Off Topic The Politics Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

Should the UK remain a part of the EU or leave?

  • Stay in

    Votes: 56 47.9%
  • Get out

    Votes: 61 52.1%

  • Total voters
    117
  • Poll closed .
The fact is this was Trump's withdrawal. Admittedly it seems to have been handled disastrously by Biden, but who's to say it would have been different under Trump. The unforeseen element seems to have been the utter capitulation of Afghan government forces, giving no time for an orderly withdrawal. Trump releasing 5,000 imprisoned Taliban fighters won't have helped in this regard, though.

Biden agrees with Trump in that it's not America's job to be the world's policeman. He stood on the platform of carrying out Trump's withdrawal, so this shouldn't have been a surprise. He will be judged by the US electorate on the success or otherwise of his domestic policies - with which he seems to be doing rather well - not foreign policy.

Oh, and Biden looked at his watch - really? Trump refused to go to a memorial for fallen servicemen because he thought they were 'losers'.

It was Trump's withdrawal, and there are arguments for and against leaving Afghanistan. But Trump was a negotiator and he was doing deals with the Taliban. And he listened to professional advice, including military.

Biden did none of these things and could not have made more of a mess if he tried. His approval rating in the US on this is 34%

Biden's approval rating at home is sinking like a stone too. His record on Coronavirus and the economy is poor, according to CNN. Kamala Harris is even more unpopular.

The sooner he goes the better - and I don't want Trump back either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rangercol
It was Trump's withdrawal, and there are arguments for and against leaving Afghanistan. But Trump was a negotiator and he was doing deals with the Taliban. And he listened to professional advice, including military.

Biden did none of these things and could not have made more of a mess if he tried. His approval rating in the US on this is 34%

Biden's approval rating at home is sinking like a stone too. His record on Coronavirus and the economy is poor, according to CNN. Kamala Harris is even more unpopular.

The sooner he goes the better - and I don't want Trump back either.

Biden's overall approval rating has just fallen into a negative - 47.5% against 47.2%

How Popular Is Joe Biden? | FiveThirtyEight

Trump's rating was consistently highly negative.

How Popular Is Donald Trump? | FiveThirtyEight

We'll see how Biden progresses, but I suspect that the American public care more about domestic issues than foreign policy.
 
Biden's overall approval rating has just fallen into a negative - 47.5% against 47.2%

How Popular Is Joe Biden? | FiveThirtyEight

Trump's rating was consistently highly negative.

How Popular Is Donald Trump? | FiveThirtyEight

We'll see how Biden progresses, but I suspect that the American public care more about domestic issues than foreign policy.

Latest on Biden's ratings at home from CNN:

https://edition.cnn.com/2021/08/28/politics/biden-afghanistan-polling-analysis/index.html
 
Biden's overall approval rating has just fallen into a negative - 47.5% against 47.2%

How Popular Is Joe Biden? | FiveThirtyEight

Trump's rating was consistently highly negative.

How Popular Is Donald Trump? | FiveThirtyEight

We'll see how Biden progresses, but I suspect that the American public care more about domestic issues than foreign policy.

Wasn't it Biden that said ‘**** That’ when asked about America’s obligations to the Afghans back in 2010 ?
 
The fact is this was Trump's withdrawal. Admittedly it seems to have been handled disastrously by Biden, but who's to say it would have been different under Trump. The unforeseen element seems to have been the utter capitulation of Afghan government forces, giving no time for an orderly withdrawal. Trump releasing 5,000 imprisoned Taliban fighters won't have helped in this regard, though.

Biden agrees with Trump in that it's not America's job to be the world's policeman. He stood on the platform of carrying out Trump's withdrawal, so this shouldn't have been a surprise. He will be judged by the US electorate on the success or otherwise of his domestic policies - with which he seems to be doing rather well - not foreign policy.

Oh, and Biden looked at his watch - really? Trump refused to go to a memorial for fallen servicemen because he thought they were 'losers'.
It’s a tallest dwarf battle between Trump and Biden and I don’t really care about the winner.

But my Democrat friends in the US tell me that Biden is proving pretty poor all round, and Harris as VP even worse. COVID is just about completely out of control, inflation is rising sharply and hundreds of thousand of immigrants are entering the country illegally (supposedly Harris’ special brief’). Lots of resignations from the core teams, especially Harris’, who is apparently something of a bully and not very talented. As we know, this does not in any way damage her credentials to be the next president.

But we should be grateful to Biden, he deflects away from the sharp exposure of the true dimensions of ‘sovereign, independent, world player’ Great Britain and the way we have had to meekly follow nasty Joe’s lead. Seems only a few ex military Tory MPs want to make an issue of our culpability, and I salute them for it.

Meanwhile lots of weird empty threats/promises from Johnson and Raab to the Taliban - you’d better not harbour terrorists or……we’ll ask the Yanks to drone attack you? We won’t let you have an embassy in the U.K.? Chinese burn? Flicked with a wet towel? Gang raped by Old Etonians?

Raab busy with his usual bollocks this morning. Apparently there are some British citizens left in Afghanistan but ‘only in the low hundreds’. So that’s ok then. Government last week said about 250 citizens and a thousand others who have strong links to the U.K.s activities in the country and are therefore at risk from the Taliban are still there. Other sources, like the agencies that employed these people, put the figure at 7 to 9,000. Dom is still pondering the strategy to get them out, other than asking the Taliban nicely.

He also, rather casually, threw the intelligence services under the bus, saying that there was no intel predicting the rapid collapse of the Afghan military. Although others have claimed that Biden simply ignored strong advice that this would happen. So either we don’t share intelligence with the US, or our intelligence was just ****, or Raab is lying. None of which are great options.

Finally he had a quick windmill at those who have criticised his and the Foreign Office’s handling of this farce. Much of this criticism has come from within government, notably the Ministry of Defence. Raab reckons that the critics weren’t credible as they only had a ‘peripheral’ role in what was going on. Strange that, I thought the 18 year old soldiers who ended up processing evacuees at the airport worked for the MoD. The Foreign Office had got its staff (you know, the ones who are ‘skilled’ at processing visas) out as quickly as possible, the ambassador apparently had to be told to stay in Kabul.

Above all Dom didn’t spend any time on the beach during this episode. Honest.
 
Last edited:
It’s a tallest dwarf battle between Trump and Biden and I don’t really care about the winner.

But my Democrat friends in the US tell me that Biden is proving pretty poor all round, and Harris as VP even worse. COVID is just about completely out of control, inflation is rising sharply and hundreds of thousand of immigrants are entering the country illegally (supposedly Harris’ special brief’). Lots of resignations from the core teams, especially Harris’, who is apparently something of a bully and not very talented. As we know, this does not in any way damage her credentials to be the next president.

But we should be grateful to Biden, he deflects away from the sharp exposure of the true dimensions of ‘sovereign, independent, world player’ Great Britain and the way we have had to meekly follow nasty Joe’s lead. Seems only a few ex military Tory MPs want to make an issue of our culpability, and I salute them for it.

Meanwhile lots of weird empty threats/promises from Johnson and Raab to the Taliban - you’d better not harbour terrorists or……we’ll ask the Yanks to drone attack you? We won’t let you have an embassy in the U.K.? Chinese burn? Flicked with a wet towel? Gang raped by Old Etonians?

Raab busy with his usual bollocks this morning. Apparently there are some British citizens left in Afghanistan but ‘only in the low hundreds’. So that’s ok then. Government last week said about 250 citizens and a thousand others who have strong links to the U.K.s activities in the country and are therefore at risk from the Taliban. Other sources, like the agencies that employed these people, put the figure at 7 to 9,000. Dom is still pondering the strategy to get them out, other than asking the Taliban nicely.

He also, rather casually, threw the intelligence services under the bus, saying that there was no intel predicting the rapid collapse of the Afghan military. Although others have claimed that Biden simply ignored strong advice that this would happen. So either we don’t share intelligence with the US, or our intelligence was just ****, or Raab is lying. None of which are great options.

Finally he had a quick windmill at those who have criticised his and the Foreign Office’s handling of this farce. Much of this criticism has come from within government, notably the Ministry of Defence. Raab reckons that the critics weren’t credible as they only had a ‘peripheral’ role in what was going on. Strange that, I thought the 18 year old soldiers who ended up processing evacuees at the airport worked for the MoD. The Foreign Office had got its staff (you know, the ones who are ‘skilled’ at processing visas) out as quickly as possible, the ambassador apparently had to be told to stay in Kabul.

Above all Dom didn’t spend any time on the beach during this episode. Honest.

Brilliant post.

Biden/Trump/Obama…..the same sides to the rotten penny.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kiwiqpr and sb_73
It’s a tallest dwarf battle between Trump and Biden and I don’t really care about the winner.

But my Democrat friends in the US tell me that Biden is proving pretty poor all round, and Harris as VP even worse. COVID is just about completely out of control, inflation is rising sharply and hundreds of thousand of immigrants are entering the country illegally (supposedly Harris’ special brief’). Lots of resignations from the core teams, especially Harris’, who is apparently something of a bully and not very talented. As we know, this does not in any way damage her credentials to be the next president.

But we should be grateful to Biden, he deflects away from the sharp exposure of the true dimensions of ‘sovereign, independent, world player’ Great Britain and the way we have had to meekly follow nasty Joe’s lead. Seems only a few ex military Tory MPs want to make an issue of our culpability, and I salute them for it.

Meanwhile lots of weird empty threats/promises from Johnson and Raab to the Taliban - you’d better not harbour terrorists or……we’ll ask the Yanks to drone attack you? We won’t let you have an embassy in the U.K.? Chinese burn? Flicked with a wet towel? Gang raped by Old Etonians?

Raab busy with his usual bollocks this morning. Apparently there are some British citizens left in Afghanistan but ‘only in the low hundreds’. So that’s ok then. Government last week said about 250 citizens and a thousand others who have strong links to the U.K.s activities in the country and are therefore at risk from the Taliban. Other sources, like the agencies that employed these people, put the figure at 7 to 9,000. Dom is still pondering the strategy to get them out, other than asking the Taliban nicely.

He also, rather casually, threw the intelligence services under the bus, saying that there was no intel predicting the rapid collapse of the Afghan military. Although others have claimed that Biden simply ignored strong advice that this would happen. So either we don’t share intelligence with the US, or our intelligence was just ****, or Raab is lying. None of which are great options.

Finally he had a quick windmill at those who have criticised his and the Foreign Office’s handling of this farce. Much of this criticism has come from within government, notably the Ministry of Defence. Raab reckons that the critics weren’t credible as they only had a ‘peripheral’ role in what was going on. Strange that, I thought the 18 year old soldiers who ended up processing evacuees at the airport worked for the MoD. The Foreign Office had got its staff (you know, the ones who are ‘skilled’ at processing visas) out as quickly as possible, the ambassador apparently had to be told to stay in Kabul.

Above all Dom didn’t spend any time on the beach during this episode. Honest.
Left all those people behind but we got some cats and dogs out so it's ok
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wherever
It wasn't me that said that.

It's true though, inasmuch as he's not a white supremacist neo-fascist like his predecessor.

With respect Strolls, I didn’t say you did.
However that was the general feeling being put out by media luvvies.
Whereas the fact is, he was always gonna be as big a **** as his predecessor and the one before that.
I think, in my opinion, only Sanders ‘might’ have been different…..sadly we’ll never know
 
  • Like
Reactions: BobbyD
With respect Strolls, I didn’t say you did.
However that was the general feeling being put out by media luvvies.
Whereas the fact is, he was always gonna be as big a **** as his predecessor and the one before that.
I think, in my opinion, only Sanders ‘might’ have been different…..sadly we’ll never know

I hold no particular candle for Biden, and think that his abandonment of the Afghan people is pretty reprehensible, but it would have been the same under Trump.

I don't think he's anything like as big a **** as his predecessor in pretty much every other respect, though.
 
https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/biden-approval-rating/

Will be interesting to see how fast this falls. There surely isn't any coming back from this. All eyes on the Republican primaries now. Set up perfectly for a Trump comeback, isn't it?

I posted that chart earlier. The fall doesn't seem that dramatic to me, and is certainly recoverable.

Did you see Trump's chart?

After Trump's collusion with the attackers of the Capitol he should be disbarred from standing again.
 
Brilliant post.

Biden/Trump/Obama…..the same sides to the rotten penny.
They are products of the system they exist within, and ours is no better. Complex unwritten frameworks of favours and compromises with the sole purpose of avoiding radical change which alters where power and wealth sits, in exchange for a promise of a vote every few years and some kind of physical ‘security’ which is relative (hey you’re safer than a Syrian aren’t you?) and where values and integrity are just proxy phrases for ‘business as usual’. Trump never understood this, and I suspect Johnson doesn’t either, they believe that they are untouchable forces of nature and can do whatever they like, and they might damage the old status quo seriously and probably not in any intentional way as a result. Might not be a bad thing, as long as they end up personally crushed and humiliated.

Having said that whenever I see/hear the smug, arrogant, ‘I did everything right and still know better than you lot’ faces of Blair and Obama, I want to smash them in. And pretty obviously Clinton and Cameron are basically crooks.
 
Last edited:
I posted that chart earlier. The fall doesn't seem that dramatic to me, and is certainly recoverable.

Did you see Trump's chart?

After Trump's collusion with the attackers of the Capitol he should be disbarred from standing again.

Sorry, missed that! I think that fall might just be the start when people realise there are between 100-200 US citizens who wanted to get out but haven't yet. We'll see I guess.
 
I hold no particular candle for Biden, and think that his abandonment of the Afghan people is pretty reprehensible, but it would have been the same under Trump.

I don't think he's anything like as big a **** as his predecessor in pretty much every other respect, though.

Obama wasn’t that great to be fair…..however I take your point on Trump probably being the worse of a terrible bunch.