Off Topic Official DC Mafia Game

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Captainchaos. said:
I have a hidden role though
Click to expand...

well speaking frnakly as town you've painted a bulleye on you so for me the town should say do we want to know and the obvious tactic would be to say investigators should look at chaos to see who kills him

the conundrum here is whats best for town over all

1. Chaos you could be telling a lie to live over lynch.

2. Chaos could be Iris or harvey so a disaster to lose having lost vibe already. (in which canse you must leave doubt for the bad guys to ponder)

so for me you've already said enough to be centre of attention.
 
afcftw said:
I've tried to get some conversation going so I think this is a good idea!

Well my three suspicious are:

Chaos - reasons already given, said he voted for Tobes early on day one before disappearing until directly after nightfall where he began to post again, doesn't fit his play style and comes across like he could have teammates who had shut him up. Nothing particularly concrete but it stands out as odd to me.

DPP - only completely inactive player so ties in with being the SK.

Hmmm... Beyond that I'm not sure, ACS could be a good call as he went for a different option to the neutral one but we don't know which is bad/good yet. Not sure one comment is a good enough reason to be lynching him! But I also haven't got any other suspicions yet, everyone else has either come across like town or not posted enough to get any kind of read. So I suppose ACS is my third for now.

Directions:

In terms of the directions we don't have any wording that could potentially lead us this time so it seems a bit random to me. I like the thinking that the options match up with the options for day one and as such the cafe would be the bar option and neutral with the other two being good/bad. But then I'm thinking if the options match up each day doesn't that mean if we figure out the good option on one day we have it for every day? Seems too easy to me even though I like the theory. Also do we risk going for bad by accident in the search for good, or if we think we have figured out neutral do we just stick with neutral?
Click to expand...


You are soooo wrong on me mate
 
afcftw said:
I've tried to get some conversation going so I think this is a good idea!

Well my three suspicious are:

Chaos - reasons already given, said he voted for Tobes early on day one before disappearing until directly after nightfall where he began to post again, doesn't fit his play style and comes across like he could have teammates who had shut him up. Nothing particularly concrete but it stands out as odd to me.

DPP - only completely inactive player so ties in with being the SK.

Hmmm... Beyond that I'm not sure, ACS could be a good call as he went for a different option to the neutral one but we don't know which is bad/good yet. Not sure one comment is a good enough reason to be lynching him! But I also haven't got any other suspicions yet, everyone else has either come across like town or not posted enough to get any kind of read. So I suppose ACS is my third for now.

Directions:

In terms of the directions we don't have any wording that could potentially lead us this time so it seems a bit random to me. I like the thinking that the options match up with the options for day one and as such the cafe would be the bar option and neutral with the other two being good/bad. But then I'm thinking if the options match up each day doesn't that mean if we figure out the good option on one day we have it for every day? Seems too easy to me even though I like the theory. Also do we risk going for bad by accident in the search for good, or if we think we have figured out neutral do we just stick with neutral?
Click to expand...

on last part.

There's a reward for town going good. there's noting for nuetral. there's a punishment for bad.

If we decide the rewards is not worth the risk we are doing so on what?

I think this is the only thing we can at least make people talk about. no vanilla has to take anything but their own advice on it.
 
moreinjuredthanowen said:
on last part.

There's a reward for town going good. there's noting for nuetral. there's a punishment for bad.

If we decide the rewards is not worth the risk we are doing so on what?

I think this is the only thing we can at least make people talk about. no vanilla has to take anything but their own advice on it.
Click to expand...

Well we don't know what the reward or punishment is, so my question was, do we feel like the risk of a punishment is worth a reward or are we happy to stick with no reward knowing we avoid the punishment? This obviously only works if the thinking behind the options matching up with yesterday works and we know the neutral option. If we don't go with that trail of thought then any of the three could still be the good or bad and so we need to discuss them all.

I definitely still think people should be giving there suggestions on the direction.
 
afcftw said:
Just went back and read and I was right! OP says there are no hidden roles, it's an open game. So Chaos is making up a claim of a hidden role...
Click to expand...

Ha ha

You haven't figured me out yet have you mate?

Im just a piss taker
 
I'll update the day 1 update post later when home, forgot last night.

In in answer to question I saw, if a recruit was attempted and failed, that person would be made aware but it wouldn't be announced.
 
CENTRAL CITY NEWS
where the news comes first.

Edition – 10123940

All the latest news from Iris West Allen
A tough-as-nails journalist from Central City

News hot in from the Major’s Office:
Who voted for who in Lynch Vote. The Major was being relatively quiet and didn’t give much away but our hot reporter was able to find out how the following citizens voted;
AFC voted for Tobes
Mikey voted for Tobes
Astro voted for Tobes
Tennis voted for DPP
Bod did not vote

Well, what do you citizens think that shows? Time to muse and speculate. Tobes was a good guy but did he commit “suicide” by putting his big foot in it or was he killed by those who feared what he could do?

An attempt was made to follow one of our respectable citizens last night but he wasn’t where he claimed to be. What does this mean? It means that Iris is watching you and will continue to watch you. Be sure citizens this Reporter is one who won’t rest on previous glories and is keeping her eyes open to keep you GOOD citizens safe.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back