Hi a question for the real football fans

Hi guys on football manager i have got a load of players and was wondering if you lot who seem swiched on with football will help and advise me on a best 11 i will tell you the team and if you could help that whould be great (im wigan team by the way)

From this lot who whould you play as the best 11 and who whould be on the bench also what formation whould you play.

Goalkeeper:
Chris Kirkland
Brad Jones
Marcus Hahnemann

Defender:
Paul Koncheskey
Wes Brown
Gary Caldwell
Jame Carragher
Fabio Aurelio
Steven Caldwell
Maynor Figueroa
Martin Kelly

Midfielder:
Shane Ferguson (IOL)
Ryan Giggs
Ahmed Elmohamady
Emannual Frimpong (IOL)
James McCarthy
Kevin Nolan
Alan Smith
Ben Watson
Jay Spearing
Jordi Gomez
Mohamed Diame
Jason Koumas
Joey Barton
Scott Parker
Lee bowyer
Charlie Adam
Raul Miereles
Rory Delap



Striker:
Franco Di Santo
Victor Moses
Conor Sammon
Hugo Rodallega
Emile Heskey
Danny Wellbeck
Michel Owen
Eiður Guðjohnsen

 

4-4-2 (2 Poachers) , Line up: LB - Figueroa, CB - Brown, CB - Carragher, RB - Kelly, LM - Giggs, CM - Diame, CM - Adam, RM - Elmo, ST - Rod, ST - Welbeck

 

GK - all pretty much same ability

 

thats interesting so your leaving both of nolan and barton on the bench

 

Nolan is terrible on FM, Barton nothing flash

 

------------------Kirkland-------------------

Brown---Carragher---Figeuroa-----Auerlio

------------Parker--------Adam------------

Welbeck--------McCarthy----------Rodallega

------------------Di Santo------------------

 

This is daft, it depends where you are in the game timewise and how you want to play. Plus who you're playing against, what league you're in and a load of other factors that involve you actually making decisions yourself...

 

ok colly on 606 they had sports gaming and its the same on ja606 im part of that so it is right now i was wondering what you thought the best team was out of my squad

 

Drop Owen

 

GK Jones
Def Carragher, Kelly, G.Caldwell, Figureoa
Mid Meireles, Parker, Adam, Giggs
Striker Rodallega, Welbeck

 

Preferably off a very big bridge somewhere

 

Too many midfielders in that team. Unless you rotate every game, a lot will become unhappy in about 3 months

 

what year are you in?

 

I'd answer, but i'm actually a sentient computer program, and therefore not a 'real' football fan

 

im in 2011 and by real football fan i asked sunderland fans and they couldnt come up with any thing so i came and asked the fans who actually know somthing about football

 

There's a gaming thread..

 

1: how did you get all them players without adding another user and giving them to you?
2:How much money did you get for the transfers?

 

i have no money left and i just bought them i just want your opinion on whats the best 11

 

Ask your assistant manager, then just experiment for yourself, there's more to building a successful team than just ability.

 

well in that case, bit OTT on the midfield so I'd say you'd have to play some form of 451, my favourite being:

--------ST------------
AML---------------AMR
---CMATK----DLP------
---------DMC---------
---standard defence

DLP = deep lying playmaker.

I'll get back to you on specifics once i've had a proper look at the players.