In the next game, can we ditch the 3 team thing. Preferred it when it was 2. Also with a lynching, 2 assassins and a vigilante, half the players were dead by day 2!! Dont mind if its Mafia Vs Town, Mafia Vs Vampire or whatever, but 3 teams meant too many killing roles and everyone dead.
Just on the AFc claiming he had me fingered on day one/two, I'm just reading through the Freemasons board again (bored at work ) thought this exchange on day two was interesting (discussing who to recruit): Sky: "I think tonight if we both stay alive we should definately bring someone in. Either take a risk on Swarbs, or perhaps Gerrez or IBWT." AFC: "I'm unconvinced with IBWT, he immediately accepted what you said as true, though that doesn't made him guilty lol. I'd be up for taking a risk on swarbs or gerrez" Yep, he certainly had me fingered
Not really, there were no kills other than lynching for the last two or three days. The vigilante and Mafia Assassin both only used one of their two kills too meaning only four kills were made outside lynching, that's not that many when there are fifteen players. Obviously, from the towns view it may be seen as too many since two teams are targeting people that aren't on their team but they could have attacked someone from the other team too. From our (KGB) perspective, we didn't have enough kills. We had to sit, plot and use lynching after the second night. We never lost a member and it still went on until night six
http://www.not606.com/showthread.php/27428-OT-The-Carragher-Arms?p=7178042 Gerrez try that for pub thread.
And this doesn't fit with what AFC was saying either: I'd have been happy with this. If you had all gone on Magic I'd have switched early to bluff and make you think we were trying to save the recruiter. I'd have switched back again with a few minutes to go Had you put all the votes on me, Biscan and myself (I checked with Milk that I could vote for myself) would have do so too. again, it would have been a bluff attempt to say we were happy for me to be lynched because I wasn't the recruiter. As I said several times to AFC, the game was far from over going into that final lynching, just a same the site problems ruined the game
I just thought 3 people dying on Day 1 was too much.....and not just because 2 were mafia, that coupled with me taking out the town cop pretty much handed the game to the KGB on Day 1.
Exactly. My point was that the game was too long imo so I wouldn't say there wasn't enough kills. I think we needed more but with restrictions.
Three dying on day one wasn't too much, it was the lucky hit (in KGB eyes) that was the issue. Taking out the Mafia Recruiter, Mafia Assassin and Town Cop on the first night was the worse case scenario for your team, perfect for us and better than average for the town.
Six days and I think it depends how you look at it. Being involved until the end, the last couple of days were a drag. The connection issues obviously wouldn't have helped but as people die off the game becomes slower and more technical. I think any longer and people would lose interest.
I think a week is fine, provided its no longer than that. I survived the last one till the end and fully enjoyed it. I think a combination of PMT on the part of a couple of users, and connection issues, killed the game off in the last couple of days.
Mafia 2 only lasted three days. Maybe the connection issues made a bigger impact than I gave it credit for. @ PMT. I'm guessing you mean Magic and Astro
