twice-to-draw-in-germany-friendly
Last edited:
DS said he has been impressed with Sinani since he’s come back from loan so I believe he will be staying with the club this season
For those who haven't seen Smith's comments on players:
“It's also been important for the loan players. I’ve been really impressed with Danel, who’s been on loan at Huddersfield all season. He’s got a really good picture when the ball arrives, plays a one-two touch really well and has a really good delivery from set pieces. Onel has made his mark in training already, as well as Jordan (Hugill) and Sam (McCallum), who’ve adjusted really well to the pace of the squad. Isaac Hayden trained the first week with us but he got a little bit of swelling on the knee, so we were a bit concerned about that and we're just resting him at the moment. The international guys will have a little bit more work to do to catch up, but they’ve had a shorter break than the others.”
Thanks RER, apologies I wrote this and then saw you had quoted the above on a different thread.
It’s also worth pointing out hat DS said he deliberately brought them in to the game tired and stressed to see how they would cope against a team much further raking in their pre season.
And test their decision making when they are tired and stressed.
Sounds like the average day at work for most people
Anyone else expecting (should our squad remain as is + Sara) our line up at Cardiff to look like this...
Krul
Aarons Hanley Gibson Giannoulis
Lees-Melou Mclean
Sargent Dowell Rashica
Pukki
??
Hayden and Sara both recovering from injury. I have a gut feeling he will go with what he knows. Personally id give Sinani and even Cantwell ago if they continue to impress, but just cant see Smith going straight in with changes unless Hayden is fit.
Krul
Aarons Hanley Gibson Giannoulis
Lees-Melou Mclean
Sargent Dowell Rashica
Pukki
??
Hayden and Sara both recovering from injury. I have a gut feeling he will go with what he knows. Personally id give Sinani and even Cantwell ago if they continue to impress, but just cant see Smith going straight in with changes unless Hayden is fit.
If Cantwell stays I think DS will start him for the first 5, he is a confidence player. Sargent is coming back from an injury, so I wouldn't expect him to start. Sinani makes a good case for coming straight into the team as well. Rashica being given the number 7 shirt seems like a bit of a statement so I can't see him being dropped. Gunn or Krul is anyone's guess at the moment, my choice would be Gunn.