I was there when Baxter came,agree he was a wonderful player. I never saw Shack,but my Dad told me he was the most wonderful player he'd seen. As for Patrick Roberts, imo he has the potential to become one of our all time greats. His brilliant close control is a delight to watch,as is his eye to turn in and get a sight on goal.I think he's a player who was looking for a home and has found it. I don't agree with those who say he was in Amad's shadow last season....he was just as active and they were a great double team at times. They both read each other well and gave great opportunity to each other.