Sunderlands best ever signing.

As we have the worst let's see who we think the best is.....

 

I'll go Phillips, Kevin Ball, Bridges for cost to profit ratio. Stephan Schwartz. How much did that lot cost?

 

Best is simple. SKP. £350,000 represents the best value sigining from any club in the last 20 years. How many times has a £350k footballer won the European Golden Boot?

 

Argument over me thinks

 

You got too be right you know my feelings about skp he is without doubt our best ever signing

 

Again sorry tony end of thread lol

 

I'd even say he is the best signing in our entire history given the cost, goals, European Goldern Boot, goals in a top flight season and general impact for 6 years.

If anyone can name a better signing I'd like to hear it. He is a total shoe in for selection in any poll to find the best ever sunderland 11 as well imo.

 

Ces100per cent correct

 

I'd go for Superkev, where it not for Sir Niall Quinn.

Yes, he cost £1.3million, and scored less goals than Kev.

If we hadn't signed him though, where would we be now?? No Drumaville, no Ellis....

He was superb on the park, and was the main reason we came back from the dead after he'd retired.

He simply has to the one.

 

Brian Clough or Kevin Philips or Dave Watson

 

im going to say it..... at the time it was a buzz to the team and the club... the epic airport thread and the amazing song and the goals

[NSFW] I Miss Him [/NSFW]

 

Sir Niall for me, look what he's done for this city and club, has to be the best signing ever!

 

Bramble.

 

Oh!, Monsmush chucks a Quinny in to muddy the waters of a debate delared 'over'.

Well we have narrowed it down to two, the big guy or the little fellah in the same strike partnership.

For overall impact on the club as a whole Quinny wins hands down IMO

 

It was never over amigo!

Without signing the big man, we actually might not have a club now, as we agree, he walks this!

 

Id go for Phillips on the field.

For an overall impact Quinn is arguably the most important figure in recent Safc history he should have a statue in his honour.

 

If its the best player its SKP by a country mile.

If its most important person to ever sign for the club for off the field contribution its Quinny by a universe.


However, unless I mis-understood the question, its aimed at the best signing on the pitch surely? Isnt it?

 

This is a good way to get banned.

Seriously though, Bent was an amazing signing but as Cest says, Phillips has to be your best ever signing.

 

well i was thinking ot the box because the OP never said the definition of "best signing"

i was thinking... high profile, most exitment.... and added bonus on scoring lots for us....

SKP and Quinny i think have to be the top ones... but i think mig in a few years mighg be up there tooo

 

Charlie Hurley anouther one aswell....