When he was good he was very. very good, when he was bad he was awful,,,,,,,,,,,,,the hallmark of MM's Watford sides was working hard for one another, they overcame some of their shortcomings skill wise by working their socks off for one another, MM is said to be a disciniplarian in the Ferguson mould, would he want an undoubtedly talrnted prima donna like Jay at the club, or would he rather bring in a 100% commited pro, who will not go missing 50% of the time? Don't get me wrong I was a Bothroyd fan, but sometimes IMO we relied on him too much and he didn't deliver.