Street Racing?

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
A couple of years ago I was in the square in Siena where they hold the Palio (although I wasn't there for the race). Each time I see any coverage of the damned thing it just makes me shudder. It is only when you stand there do you realise it is totally unsuitable for a horse race of any kind. There is an article here (warning - horrible youtube footage of a horse breaking its leg) and, whilst I understand the tradition and the excitement it creates, for me it is a non-starter. Just like bull fighting in Spain. So why on Earth he thinks this is a good idea (whatever safety measures are put in place) this just shouldn't get off the ground. There are any number of racecourses around the country who would cry out for some of the money being wasted on this idea.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bayernkenny
OddDog said:
A couple of years ago I was in the square in Siena where they hold the Palio (although I wasn't there for the race). Each time I see any coverage of the damned thing it just makes me shudder. It is only when you stand there do you realise it is totally unsuitable for a horse race of any kind. There is an article here (warning - horrible youtube footage of a horse breaking its leg) and, whilst I understand the tradition and the excitement it creates, for me it is a non-starter. Just like bull fighting in Spain. So why on Earth he thinks this is a good idea (whatever safety measures are put in place) this just shouldn't get off the ground. There are any number of racecourses around the country who would cry out for some of the money being wasted on this idea.
Click to expand...

I visited Siena while staying at Forte dei Marmi during Italia 1990. The same thoughts about the 'Palio' went through my mind; tradition is all very well however surely the welfare of the horses must, in time, take precedence. Gotta say I preferred Lucca as a 'tourist' town.
 
OddDog said:
A couple of years ago I was in the square in Siena where they hold the Palio (although I wasn't there for the race). Each time I see any coverage of the damned thing it just makes me shudder. It is only when you stand there do you realise it is totally unsuitable for a horse race of any kind. There is an article here (warning - horrible youtube footage of a horse breaking its leg) and, whilst I understand the tradition and the excitement it creates, for me it is a non-starter. Just like bull fighting in Spain. So why on Earth he thinks this is a good idea (whatever safety measures are put in place) this just shouldn't get off the ground. There are any number of racecourses around the country who would cry out for some of the money being wasted on this idea.
Click to expand...

Is a horse dying in the Palio any worse than a horse perishing at Aintree? I agree with you in regards the Palio, it should be banned, but in saying that, we lay ourselves open to others asking the same of horse racing. I'm happy to live with the double standard, but I'm as weak as piss.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OddDog
bayernkenny said:
I visited Siena while staying at Forte dei Marmi during Italia 1990. The same thoughts about the 'Palio' went through my mind; tradition is all very well however surely the welfare of the horses must, in time, take precedence. Gotta say I preferred Lucca as a 'tourist' town.
Click to expand...

Oh yes, Lucca is beautiful. I spent a happy couple of hours in the main piazza there sinking ice cold Peronis whilst the wife and kids were off browsing the shops. I was even surprised by a live performance from a samba band <cheers>
 
  • Like
Reactions: bayernkenny
I think street racing has been summed up by this thread, no appetite for it and we just start talking about something else. What they should be investing in is getting the best horses from around the world together for Royal Ascot.
 
Cyclonic said:
Is a horse dying in the Palio any worse than a horse perishing at Aintree? I agree with you in regards the Palio, it should be banned, but in saying that, we lay ourselves open to others asking the same of horse racing. I'm happy to live with the double standard, but I'm as weak as piss.
Click to expand...

You are right Cyc, of course. It just seems to me that professional horse racing does everything for the horses welfare whereas the Palio is a group of lunatics thrashing horses around a tight town square cheered on by more drunken lunatics.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cyclonic
I saw something about this on one of the daily paper websites the other day.

Peter might be 14th in line to the throne but presumably he will drop to 15th in a couple of months’ time and if Kate knocks out another he will drop to 16th.

I simply do not see this as a starter.

Three days from start to finish is a funny definition of ‘pop-up’. Would the Aussies really close Sydney Harbour Bridge for that long for a gimmick?

Control of the environment will be almost impossible, so the animal rights nutters will be along on raceday one to disrupt proceedings. Horses are for food and glue, not racing on city streets.

Given that the various venues envisioned operate in different types of betting jurisdictions, it is difficult to see how that is going to be controlled. What is to stop Ladbrokes offering betting on a race in Singapore, from which the local betting monopoly receives no revenue?
 
When I saw the heading my instant reaction was wtf. But, I think this is about an event once a year (cf to massive fair or equestrian show jumping event) run on a well prepared racing surface. Cruelty doesn't come into it because the surface that will be laid will be safer than extreme going on turf. Finding an appropriate stretch might be the biggest logistical problem. Show jumping at the NEC is actually on a surface laid over concrete. If it takes off in Europe I'm sure my daughter will be there marketing a better surface than that proposed which will take much less than 3 days to prepare; and easier to clear up afterwards (already being used for training gallops and arenas)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back