1. Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

Ask PN - November 2011

Discussion in 'Horse Racing' started by Ron, Oct 31, 2011.

  1. Ron

    Ron Well-Known Member
    Forum Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 25, 2011
    Messages:
    51,288
    Likes Received:
    25,808
    #1
  2. PNkt

    PNkt Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jul 25, 2011
    Messages:
    8,106
    Likes Received:
    2,041
    Thanks for the new thread Ron!
     
    #2
  3. Dexter

    Dexter Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jun 24, 2011
    Messages:
    6,372
    Likes Received:
    244
    Hi PN.

    Do you know if Sequence,scheduled to run tomorrow,was a gift from the Aga Khan to the Queen.
     
    #3
  4. PNkt

    PNkt Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jul 25, 2011
    Messages:
    8,106
    Likes Received:
    2,041
    I don't know for certain Dexter, but it looks to be the case. She certainly hasn't passed through the sale ring.
     
    #4
  5. Ron

    Ron Well-Known Member
    Forum Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 25, 2011
    Messages:
    51,288
    Likes Received:
    25,808
    He definitely gave her one.
     
    #5
  6. OddDog

    OddDog Mild mannered janitor
    Staff Member

    Joined:
    Jun 2, 2011
    Messages:
    28,588
    Likes Received:
    10,550
    Steady on Ron <yikes>
     
    #6
  7. King Shergar

    King Shergar Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    May 9, 2011
    Messages:
    8,982
    Likes Received:
    1,010
    Hi PN, I was just wondering wether there had been any future plans made for Workforce, as Id assume he is going to stud this year.

    Also there is usually alot of discussion about keeping Derby winners in training as 4yos, and most owners retire them, through fear of defeat or injury. How much do you think Workforce's unsuccessful 4yo campaign has affected his fee. Surely it must have damaged it considerably.

    I know this is pretty irrelevant as KA is loaded, but just to get an idea of the long term financial risks a Derby winning owner would be taking, racing on at 4:biggrin:
     
    #7
  8. Grizzly

    Grizzly Active Member

    Joined:
    Aug 23, 2011
    Messages:
    2,738
    Likes Received:
    16
    PN - would you have access to any info relating to the Plumpton meeting on Mon 14 Nov ?
    The racecourse website boast that it's the biggest Monday prizemoney meeting in their calendar (sponsored by Spinal Research) but I can't find any race schedules.
    I wanted to know race times/distances and whether there might be a few half decent sorts going ?
    Many Thanks
     
    #8
  9. PNkt

    PNkt Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jul 25, 2011
    Messages:
    8,106
    Likes Received:
    2,041
    I have not heard for certain that Workforce has been retired, though I would imagine he will be simply because the Juddmonte stallion roster is going to have several new additions over the next few years and it makes little sense to have them all arriving at once!

    Althought Workforce hasn't had the greatest year, he has finished 2nd in 2 G1s which is not bad going! Of course wins would have increased his value further but you can't say that 4 wins and 3 2nds from only 9 starts is a "bad" record.

    Had he won again at G1 level this year I'd have expected his fee to be set at around the £40,000 mark (other recent Derby winners had their first fees set at £25k, £30k and &#8364;85k). I now think it is likely to be about £25k, perhaps a little lower.

    You are right in that keeping a derby winner in training at 4 is a risky gamble, it is understandable why so many are retired at the end of their 3yo season. Prince Khalid is a sporting man, as evidenced by his keeping so many good horses in training, and I am sure he gains much pleasure from seeing them continue to run, regardless of whether they are beaten or not.


    Grizzly, I can get the info re Plumpton. I'll dig it out and post it a little later.
     
    #9
  10. Ron

    Ron Well-Known Member
    Forum Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 25, 2011
    Messages:
    51,288
    Likes Received:
    25,808
    This to me puts a big question mark over calling any horse, however good, one of the greats if it is retired at 3. If it is forced into retirement through injury, that's different; but to retire them because defeat can't be risked really says it all.
     
    #10

  11. PNkt

    PNkt Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jul 25, 2011
    Messages:
    8,106
    Likes Received:
    2,041
    Grizzly, the info you require, though times are subject to change:

    Plumpton 14th November

    1pm The Cloudesley Marsham Memorial Novices&#8217; Hurdle Race (Class 4)
    2miles for novice 4yos+. £3,900

    1.30pm The theatlantic4.com Novices&#8217; Steeple Chase (Class 3)
    2m4f for novice 4yo+. £10,000

    2pm The Cenkos Guernsey Supports Spinal Research &#8216;National Hunt&#8217; Novices&#8217; Hurdle Race (Class 4)
    2m5f for novice 4yo+ which have not run in a Flat race. £3,900

    2.30pm The Cenkos Fund Managers Atlantic4 Handicap Steeple Chase (Class 4)
    2m4f for 4yo+ rated 0-120. £8,500

    3pm The Spinal Research Albert Davison Conspiracy Handicap Hurdle Race (Class 5)
    2m2f for 4yo+ rated 0-100. £2,600

    3.30pm The Cenkos Jersey 3000 Miles to Go Novices&#8217; Handicap Steeple Chase (Class 5)
    3m2f for novice 4yo+ rated 0-100

    4pm The Mandeville Paralympics Mascot Standard National Hunt Flat Race (Class 6)
    2m2f for 4, 5 & 6yos which have not run under any recognised Rules of Racing, except National Hunt Flat races, Irish National Hunt races or French AQPS Flat races. £2,100.
     
    #11
  12. Grizzly

    Grizzly Active Member

    Joined:
    Aug 23, 2011
    Messages:
    2,738
    Likes Received:
    16
    Great stuff PN, many thanks.
     
    #12
  13. Dexter

    Dexter Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jun 24, 2011
    Messages:
    6,372
    Likes Received:
    244
    Thanks Princess.
     
    #13
  14. PNkt

    PNkt Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jul 25, 2011
    Messages:
    8,106
    Likes Received:
    2,041
    If anyone is interested I've put up a thread for the Return of Mares 2011 which has just come out. I've included a full run down of all the foals by SEA THE STARS.
     
    #14
  15. OddDog

    OddDog Mild mannered janitor
    Staff Member

    Joined:
    Jun 2, 2011
    Messages:
    28,588
    Likes Received:
    10,550
    Hi Princess,

    not sure if I'm asking the impossible here, but would it be possible to get a general overview of the top National Hunt sires (say last 5 years) and what the characteristics of their progeny tend to be? I think the subject is pretty well covered on the flat but I would like to increase my knowledge of NH sires and NH breeding in general.

    I looked at the sires stats on Racing Post and the top 3 last season were Presenting (Denman, Woolcombe Folly, Ballabriggs), Oscar (Big Zeb, Peddlers Cross, Oscar Whiskey), King's Theatre (Menorah, Captain Chris, The Minack, Volar La Vedette) so obviously they are ones to follow. How much talent is imparted by the Sire in NH, and how much by the dam? Any other things I should be looking for in NH breeding?

    Many thanks in advance for any info.
     
    #15
  16. Ron

    Ron Well-Known Member
    Forum Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 25, 2011
    Messages:
    51,288
    Likes Received:
    25,808
    Oddy, I've just loaded Presenting's data into MS Access and done a bit of analysis

    He has sired 893 under NH. (581 with no wins and 353 with no winnings)
    20 have won over £100k
    7 of those over £200k and 3 of those over £500k

    149 have an RPR of over 120
    of those 48 have an RPR over 140
    of those 22 have an RPR over 150
    of those 7 have an RPR over 160

    Those over 150:
    RPR.....................Winnings
    184 Denman £1,141,347
    173 War Of Attrition £741,257
    170 Woolcombe Folly £10,166
    168 Turpin Green £204,154
    165 Weapon´s Amnesty £216,848
    164 Ballabriggs £608,115
    163 Jered £14,958
    160 China Rock £122,679
    160 Herecomesthetruth £129,617
    159 Joaaci £49,451
    159 Dunguib £210,389
    156 Jessies Dream £123,166
    156 Horner Woods £59,787
    155 Killyglen £93,375
    155 Whatuthink £134,372
    154 Another Promise £99,593
    154 Niche Market £257,806
    153 King Troy £59,152
    153 Silverburn £108,341
    152 Our Ben £121,997
    151 Tavern Times £47,762
    151 First Lieutenant £160,855
     
    #16
  17. OddDog

    OddDog Mild mannered janitor
    Staff Member

    Joined:
    Jun 2, 2011
    Messages:
    28,588
    Likes Received:
    10,550
    <cheers> Ron - so you would conclude that he imparts plenty of stamina to his offspring (with the possible exception of Woolcombe Folly who really looks a 2-miler).
     
    #17
  18. Ron

    Ron Well-Known Member
    Forum Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 25, 2011
    Messages:
    51,288
    Likes Received:
    25,808
    Bit more analysis of Presenting:

    The first line shows that 86 of the horses sired by Presenting were out of a mare sired by Strong Gale and between them they amassed 76 wins. The average RPR of those 86 is 97 and the highest RPR of those is 170

    Here is the list (please excuse the non alignment)


    Count DAM'S SIRE WINS Avg RPR Max RPR
    86 Strong Gale 76 97 170
    46 Phardante 47 96 163
    38 Supreme Leader 32 98 153
    35 Be My Native 50 99 152
    30 Good Thyne 33 95 173
    23 Roselier 42 107 160
    21 Mandalus 19 88 129
    20 Buckskin 29 104 168
    17 Deep Run 15 98 150
    17 King´s Ride 14 94 124
    16 Le Moss 11 94 131
    14 Brush Aside 21 106 159
    14 Executive Perk 15 100 145
    12 Over The River 8 93 156
    11 Pollerton 25 98 184
    11 Orchestra 15 110 155
    10 Glacial Storm 5 99 117
    10 Montelimar 8 100 129
    10 Lafontaine 25 117 146
    9 The Parson 9 91 137
    9 Callernish 2 88 129
    9 Crash Course 4 98 116
    8 Bob Back 12 94 145
    7 Torus 7 109 160
    6 Furry Glen 4 82 119
    6 Decent Fellow 2 73 110
    6 Commanche Run 5 90 125
    5 Royal Fountain 4 101 125
    5 Oats 9 79 127
    5 Teenoso 5 112 123
    5 Kemal 2 100 105
    5 Dalsaan 4 94 120
    5 Carlingford Castle 3 104 117
    5 Broken Hearted 7 109 146
    5 Mister Lord 3 107 127

    Count DAM'S SIRE WINS Avg RPR Max RPR
    5 Town And Country 4 90 116
    4 Pragmatic 1 67 99
    4 Moscow Society 2 97 124
    4 Le Bavard 0 88 102
    4 Lancastrian 7 108 139
    4 Kambalda 0 50 86
    4 Green Shoon 10 84 137
    4 Bob´s Return 0 81 104
    4 Black Minstrel 3 85 111
    4 Jurado 5 127 154
    4 Shernazar 0 93 103
    3 Idiots Delight 5 105 139
    3 Bold Owl 3 110 117
    3 Pennine Walk 1 89 103
    3 Persian Mews 7 114 137
    3 Yashgan 1 96 100
    3 Topanoora 5 94 137
    3 Denel 11 112 116
    3 Ardross 5 114 119
    3 Un Desperado 0 95 104
    3 Electric 4 118 118
    3 Lord Ha Ha 2 102 124
    3 Damsire Unregistered 2 87 93
    3 Husyan 2 100 122
    3 Accordion 0 95 102
    3 Little Bighorn 10 126 164
    3 Remainder Man 0 58 88
    3 Satco 1 77 93
    3 Cheval 1 81 110
    2 Buckley 2 109 125
    2 Derrylin 2 102 125
    2 Desert Style 0 79 103
    2 Stalker 2 96 113
    2 Netherkelly 1 94 94
    2

    Count DAM'S SIRE WINS Avg RPR Max RPR
    2 Sheer Grit 0 34 67
    2 Torenaga 0 87 95
    2 Northern Fashion 1 107 125
    2 Toulon 1 117 123
    2 Last Fandango 0 88 107
    2 Welsh Pageant 0 96 99
    2 Henbit 0 88 107
    2 Tidaro 0 89 91
    2 Crested Lark 1 86 97
    2 Le Glorieux 6 132 144
    2 Shy Groom 3 89 109
    2 Yaheeb 5 127 145
    2 Capitano 0 83 92
    2 Cardinal Flower 0 66 76
    2 Daring March 1 96 114
    2 Jolly Jake 0 106 114
    2 Celio Rufo 0 97 97
    2 Neltino 0 89 94
    2 Fourstars Allstar 11 147 151
    2 Sayyaf 0 83 84
    2 Religiously 0 102 109
    2 Alphabatim 3 96 128
    2 Garryowen 0 31 31
    2 Shalford 4 114 116
    2 Proverb 4 97 101
    2 Quayside 0 70 94
    2 Avocat 2 102 112
    2 Radical 1 98 98
    2 Architect 2 109 115
    2 Ela-Mana-Mou 9 89 148
    2 Anshan 0 107 111
    2 Fidel 4 121 133
    2 Regular Guy 0 59 96
    2 Old Vic 5 125 165
    2 Panoramic 5 120 124

    Count DAM'S SIRE WINS Avg RPR Max RPR
    2 Beneficial 1 99 109
    2 Air Display 0 17 17
    2 Roman Warrior 0 82 82
    2 Exhibitioner 1 100 101
    2 Duky 0 67 82
    2 Efisio 0 64 81
    2 Al Sirat I 0 102 117
    2 Seamanship 1 74 126
    2 Beau Sher 4 126 126
    2 Perugino 3 106 137
    2 Petoski 0 95 110
    2 Seymour Hicks 0 95 109
    2 Batshoof 0 103 111
    2 Balliol 0 102 104
    1 Vaguely Pleasant 0 95 95
    1 Val De L´Orne 0 108 108
    1 Eurobus 0 85 85
    1 Croghan Hill 0 83 83
    1 Eurodeal 0 111 111
    1 Darazari 1 112 112
    1 Tug Of War 0 52 52
    1 El Conquistador 0 87 87
    1 Derring Rose 0 0 0
    1 Durgam 8 159 159
    1 Distant Relative 0 35 35
    1 Double Trigger 0 104 104
    1 Dr Massini 0 104 104
    1 Common Grounds 0 90 90
    1 Dry Dock 0 63 63
    1 Definite Article 0 103 103
    1 Ashford 1 93 93
    1 Cadoudal 2 117 117
    1 Boreen 0 111 111
    1 Windjammer 0 89 89
    1 Ya Zaman 0 94 94

    Count DAM'S SIRE WINS Avg RPR Max RPR
    1 Bluebird 1 114 114
    1 Belmez 0 43 43
    1 Belfalas 0 96 96
    1 Brief Truce 1 96 96
    1 Assert 0 93 93
    1 Welsh Term 0 93 93
    1 Aristocracy 0 97 97
    1 Arctic Lord 0 64 64
    1 Arapahos 0 101 101
    1 Arapaho 1 108 108
    1 Amoristic 0 42 42
    1 Alzao 0 57 57
    1 Altountash 2 132 132
    1 Al Hareb 1 95 95
    1 Baron Blakeney 0 100 100
    1 Caribo 0 86 86
    1 Comedy Star 4 143 143
    1 Classic Cliche 0 92 92
    1 Chromite 0 113 113
    1 Charlaw 0 97 97
    1 Celtic Cone 0 74 74
    1 Cataldi 0 73 73
    1 Castle Keep 2 129 129
    1 Bowling Pin 0 99 99
    1 Warpath 2 98 98
    1 Villez 1 92 92
    1 Candy Cane 0 96 96
    1 Camden Town 3 123 123
    1 Wauthi 0 72 72
    1 Exactly Sharp 0 0 0
    1 Bustino 1 94 94
    1 Burslem 0 86 86
    1 Bulldozer 0 95 95
    1 Welsh Saint 1 83 83
    1 Carroll House 0 75 75

    Count DAM'S SIRE WINS Avg RPR Max RPR
    1 Northern Crystal 5 148 148
    1 Hatim 6 100 100
    1 Pampabird 0 80 80
    1 Paean 0 93 93
    1 Overbury 0 98 98
    1 Ore 0
    1 Shardari 1 121 121
    1 Shareef Dancer 0 70 70
    1 Nucleon 0 78 78
    1 Petorius 0 91 91
    1 Northern Guest 0 105 105
    1 Pistolet Bleu 0 84 84
    1 Noblequest 1 95 95
    1 No Argument 3 99 99
    1 Nikos 0 92 92
    1 Night Shift 0 88 88
    1 Neshad 1 105 105
    1 Nashamaa 0 90 90
    1 Montekin 0 99 99
    1 Monksfield 0
    1 Miner´s Lamp 0 54 54
    1 Northfields 0 85 85
    1 Rainbows For Life 1 105 105
    1 Saddlers´ Hall 0 81 81
    1 Rontino 5 125 125
    1 Roi Guillaume 0
    1 Rising 3 125 125
    1 Riot Helmet 0 0 0
    1 Reprimand 1 122 122
    1 Relkino 0 55 55
    1 Rashar 0 54 54
    1 Pas De Seul 0 54 54
    1 Raise You Ten 0 83 83
    1 Mazaad 0 105 105
    1 Rahotep 1 92 92

    Count DAM'S SIRE WINS Avg RPR Max RPR
    1 Quisling 0 63 63
    1 Pry 0 94 94
    1 Project Manager 0 79 79
    1 Priamos 0 60 60
    1 Precocious 0 91 91
    1 Posen 2 112 112
    1 Pitskelly 0 82 82
    1 Pitpan 2 110 110
    1 Random Shot 0 58 58
    1 Glenstal 4 105 105
    1 Jeu De Paille 0 82 82
    1 Indian Ridge 0 81 81
    1 In The Wings 0 32 32
    1 Houmayoun 0 100 100
    1 Homo Sapien 0 80 80
    1 Homing 0 85 85
    1 Royal Vulcan 0 90 90
    1 He Loves Me 4 142 142
    1 Meneval 0 34 34
    1 Glint Of Gold 0 82 82
    1 Terimon 0 105 105
    1 Girandole 7 137 137
    1 Germany 1 105 105
    1 General Ironside 0
    1 General Assembly 1 100 100
    1 Tremblant 0 31 31
    1 Formidable I 1 114 114
    1 Fine Blade 1 109 109
    1 Faustus 0 94 94
    1 Fairy King 0 85 85
    1 Goldhill 0 117 117
    1 Leading Counsel 0 119 119
    1 Tudor Flame 0 78 78
    1 Master Willie 0 88 88
    1 Master Buck 0 63 63

    Count DAM'S SIRE WINS Avg RPR Max RPR
    1 Silver Hawk 0 91 91
    1 Manado 2 111 111
    1 Magical Strike 0 88 88
    1 Lorenzaccio 0 88 88
    1 Lord Americo 4 143 143
    1 Long Pond 3 119 119
    1 Jupiter Island 5 148 148
    1 Legend Of France 0 102 102
    1 Kahyasi 2 124 124
    1 Simply Great 0 77 77
    1 Skyliner 0 64 64
    1 Zaffaran 0 102 102
    1 L´Emigrant 0 35 35
    1 Kris 0 97 97
    1 Kinglet 0 58 58
    1 Step Together 0 111 111
    1 Tale Quale 0 90 90
    1 Menelek 1 91 91
    1 Linacre 1 99 99
     
    #18
  19. Ron

    Ron Well-Known Member
    Forum Moderator

    Joined:
    Jan 25, 2011
    Messages:
    51,288
    Likes Received:
    25,808
    Oddy, now I have the data in a processable format I should be able to answer any questions on Presenting.
     
    #19
  20. OddDog

    OddDog Mild mannered janitor
    Staff Member

    Joined:
    Jun 2, 2011
    Messages:
    28,588
    Likes Received:
    10,550
    King of the number crunchers Ron <yikes>

    Just looked at Montjeu's progeny over the sticks - a very select few <ok>

    Anyone know if that is likely to grow?
     
    #20

Share This Page