When he's at his best (which is very good) I can cope with his half-assed tracking back and nonexistent tackling or heading. When he's like he has been all season, underpar, mis-firing and miserable, he's a liability. He's been fantastic for us and was unbelievably good last season. This season has been a struggle start to finish. Is that down to him or an indication of how things have gone wrong off the pitch?