Food for thought from the IFHA (International Federation of Horseracing Authorities) Conference:
Free movement of horses proving 'a very painful subject'
Brexit challenge made starkly apparent to administrators
Brexit added colour to Ascot but is causing headaches for bloodstock
Edward Whitaker
1 of 1
By Howard Wright in Paris6:19PM, OCT 2 2017
Brexit and the huge problems it will cause for bloodstock markets in Britain, Ireland, France and beyond when Britain leaves the EU in March 2019 (or whenever) were laid bare in stark detail in Paris on Monday.
Delegates to the annual post-Arc conference of the International Federation of Horseracing Authorities heard public confirmation – for the first time – that the tripartite agreement, which has allowed free movement of horses between the three major powers of Europe since the 1960s, will disappear when Britain becomes a "third country" in EU terms.
The news that the thoroughbred industries of all three countries least wanted to hear was delivered last week, when BHA chief executive Nick Rust, his Horse Racing Ireland counterpart Brian Kavanagh and Paul-Marie Gadot, France-Galop's chief veterinary officer and co-chairman of the European & Mediterranean Stud Book Liaison Committee, met the EU negotiator in Brussels.
Tripartite agreement doomed
Describing Brexit as "a very painful subject," Gadot told the Paris delegates: "The EU negotiator's position is simple and it has not changed: on March 29, 2019, the UK will be a third country and the tripartite agreement will no longer exist.
"It will be impossible to say the agreement was signed before Britain and Ireland joined the EU in 1973, was executed before Brexit and therefore will exist afterwards, because it has become part of EC legislation, after being accepted by the EU in accordance with an EC directive in 2009.
"The future status of the UK can't be the same as it was before Brexit. Moreover, we were told that we won't obtain the same status for Britain as Switzerland currently has. Switzerland is not in the EU but has special statutes and we can easily move horses from there to France and Germany. That will not be the solution after Brexit."
Penalised
As a consequence, Gadot said, the industry position was paramount. "We need to protect our economic and technical interests," he added. "The restrictions imposed on the UK will penalise Irish and French interests, but also the other European nations which maintain trading activities with the UK.
"We told the EU negotiator: 'You are going to finish with Britain, but you are going to punish the Irish and French industries, but we – the Irish and the French – are still Europeans, so you must be very careful.'"
Brian Kavanagh: HRI chief executive praised common approach
Patrick McCann (racingpost.com/photos)
Looking to the challenges and their possible solutions, Gadot pointed to the need for mutual recognition of a common, high-health status for thoroughbreds and its stud books, "otherwise we would have the nightmare of the General Stud Book not being recognised by the EC," and the continuation of the tripartite agreement in an evolved form.
New system
"It's clear that we can't call it a TPA," he said. "But we will invent a new system that allows easy movement between the three countries. For border inspection posts, they have to allow a fluent custom passage, otherwise trade and welfare would be affected.
"If on March 29, 2019, we have thousands of horses moving between countries, there will be hundreds of lorries at border posts, so it not only our problem but the EU's problem, because they will have to give a lot of money for something that today is not considered necessary."
Gadot pointed out that Britain, Ireland and France were already working closely on a common position, and that other European countries had approached their EU commissioners highlighting serious concerns.
Confirming the joint approach, Brian Kavanagh said: "If there is any silver lining to the cloud, this is it. The process has challenged us to look at the fundamentals, and I see nothing but co-operation between Britain, Ireland and France, which has sent out a very powerful message to the EC."
Free movement of horses proving 'a very painful subject'
Brexit challenge made starkly apparent to administrators
You must log in or register to see images
Brexit added colour to Ascot but is causing headaches for bloodstock
Edward Whitaker
1 of 1
By Howard Wright in Paris6:19PM, OCT 2 2017
Brexit and the huge problems it will cause for bloodstock markets in Britain, Ireland, France and beyond when Britain leaves the EU in March 2019 (or whenever) were laid bare in stark detail in Paris on Monday.
Delegates to the annual post-Arc conference of the International Federation of Horseracing Authorities heard public confirmation – for the first time – that the tripartite agreement, which has allowed free movement of horses between the three major powers of Europe since the 1960s, will disappear when Britain becomes a "third country" in EU terms.
The news that the thoroughbred industries of all three countries least wanted to hear was delivered last week, when BHA chief executive Nick Rust, his Horse Racing Ireland counterpart Brian Kavanagh and Paul-Marie Gadot, France-Galop's chief veterinary officer and co-chairman of the European & Mediterranean Stud Book Liaison Committee, met the EU negotiator in Brussels.
Tripartite agreement doomed
Describing Brexit as "a very painful subject," Gadot told the Paris delegates: "The EU negotiator's position is simple and it has not changed: on March 29, 2019, the UK will be a third country and the tripartite agreement will no longer exist.
"It will be impossible to say the agreement was signed before Britain and Ireland joined the EU in 1973, was executed before Brexit and therefore will exist afterwards, because it has become part of EC legislation, after being accepted by the EU in accordance with an EC directive in 2009.
"The future status of the UK can't be the same as it was before Brexit. Moreover, we were told that we won't obtain the same status for Britain as Switzerland currently has. Switzerland is not in the EU but has special statutes and we can easily move horses from there to France and Germany. That will not be the solution after Brexit."
Penalised
As a consequence, Gadot said, the industry position was paramount. "We need to protect our economic and technical interests," he added. "The restrictions imposed on the UK will penalise Irish and French interests, but also the other European nations which maintain trading activities with the UK.
"We told the EU negotiator: 'You are going to finish with Britain, but you are going to punish the Irish and French industries, but we – the Irish and the French – are still Europeans, so you must be very careful.'"
You must log in or register to see images
Brian Kavanagh: HRI chief executive praised common approach
Patrick McCann (racingpost.com/photos)
Looking to the challenges and their possible solutions, Gadot pointed to the need for mutual recognition of a common, high-health status for thoroughbreds and its stud books, "otherwise we would have the nightmare of the General Stud Book not being recognised by the EC," and the continuation of the tripartite agreement in an evolved form.
New system
"It's clear that we can't call it a TPA," he said. "But we will invent a new system that allows easy movement between the three countries. For border inspection posts, they have to allow a fluent custom passage, otherwise trade and welfare would be affected.
"If on March 29, 2019, we have thousands of horses moving between countries, there will be hundreds of lorries at border posts, so it not only our problem but the EU's problem, because they will have to give a lot of money for something that today is not considered necessary."
Gadot pointed out that Britain, Ireland and France were already working closely on a common position, and that other European countries had approached their EU commissioners highlighting serious concerns.
Confirming the joint approach, Brian Kavanagh said: "If there is any silver lining to the cloud, this is it. The process has challenged us to look at the fundamentals, and I see nothing but co-operation between Britain, Ireland and France, which has sent out a very powerful message to the EC."
