1. Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

Austrian GP Driver Ratings

Discussion in 'Formula 1' started by Paco Montoya, Jun 22, 2014.

  1. Paco Montoya

    Paco Montoya Active Member

    Joined:
    Jan 25, 2011
    Messages:
    2,672
    Likes Received:
    26
    Remember, the ratings are for both qualifying and the race.

    Rosberg -
    Hamilton -
    Bottas -

    Massa -
    Alonso -
    Perez -
    Magnussen -
    Ricciardo -
    Hulkenberg -
    Raikkonen -

    Button -
    Maldonado -
    Sutil -
    Grosjean -
    Bianchi -
    Kobayashi -
    Chilton -
    Ericsson -
    Gutierrez -

    Vergne -
    Kyvat -
    Vettel -
     
    #1
  2. EternalMSC

    EternalMSC Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jan 26, 2011
    Messages:
    10,624
    Likes Received:
    747
    Rosberg - 8
    Hamilton -7
    Bottas -9

    Massa -8
    Alonso -8
    Perez -7
    Magnussen -8
    Ricciardo -7
    Hulkenberg -7
    Raikkonen -6

    Button -6
    Maldonado - 7
    Sutil -6
    Grosjean - 6
    Bianchi -7
    Kobayashi -7
    Chilton - 6
    Ericsson -6
    Gutierrez -5

    Vergne -6
    Kyvat -8
    Vettel -5
     
    #2
  3. Paco Montoya

    Paco Montoya Active Member

    Joined:
    Jan 25, 2011
    Messages:
    2,672
    Likes Received:
    26
    Rosberg - 8
    Hamilton - 7.5
    Bottas - 9

    Massa - 8
    Alonso - 8
    Perez - 7.5
    Magnussen - 7.5
    Ricciardo - 7
    Hulkenberg - 6.5
    Raikkonen - 6

    Button - 5
    Maldonado - 7
    Sutil - 6
    Grosjean - 6
    Bianchi - 7
    Kobayashi - 6.5
    Chilton - 6
    Ericsson - 5
    Gutierrez - 5

    Vergne - 5
    Kyvat - 7
    Vettel - 4
     
    #3
  4. di Fredsta!

    di Fredsta! Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jan 25, 2011
    Messages:
    3,366
    Likes Received:
    89
    Rosberg - 9 - Bad first lap in quali then Hamilton's "mistake" cost him pole which stops him getting a 10.
    Hamilton - 6 - Want a BOTTLE of water?
    Bottas - 7 - I still think he's hugely overrated. Pit stops favouring him got him 3rd ;) Plus I'm still saying his qualifying was illegal in Q3

    Massa - 7.5 - Pole out of nowhere but the team let him down.
    Alonso - 10 - What else should he do? Not far off the podium either. Still making Kimi look very amateurish
    Perez - 9.5 - Out qualified by Hulk is the only reason why no 10
    Magnussen - 8 - Great weekend all round
    Ricciardo - 7 - Meh, bullied off the track by Hamilton at the start then did nothing
    Hulkenberg - 7 - Is he really as good as everyone says?
    Raikkonen - 4 - He's just useless

    Button - 6 - Where was he? Magnussen had him all weekend
    Maldonado - 8 - Good drive!
    Sutil - 7 - Good qualifying and race but the car is nowhere
    Grosjean - 5 - Meh
    Bianchi - 8 - Miles quicker than Chilton
    Kobayashi - 8 - See above, change to Ericsson
    Chilton - 5 - Go home, you may as well be drunk
    Ericsson - 5 - See above
    Gutierrez - 4 - I think the guy has potential but that's just poor today

    Vergne -
    Kyvat -
    Vettel -
     
    #4
  5. El_Bando

    El_Bando Can't remember, where was I?
    Forum Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 26, 2011
    Messages:
    14,374
    Likes Received:
    1,830
    Rosberg - 8 - Not his best drive but did what was needed to win + extend lead
    Hamilton - 7 - good recovery drive but the british media have over rated it. His weekend was full of mistakes.
    Bottas - 8 - unexpectedly found himself on the podium

    Massa - 8 - good Pole position though it was a crap lap, team screwed his chance of 3rd or more.
    Alonso - 9 - the car cant do any more He is definitely out performing this car
    Perez - 9 -Driver of the day
    Magnussen - 8 - didnt really notice he was here
    Ricciardo - 7 - Got bullied off the track by Vettel and Hamilton
    Hulkenberg - 6 - Whats happened?
    Raikkonen - 4 - FFS Kimi

    Button - 6 - frustrating drive
    Maldonado - 7 - did well to finish this high up and not retire
    Sutil - 7 - the car is so poor
    Grosjean - 5 - could have done better
    Bianchi - 8 - best of the back markers
    Kobayashi - 8 - a solid weekend for caterham
    Chilton - 3 - What Fred said.
    Ericsson - 3 - at least he brought it home
    Gutierrez - 5 a few issues

    Vergne - 6 - the car is very unreliable
    Kyvat - 7 - unlucky, spoilt a good weekend
    Vettel - 4 - Its all part of his agreement with the devil
     
    #5
  6. Forza Bianchi

    Forza Bianchi Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jan 25, 2011
    Messages:
    5,132
    Likes Received:
    26
    Rosberg - 8 - Should have done better in qualifying
    Hamilton - 7 - Strong race but choked in qualifying
    Bottas - 8 - A bit lucky to beat Massa but good race anyway

    Massa - 9 - Equal pace to Bottas in race but an extra point for pole
    Alonso - 9 - Good qualy and race result, 29 seconds ahead of Kimi at the end
    Perez - 10 - Easily beat Hulk despite the 5 place grid penalty
    Magnussen - 9 - Did well to finish where he did considering the SS graining problems that McLaren have
    Ricciardo - 7 - Even with a **** engine, he should have done better
    Hulkenberg - 6 - Points again, but Perez is making Hulk look like another Heidfeld
    Raikkonen - 4 - Not really an improvement over Massa

    Button - 6 - Anonymous and should have at least beaten Kimi
    Maldonado - 8 - Finally beat Grosjean
    Sutil - 7 - I'm starting to think Marussia might finish 9th, Sauber suck
    Grosjean - 5 - Too many mistakes
    Bianchi - 8 - 7 seconds behind Grosjean at the end
    Kobayashi - 8 - Good weekend, but car still not quick enough to beat Marussia
    Chilton - 4 - Outqualifed by Caterham, then 34 seconds behind Bianchi in race
    Ericsson - 5 - Anonymous
    Gutierrez - 5 -Unlucky with the pit stop fail but 0.063 ahead of Bianchi in Q1 is not good enough

    Vergne - 6 - It's a shame that bad luck is ruining what is probably his last season
    Kyvat - 7 - I can't remember what happened to him in the race, good qualy though
    Vettel - 3 - Unlucky, but poor in qualifying, and silly mistake to lose front wing
     
    #6
  7. BrightLampShade

    BrightLampShade Well-Known Member
    Forum Moderator

    Joined:
    Feb 14, 2011
    Messages:
    13,495
    Likes Received:
    2,568
    Rosberg - 8.0 Scruffy q3, strong race
    Hamilton - 7.5 very scruffy q3, stronger race
    Bottas - 9.0 Good q3, very strong race performance

    Massa - 8.0 amazing q3, faded in race
    Alonso - 8.5 The unnoticed man, was never really racing anyone all weekend.
    Perez - 10.0 Faultless Sunday, amazing
    Magnussen - 8.5 Good race
    Ricciardo - 8.0 Bad engine made worse by loss of full power, did well I suppose, beat Vettel in quali at least
    Hulkenberg - 6.5 faded
    Raikkonen - 4.5 Looked totally not for it

    Button - 5.5 Not at the races
    Maldonado - 7.0 Good!
    Sutil - 7.0 Can't say I noticed
    Grosjean - 6.5 Iffy
    Bianchi - 6.5 Hard to say
    Kobayashi -7.0 was a fighter
    Chilton - 6.0 meh
    Ericsson - 6.0 meh
    Gutierrez - 5.0 bad meh

    Vergne - 4.0 Was loosing out to Kyvat
    Kyvat - 7.0 Was looking strong!
    Vettel - 5.0 iffy quali, unlucky failure, clumsy overtaking of Gutierrez.
     
    #7
  8. allsaintchris.

    allsaintchris. Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jan 28, 2011
    Messages:
    7,655
    Likes Received:
    1,314
    Rosberg - 8 Lost place back to Bottas after start but did what he had to after that
    Hamilton - 7 Can't ignore quali errors, but drove very good race to rescue 2nd
    Bottas - 8 Excellent quali but could do nothing about Mercedes race pace

    Massa - 8 Landmark pole for him, but seemed to fade in the race
    Alonso - 7 Solid job again
    Perez - 9 Showing up Hulk again. Early season woe's clearly behind him now
    Magnussen - 8 Much better. Had the measure of his teammate all weekend
    Ricciardo - 6 Hard to fathom this weekend. RBR clearly not on the pace but still seemed off.
    Hulkenberg - 6 Needs to raise his game having been again out raced by Perez
    Raikkonen - 4 Will he see the season out?

    Button - 5 Is he regretting making comments about his teammate a few races ago?
    Maldonado - 7 Much better. A point would have been just reward for him this weekend
    Sutil - 6 Seemed more on the pace this weekend
    Grosjean - 5 All at sea, definitely a bad weekend for him.
    Bianchi - 7 No heroics but fine drive.
    Kobayashi - 7 as above
    Chilton - 5 A bit lacklustre this weekend
    Ericsson - 5 as above
    Gutierrez - 5 Not quite there again

    Vergne - 6
    Kyvat - 8 Unlucky not to get a decent result this weekend
    Vettel - 4 Out in Q2, hit Guitterz in the race and showed visible frustration when car failed early on
     
    #8
  9. Smithers

    Smithers Well-Known Member
    Forum Moderator

    Joined:
    Feb 1, 2011
    Messages:
    8,233
    Likes Received:
    811
    Rosberg - 8.5 - Outqualified in the best car and didn't exactly monster the Williams out of the way.
    Hamilton - 7 - Great recovery after awful Quali.
    Bottas - 8.5 - Should have had pole, and poor stratagem by team - only 6 secs down at the end.


    Massa - 8.5 - Great pole, poor strategy.
    Alonso - 8.5 - I think that was physically all that was in the car
    Perez - 9.0 - Not a great quali but made up for it in the race.
    Magnussen - 8.0 - Out qualified and out raced his team mate, maybe should have beaten Perez?
    Ricciardo - 7 - Poor quali, probably finished as high as expected.
    Hulkenberg - 6 - Out done by his team mate again?
    Raikkonen - 5.5 - As above, but greater gap to teammate.


    Button - 6.0 - As above, but small allowance for P3 reliability.
    Maldonado - 6
    Sutil - 6
    Grosjean - 5
    Bianchi - 8
    Kobayashi - 7
    Chilton - 6
    Ericsson - 5
    Gutierrez - 4


    Vergne - 4
    Kyvat - 7
    Vettel - 6
     
    #9
  10. El_Bando

    El_Bando Can't remember, where was I?
    Forum Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 26, 2011
    Messages:
    14,374
    Likes Received:
    1,830
    Y for Why did he turn up?
     
    #10

  11. GramP

    GramP Member

    Joined:
    Mar 15, 2014
    Messages:
    122
    Likes Received:
    2
    Gerhard Berger = 11
     
    #11
  12. fevriul

    fevriul Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jun 12, 2011
    Messages:
    1,111
    Likes Received:
    91
    You need to grow up!
     
    #12
  13. Big Ern

    Big Ern Lord, Master, Guru & Emperor

    Joined:
    Jan 28, 2011
    Messages:
    23,657
    Likes Received:
    17,965
    Rosberg - 6.5 Came third in qualifying in a two horse race, and had an off-track excursion during the race
    Hamilton - 6 Choked during quali again, and came 2nd in a two horse race,
    Bottas - 9 beat the much faster Mercs in quali, then beat his team-mate in the race
    Massa - 8.5 Great pole, but has had the same problem since the accident, fading at the mid-point.
    Alonso - 9.5 D.O.D, Ferrari is a dog, with a **** engine, and Alosno pulls it up into a decent point scoring poisition
    Perez - 9 After last weeks affair came back very strongly this race, kept the faster cars behind him while his tyres wore out, great result, started much further behind his team-mate and beat him
    Magnussen - 7 Good weekend for him considering how bad the McLaren is.
    Ricciardo - 7 Beat Seb again in Quali, but got bullied at the start and went backwards
    Hulkenberg -6 scored some points, but is being shown up by Perez
    Raikkonen - 5 Never particularly rated him and he's showing why.
    Button - 6 Another forgettable weekend from him.
    Maldonado - 7 Beat romain and kept out of trouble, is that a first?
    Sutil - 7 Doing what he can in a pile of dog-**** that is Sauber
    Grosjean - 6 beaten by Maldonado can't really remember seeing uch of him
    Bianchi - 7 Doing what he can in the Marussia, got past Kobayashi without smashing into him, which is a plus.
    Kobayashi - 8 Worst car on the grid by a margin but always harrassing Bianchi, who doesn't particularly impress me.
    Chilton - 5 How much cash do the Chiltons have? will it run out? I hope so.
    Ericsson - 5 poor, as usual
    Gutierrez - 5 as above,

    Vergne - 6 last year with STR I imagine, and I doubt he'll be the choice to replaced Vettel or Ricciardo when the time comes, that'll be Kvyat
    Kyvat - 7.5 Great quali, but went a bit backwards in the race until he retired
    Vettel - 4 Expect better from a 4xWDC, but unless Renault pull their finger out it will continue
     
    #13
  14. Julius Caesar

    Julius Caesar Well-Known Member
    Forum Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 30, 2011
    Messages:
    6,665
    Likes Received:
    1,008
    Rosberg -7.5 A win, but hardly convincing.
    Hamilton - 6 Decent recovery on the opening lap, but needs to cut out the mistakes and start winning before Nico is too far ahead
    Bottas - 9 Stellar to be so close to the Mercs, Should have been higher if the team had showed some ambition.
    Massa - 8.5 Good race for Massa, but he always seems to work his way backwards doesn't he?
    Alonso - 9.5 No more in it.
    Perez - 8.5 Getting the better of Hulk again.
    Magnussen - 8 Good driver, terrible car.
    Ricciardo - 7 Solid, but unspectacular.
    Hulkenberg -6.5 His consistency is good, but is this really the worldbeating pace that's been so hyped?
    Raikkonen - 4 Wondering if his time is up.
    Button - 5 Hard race. Never recovered from missing FP3.
    Maldonado - 6.5 Best race of the year for Pastor.
    Sutil - 7
    Grosjean - 6
    Bianchi - 7
    Kobayashi - 7
    Chilton - 5
    Ericsson - 5
    Gutierrez - 6

    Vergne - 6 Not sure why he's still here tbh.
    Kyvat - 7
    Vettel - 5 Still slower than Ricciardo, Seb? Obviously unlucky in the race though.
     
    #14

Share This Page