Eddie is in the hardest section. I reckon Bartram and Mendonca are certainties. Killer, Peacock and Eddie is a tough choice, Keith cos I know him, Eddie cos I feel like I know him and Halesy cos he'd kill me if I voted for anyone else. Maybe its a very large Scotch!!
I just missed out on Mark Kinsella as a player - I saw him on the odd occasion but wasn't a season ticket holder until just after he left (this was a coincidence and not a deciding factor). So was he actually as good as he's made out to be? I just remember him as the odious be-shorted dwarf who looked out of his depth and irrelevant under Super Pards...
I think Kinsella is listed largely due to the fact he didn't leave us when we were relegated. Showed a tremendous amount of loyalty. As for on the pitch, was a good player, but not a ''legend'' in my eyes. Mendonca will take my vote from that team.
Pre 50's: Sam Bartram - How can you ignore the guy who has made the most appearances in a Charlton shirt. 50s - 80s: Keith Peacock - He's Mr Charlton and has held every position within the club, am sorry Killer and please dont hurt me but you'll have to wait till the next time 80s Onwards: Mark Kinsella - I would put Super Clive but Mark was here first and was here after Clive as well, was a fabulous captain, scoring goals isnt everything.
They already is a charlton athletic hall of fame, i have 2 of the original prints on my bed room wall! Why do we need another one?
Check the OS Stu. There is a vote going in for hall of fame players in three eras. Our very own Eddie Firmani is up against keith Peacock and Hales.
Modesty forbids me to comment. Except to say I shocked not to see the name of Stuart Leary in the shortlist.
