The Fifa12 Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
RickieLambertsGoldenBoot

RickieLambertsGoldenBoot

Well-Known Member
Feb 24, 2011
6,391
37
48
This is a thread for FIFA fans.


Once again it is that time of year. On 30th September FIFA 12 is released so what ratings do we think we'll get as a team and individual players.

Or what would you like.

For me:

Davis 69
Bialkowski 64

Richardson 68
Butterfield 65
Fonte 72
Martin 67
Seabourne 63
Jaidi 66
Harding 68
Dickson 65
Fox 71 (yet to judge)

De Ridder 72
Chaplow 68
Hammond 71
Schneiderlin 72
Cork 74
Holmes 67
Lallana 75 (at least plus 5 star skills and weak foot etc)

Barnard 71
Connolly 70
Guly 70
Lambert 73 (80+ FK accuracy)


They are my own opinions.

Obviously we won't know until it comes out but I think some of those scores I gave were fair.

Opinions...

COYR!
 
i'd give martin and seabourne 65 or 66, but martin with a lot of potential to improve. maybe give connolly a higher rating, but otherwise i'd agree
 
Rickie Lamberts Golden Boot said:
This is a thread for FIFA fans.


Once again it is that time of year. On 30th September FIFA 12 is released so what ratings do we think we'll get as a team and individual players.

Or what would you like.

For me:

Davis 69
Bialkowski 64

Richardson 68
Butterfield 65
Fonte 72
Martin 67
Seabourne 63
Jaidi 66
Harding 68
Dickson 65
Fox 71 (yet to judge)

De Ridder 72
Chaplow 68
Hammond 71
Schneiderlin 72
Cork 74
Holmes 67
Lallana 75 (at least plus 5 star skills and weak foot etc)

Barnard 71
Connolly 70
Guly 70
Lambert 73 (80+ FK accuracy)


They are my own opinions.

Obviously we won't know until it comes out but I think some of those scores I gave were fair.

Opinions...

COYR!
Click to expand...

I think that most of them are a couple of points to high. Although I agree, I think EA wont. For the most part I think you can take the ratings we had on Fifa 11 and add about 5-7 points, maybe 10 for players like Fonte, Lambert and Lallana.
 
Don't forget that Chris Brunt was rated at 58 last year, having just been one of West Brom's best players (2009/10) as they won promotion to the Premier League. You can never rely on EA to give fair or accurate ratings.
 
The first number is what i'd like and think is fair the secound is what I think we will get.


Davis 70 67
Bialkowski 65 63/4

Richardson 68 65
Butterfield 65 64
Fonte 74 69
Martin 68 62
Seabourne 65 63
Jaidi 66 66
Harding 69 66
Dickson 64 62
Fox ?? ??

De Ridder 69/70 (with 5 star skills) 67 (with sadly 3 star skills)
Chaplow 68 65
Hammond 71 66
Schneiderlin 73 67
Cork 72 70 (probably less now he's not a chelsea player)
Holmes 65 63
Lallana 77 (as far as I'm aware the cap for championship players is 75 though.) (at least plus 5 star skills and weak foot etc) 73 (will be 3-4 star skills GRR)

Barnard 69 67
Connolly 72 67
Guly 71 (With at least 4 star skills and flair, but low consistency) 69
Lambert 74 (80+ FK accuracy, 85+ penaltys) 72

This is also being very optimistic, I think we will be 3 star at best with very average and ****e ratings due to us being newcomers to the league, although I will say that I will just edit the players until they are acceptable.

One final comment, Chamberlains rating if he had stayed with us 70 now he's at arsenal 76 with an update by christmas making him 80 I'd put money on that one.
 
"as far as I'm aware the cap for championship players is 75 though"

Bellamy was above, Taarabt was 75 or 76 I *think*...
 
The only players we'll have above 70 are Cork, Fonte and Lallana, even then it's unlikely.
 
EA do know research, they just follow the media hype...
For example I bet Chamberlain will now be 75+

Lallana is ten times better than him.

I agree some of my ratings are a little high but if I don't like them I'll alter them slightly so that it is more realistic to the player...
 
JDub Saint said:
The only players we'll have above 70 are Cork, Fonte and Lallana, even then it's unlikely.
Click to expand...

Think it might be worth chucking in lambert to that list seeing as for fifa 11 he was the lower league player they talked to and used in advertisements the most, google rickie lambert fifa 11 and you'll see what I mean. Not sure if he's got the same role for 12 but regardless I reckon he'll make it over the 70 barrier.
 
We've got to remember the lines of Maynard, probably the division's best striker (bar Bellamy) was a 72, and Barnard is more than a tiny bit worse than him.
 
-Dan said:
We've got to remember the lines of Maynard, probably the division's best striker (bar Bellamy) was a 72, and Barnard is more than a tiny bit worse than him.
Click to expand...

Fair point I've got barnard being put as a 67 so 5 points worse, but I wouldn't be surprised to see barny at a 65 which is 7 points worse. Probably fair to be honest. Fingers crossed the spanish players won't walk on water as gods of Fifa this year!
 
I remember when I bought the first edition of Pro Evo which didn't have Saints in it, so I built the team from scratch. Just for the hell of it, I also built one Saints side with all my favourite ex-Saints players in it, going to a lot of trouble to make them look as much like the individual players, from the past, as I could. I also gave them the best combination of skills, power, stamina, you name it, it was possible to have, and then played Man U at OT on level 5 [or 6 was it..?] for the longest game possible.

My Saints team absolutely blew them away. It was so satisfying. :D
 
I'll have a go - two ratings, what I think they should be and in bracketswhat I think they will be.

Davis 70 (68)
Bialkowski 66 (62)

Richardson 68 (64)
Butterfield 63 (64)
Fonte 70 (68)
Martin 63 (61)
Seabourne 63 (63)
Jaidi 66 (64)
Harding 68 (65)
Dickson 65 (61)
Fox 70 (69)

De Ridder can't really say (68, based on what he is this game)
Chaplow 65 (65)
Hammond 67 (64)
Schneiderlin 69 (67)
Cork 71 (68)
Holmes 63 (62)
Lallana 75 (70)

Barnard 66 (65)
Connolly 69 (67)
Guly 68 (67)
Lambert 71 (69)
 
I made an Ultimate Team this year that was a Saints XI. I was/am very hard to beat even for people with Golds and top IFs lol. Planning to do the same this time should be fun
 
Davis 68
Bialkowski 62

Richardson 67
Butterfield 67
Fonte 71
Martin 64
Seabourne 63
Jaidi 68
Harding 69
Dickson 65
Fox 71

De Ridder 70
Chaplow 68
Hammond 73
Schneiderlin 71
Cork 74
Holmes 67
Lallana 75

Barnard 71
Connolly 70
Guly 69
Lambert 74

I don't agree with most of them but FIFA rarely pay much attention to 'lesser teams'. My freind once told me that a bournemouth player of Fifa a few years ago was black in the game yet in real life he was white...
 
Davis 99
Bialkowski 98

Richardson 98
Butterfield 99
Fonte 99
Martin 99
Seabourne 98
Jaidi 98
Harding 98
Dickson 98
Fox 99

De Ridder 98
Chaplow 98
Hammond 99
Schneiderlin 99
Cork 99
Holmes 98
Lallana 99

Barnard 98
Connolly 98
Guly 98
Lambert 99

i thought long and hard about my predicted ratings, then thought i lov them all, haha .
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back