Doyle is a good player with plenty to offer and will run his socks off for whatever team he plays for. He would quickly become a fans favourite. A yes for me.
I was thinking about Doyle for us today. I like him. 100% player - knows his way around the park. We could do worse
Sorry, but if I have to watch Mackie for another season, I'm gonna throw myself off the nearest bridge with concrete armbands!. Ok he runs a lot but absolutely no skill,pace or control!. Derry, Hill and Mackie for all the effort are league 1 players at best... At best!. Overhaul needed.. Again!
Trouble is you need players with that attitude to keep a squad together. Hill and Derry are past it which means keeping Mackie is vital. As well as adding more players with the right attitude.