I understand where you're coming from regarding Marshall, however it's crystal clear that the TEAM have conceded less goals with Jak between the sticks. The decision shouldn't just be based on who's the more expensive or who gets paid more, it shouldn't be about who's the best shot stopper, whose distribution is better or even who's made the most/worst error(s). It should be based on what overall results have been better so far this season with each keeper in goal, and based on that I'd say that Jak wins the place hands down.
Think I'd go with - Jakupovic Weir Dawson Maguire Robertson Livermore Huddlestone Meyler Snodgrass Diomande Henriksen
I was quite impressed with Weir when he came on, with a bit more first team action he could develop into a good utility player.
Nice to see the young lads coming through the youth system and playing I think Josh Tymon is going to be very good player but Robertson can change games running at defenders Henriksen is looking better as well
Assuming it's two centre backs I think I'd rather have Maguire. But, I certainly won't moan if it is Davies, and it most likely will be.
Jak Elmo Dawson Davies Robbo Meyler Huddlestone Clucas Snoddy Dio Henriksen If he's going to go defensive first half which he will Clucas on the left. Livermore had been poor lately Huddlestone looked better in front of the back four. And if Livermore plays he's better defending further up the pitch.
My preferred team would be: Jak Elmo Maguire Davies Dawson Robbo Clucas Snodgrass Livermore Maloney (if fit) Diomande
..........................jak ..........maguire dawson davies elmo........................................Robbo ...................Clucas .........livermore Henricksen ................Snodgrass ............Hernandez/Dio 352 is our best formation because elmo is a car crash at RB, he only starts 1 up top at home so theres no way he'll start 2 away
