Off Topic The Politics Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

Should the UK remain a part of the EU or leave?

  • Stay in

    Votes: 56 47.9%
  • Get out

    Votes: 61 52.1%

  • Total voters
    117
  • Poll closed .
No it’s just a theoretical, but probably reasonably accurate, and probably based on silly assumptions like no young people dying, but it’s just a bit of fun.

Say Leave won by 1m votes, “the elderly” voted 80% Leave and every day 1000 of them die. Every day 600 more Leave voters are disappearing than Remain so in 1667 days Remain is the majority. I think the one done straight after the referendum took into account teenagers turning 18 and voting the same way as the youngest age group.
that makes sense but what about new younger people wanting Brexit (funnily I did read an article regarding new voters) or the remainers that are middle-aged and died? You are right though, it is a bit of fun, it is just alarming when I see all the responses from people (at the bottom of the article). Funnily I thought it was only 'leave' voters that were thick.
 
that makes sense but what about new younger people wanting Brexit (funnily I did read an article regarding new voters) or the remainers that are middle-aged and died? You are right though, it is a bit of fun, it is just alarming when I see all the responses from people (at the bottom of the article). Funnily I thought it was only 'leave' voters that were thick.
We are all thick mate for believing this bullshit
 
Let me work that through.

The Labour Party, supports a Brexit but staying in the Single Market - I think, but I might be wrong. Or is it just the Customs Union?

The official Tory position is Chequers, which no one from any party likes except the Cabinet.

It’s looking increasingly likely that there will be an agreement with the EU, based on Chequers but probably with more concessions.

This deal, which no one likes, will be voted on in Parliament. To abstain en masse on that vote seems to be a dereliction of duty - the Labour MPs should be representing their constituents, either they reluctantly think having any kind of agreement is better than none or they are prepared to go for a no deal unplanned Brexit, presumably in the hope of forcing an election and then going back to the EU. Abstaining is essentially the same as voting for, as Ellers says there will probably be enough Tories who follow the whip.

It’s a pretty transparent way of trying to dodge responsibility on the biggest issue for decades and the electorate will see through it. Which is why I think Corbyn will announce Labour support for a referendum on the deal at the party conference. He doesn’t want one, but Momentum and the unions do.

There must be a fairly strong possibility that, whatever the official party line is, Labour MPs from Remain constituencies (or those that feel strongly enough that any Brexit is damaging to the country) will vote against May's deal. If they do, and the remainder follow the suggested party line that they should abstain - on the basis that, whilst the referendum result should be respected, this is not the right deal - May could lose the vote. In that scenario, who would be seen to have brought May down, the Tory ERG group or Labour Blairite rebels?

As to dereliction of duty, some might say that supporting any legislation that you believe to be damaging to the country is exactly that.
 
Last edited:
Let me work that through.

The Labour Party, supports a Brexit but staying in the Single Market - I think, but I might be wrong. Or is it just the Customs Union?

The official Tory position is Chequers, which no one from any party likes except the Cabinet.

It’s looking increasingly likely that there will be an agreement with the EU, based on Chequers but probably with more concessions.

This deal, which no one likes, will be voted on in Parliament. To abstain en masse on that vote seems to be a dereliction of duty - the Labour MPs should be representing their constituents, either they reluctantly think having any kind of agreement is better than none or they are prepared to go for a no deal unplanned Brexit, presumably in the hope of forcing an election and then going back to the EU. Abstaining is essentially the same as voting for, as Ellers says there will probably be enough Tories who follow the whip.

It’s a pretty transparent way of trying to dodge responsibility on the biggest issue for decades and the electorate will see through it. Which is why I think Corbyn will announce Labour support for a referendum on the deal at the party conference. He doesn’t want one, but Momentum and the unions do.
Good post Sb. :emoticon-0148-yes:
 
As to dereliction of duty, some might say that supporting any legislation that you know to be damaging to the country is exactly that.
That fine Stoller but no one knows what effect Brexit will have.
For every doom and gloom forecast there is a response and vice versa. If Labour MP's in Brexit areas don't support things then they will be losing their seat at the next election.
I keep hearing caller after caller on radio phone in's saying if tMP's don't support their vote they will not vote again.
This brings me onto a bigger issue for a later date (if my local MP doesn't support what I voted for).
 
Looks like post-Brexit, immigration will target highly skilled workers who want to come here. We won't be forced to those we don't need from the EU, and will not discriminate against Australians, Indonesians and South Africans in favour of Romanians and Bulgarians. Good.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kiwiqpr and ELLERS
There must be a fairly strong possibility that, whatever the official party line is, Labour MPs from Remain constituencies (or those that feel strongly enough that any Brexit is damaging to the country) will vote against May's deal. If they do, and the remainder follow the suggested party line that they should abstain - on the basis that, whilst the referendum result should be respected, this is not the right deal - May could lose the vote. In that scenario, who would be seen to have brought May down, the Tory ERG group or Labour Blairite rebels?

As to dereliction of duty, some might say that supporting any legislation that you know to be damaging to the country is exactly that.
Fair enough Strolls, I am just a little tired of the gaming that these endless factions on all sides are indulging in.

Even if Chequers is a **** deal from the perspective of hard line Brexiters and pure Remainers, I respect Mark Carney’s view that we will see a significant positive economic bounce on the back of it. I’d like any deal and the implementation period and bloody quickly rather than another incredibly divisive referendum or an election in which I would be forced to spoil my ballot paper. And if it wasn’t for the DU ****ing P I think we would have got one already.
 
Gove’s department has released a short video to support his Agriculture Bill, showing the rural idyll the UK will become post Brexit. It contains footage of lovely farm scenes. Unfortunately they were shot in Slovenia and Germany.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kiwiqpr
Looks like post-Brexit, immigration will target highly skilled workers who want to come here. We won't be forced to those we don't need from the EU, and will not discriminate against Australians, Indonesians and South Africans in favour of Romanians and Bulgarians. Good.

I have a US friend, highly educated and qualified that wanted to stay and work here but was unable to. She went back to the US. Yesterday I passed a traveler site with about 6-7 mobile homes full in Eastern European families. They had enough rubbish piled up at outside their place to fill a dustbin truck (I am not joking). This is not sounding racist but I will be glad when we will be able to pick and choose who we need for this country.
 
Gove’s department has released a short video to support his Agriculture Bill, showing the rural idyll the UK will become post Brexit. It contains footage of lovely farm scenes. Unfortunately they were shot in Slovenia and Germany.
That's because we don't have any farms.
 
I have a US friend, highly educated and qualified that wanted to stay and work here but was unable to. She went back to the US. Yesterday I passed a traveler site with about 6-7 mobile homes full in Eastern European families. They had enough rubbish piled up at outside their place to fill a dustbin truck (I am not joking). This is not sounding racist but I will be glad when we will be able to pick and choose who we need for this country.

This has been part of the problem, Ellers. We can now become a truly global marketplace in London and other UK cities, able to attract the best and brightest from around the world, rather than being an adjunct to a troubled project with restrictive practices.
 
This has been part of the problem, Ellers. We can now become a truly global marketplace in London and other UK cities, able to attract the best and brightest from around the world, rather than being an adjunct to a troubled project with restrictive practices.

There hasn't been anything stopping us from letting in the brightest and best from anywhere has there? Apart from unnecessary and artificial caps of course.
 
This has been part of the problem, Ellers. We can now become a truly global marketplace in London and other UK cities, able to attract the best and brightest from around the world, rather than being an adjunct to a troubled project with restrictive practices.
Agree mate. Post Brexit I can see us pushing forward without all the EU restrictions holding us back.
We should do what France does. They doesn't let English work there unless in a highly skilled job and can speak fluent French...oops they are an EU member and I thought it was us that were protectionist? <doh>
 
Agree mate. Post Brexit I can see us pushing forward without all the EU restrictions holding us back.
We should do what France does. They doesn't let English work there unless in a highly skilled job and can speak fluent French...oops they are an EU member and I thought it was us that were protectionist? <doh>
How come France can do that while in the EU yet some think we can't? We can already attract the brightest etc we can also stop whoever we choose to at our borders. What makes anyone think that leaving the EU will change any of that?? Bizarre
 
There hasn't been anything stopping us from letting in the brightest and best from anywhere has there? Apart from unnecessary and artificial caps of course.

The restrictions in the UK on non-EU migrants are necessarily more severe because of the automatic right of EU citizens to come here. There's only some many incomers we can take. The UK population has been spiralling upwards with all the pressures on public services etc.

Much fairer to have a level playing field. We need to keep immigration numbers under control, and when we admit someone, we want them to make a material contribution to our society.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ELLERS
How come France can do that while in the EU yet some think we can't? We can already attract the brightest etc we can also stop whoever we choose to at our borders. What makes anyone think that leaving the EU will change any of that?? Bizarre
So how do you stop people from the EU entering the country?
The fact is bob is that we can't stop EU members entering. doesn't even matter if they have a criminal record.
 
So how do you stop people from the EU entering the country?
The fact is bob is that we can't stop EU members entering. doesn't even matter if they have a criminal record.

We've always had the right to ask EU citizens to leave after 3 months if they weren't in work or otherwise self-sufficient. We just haven't bothered to check.
 
We've always had the right to ask EU citizens to leave after 3 months if they weren't in work or otherwise self-sufficient. We just haven't bothered to check.
Well, hopefully things will be different post Brexit. people who come here should be vetted and working (or at least be able to support themselves. Not being inhumane here but we have plenty of problems with UK citizens that need sorting first.
We need to get our own house in order and then worry about others. Plenty of homeless, sick, poor people here to deal with.