Bristol City manager tired of being patronised as he slams inconsistent messages from PGMOL Bristol City manager Nigel Pearson wants accountability from those in leadership roles as he reveals the mixed messages received last week please log in to view this image Nigel Pearson believes the PGMOL and standard of officiating in England remains in turmoil after suggesting Bristol City are being patronised by the regular inconsistencies and mixed messages when explaining in-game decisions. The officiating was again called into question in Saturday's 2-1 victory over Rotherham United after the visitors were awarded a highly contentious penalty in the second half when Jordan Hugill went down under the soft challenge of Zak Vyner. It led to Nigel Pearson receiving a yellow card on the touchline for his reaction that had been brewing following decisions which had gone against his side in the first half. City were also denied two spot-kicks from referee Josh Smith when both Sam Bell and Tommy Conway had strong appeals turned down. "Could’ve, should’ve had a penalty, maybe but again, I get tired of talking about it in all honesty with the inconsistencies," Pearson would say after the game. "We get a penalty turned down and they get one that looks as though the player falls down in installments and he gives it." Pearson then went into a lengthy tirade regarding the PGMOL (Professional Game Match Officials Limited) and MOAS (Match Official Administration System) having received two different explanations in the wake of a decision in the 1-0 defeat against Sheffield United. It occurred in the first half at Bramall Lane when Bell was pulled back marginally outside the area when played through on goal, but referee Geoff Eltringham waved play to continue. Pearson added: "Having said that we received two emails yesterday (Friday) from MOAS which I think are rather embarrassing for them. "We got one at 14:12 that said that the foul on Sam Bell against Sheffield United there’s a really good case for it being a free-kick and a red card and then half an hour later, we had another one that they’d taken out two paragraphs and put that it was a free-kick and a yellow card. "They clearly are in turmoil, not only are the officials unclear as to how to officiate games but then the process of how they go through decisions that have either been complained about or people who understand football, like managers and coaches, look at it and I’m not sure they know what they’re doing, to be honest with you. "The leadership within their group is... wow. Everybody thought Howard Webb would come in and have a positive impact but even in the Premier League, it’s getting things wrong even with VAR. "The game is in a situation where there needs to be a bit more clarity until the leadership of officiating is improved and we get a consistency of officiating or we’re as coaches or the players are going to end up moaning all the time because it just happens week after week and I’ve said it many times, we’re sick to the back teeth of having these reports come back that just patronise us. please log in to view this image "I got booked and I don’t know what I even got booked for apart from the fourth official basically imploded because he couldn’t deal with anything, and the referee basically came over and gave me a yellow card and didn’t even tell me what it was for so I’m not sure they understand what’s happening in that regard either. "I just find it laughable in all honesty. They’re irritating, very, very irritating, inconsistent, not good enough and it’s ruining the game.” Pearson has highlighted the deficiencies and standard of officiating during the course of his City tenure but earlier in the season, following a game against Luton Town, he threatened to quit football over it. More recently, he joked that City could plaster the walls with the excuses and "poor reports" they get back from MOAS. Last week, French official Benoit Millot was mic'd up during a top flight game between Lyon and Nantes which received wide praise for the clarity behind the decisions while providing an interesting insight into how officials interact with players. The decision from the French Football Federation was to "continue to push for the modernisation of the country’s refereeing system". When asked whether the English game would benefit from the introduction of mic'd up refs, Pearson responded: "My answer to the question simply would be yes, I think it would be good for the game. "Whether the standard of officiating is capable of making that step, I have huge reservations if I'm honest. Rugby is a really good example of how officiating is done at a high standard and there is clarity. "We can hear what they're saying, we can hear why they make decisions. Whether people always agree with it or not is another thing. "I think it would take quite a big step for officiating in English football to go that far because first of all there would have to be confident that the people who are making the decisions would get them right." https://www.bristolpost.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/bristol-city-slams-mixed-messages-8380816
I have to confess, despite being an ex-referee, that very few calls have gone our way this season and it has to change by better officiating in years to come. The advent of VAR at the Premiership level has led to some quirky, to say the least, decisions but overall I think it has been a good thing and needs a little tweaking. I think that if we had the same system this season we could have been awarded 8 or 10 penalties that never reached the light of day under just the decisions by the ref. Officials alone have done the job for years but the stakes are too high in today's footballing world for major decisions not to be left to chance and the whims of a single referee.
From what I saw on the highlights their penalty was soft, but just after that there was a similar incident which could easily have been given, following the logic and interpretation for the first one. Being a ref isn't easy, I get that, but they do need to be consistent, and they just aren't
Had he not given the first I think he would have given the second, but he wasn’t about to give both. We had a couple of really good shouts too mind
Had he not given the first I think he would have given the second, but he wasn’t about to give both. We had a couple of really good shouts too mind
Not as tired as the refs are of being criticised and being treated with disrespect, and worse. What a way to describe the officials "I just find it laughable in all honesty. They’re irritating, very, very irritating, inconsistent, not good enough and it’s ruining the game",. "They clearly are in turmoil, not only are the officials unclear as to how to officiate games but then the process of how they go through decisions that have either been complained about or people who understand football, like managers and coaches,/. That would be refs Nigel. Its their job and they have to go through a lengthy and thorough process to become professional refs. "look at it and I’m not sure they know what they’re doing, to be honest with you." Refs are the top level have to know what they are doing. They pass tests, gain levels and are evaluated overs years on knowing what they are doing. The superior one here is Mr Pearson. Maybe he might want to do a bit of reffing himself. There are leagues in Bristol where entire divisions don't have refs e to the abuse they are receiving, refs this season in AYL 16 games have been assaulted. please log in to view this image
The refs in my day (expect much the same today) were ones who loved the game but for whatever reason weren't up to playing. It's OK knowing the many and sometimes obscure rules but to fully understand the game and become a professional ref I think you need to have played semi pro at least. Perhaps if referees were paid as much as the players they officiate then you'd, hopefully, get a much better game as ex pro's would be far more likely to take up refereeing. I'm also pretty sure having ex pro's as refs the players would be more likely to give them respect as well.
Witnessing pundits, and ex players having such a poor understanding of the rules, its highly questionable that ex pros would make better refs. Refs reputedly amongst the best e.g. Collina didn't play above grass roots level. The pay for refffing at pro level is above playing semi pro level. We should be able to point to significant numbers of ex semi pros becoming refs. We can't. Players and Managers should do mandatory course on the rules of the game. This may help Mr Pearson ..
[QUOTE="This may help Mr Pearson ..[/QUOTE] I will take Mr Pearsin's view of football over a ref thank you.
I’ve said before on other threads that I find it remarkable how few penalty decisions go our way - both conceding and awarding.
Former Premier League referee agrees with Nigel Pearson over disputed Bristol City penalty call Nigel Pearson was once again furious with the officials following Bristol City's 2-1 victory over the Millers https://www.bristolpost.co.uk/sport/football/referee-nigel-pearson-bristol-city-8386491
That’s exactly how I saw it, I understand refs have a really difficult job, but that decision was disgraceful, it’s not like the ref wasn’t in a good position to see it, he was. At league level they should be accountable for decisions, especially key ones. Also to book NP without an explanation of what the booking was for is unacceptable.
It was a point regarding refereeing. To be a Professional referee the individual will have a exceptional proficient refereeing ability. Referees are.
