Off Topic Official DC Mafia Game
- Thread starter InBiscanWeTrust
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
Can IBWT please update the day 1 update post at top of thread.
for those lost here is the results http://www.not606.com/threads/official-dc-mafia-game.326901/page-13#post-9125211
........................................................................
Can we as town please get organised and my suggestion is like last game where we has known innocent mikey get asked all to name and give reasons.
So in this game without a known innocent I challenge the town to do the same.
1. Name your destination choice and give at least a single sentence reason.
2. Name your choice of say 3 guys and a single sentence reason why.
I see 2 people trying to have a town game here and the rest not so much.
The reaosn for doing this is so simple.
Yesterday we went along ok, some people straight out stated a direction then astro shut that completely down by saying it was suspect to state it. here's the thing. if all 20 offer a direction. the 7 remaining vanilla can still choose their own. we are not sheep.
But maybe a mafia stated the bad direction to nudge people. or just made other options sound really bad. Right now I just have a few guys who did maybe state other directions but not many. plus we don't know which one was good or bad but at least its info! shutting down info is bad.
here are mind.. without any fear of getting killed
1. Direction:
The direction
1. The Beach
2. The Beach Hut
3. The Cafe
there is literally nothing to go on in this in and of itself. They are without description.
We've already described the potential similarity to last clue.
One is a social destination. a cafe. there is a cafe in the flash. there has been countless attacks on people in said cafe. is that good or bad.. i don't know. if it follows logic yesterday (and i quote "Nothing much happens in the bar.") then we are gathered up and this could be neutral.
The beach... outdoors, by the water.. last episode of flash was the shark guy.. is there any bad character in maifa team that would benfit form beach? not that i can see. beach at night = dark = possible danger.
The beach hut. is it like the home? is it private, are people alone or in a group. what logic is at play?
so I have to be giving a guess bascially. Neutral = cafe. toss up on others. I'll say hut =good.
these are total guesses
2. Lynch
Here are my three for the lynch.
1. I checked DPP last night. He was not on thread here not posted yesterday so was inactive. As a result he would be a medium suspect with the understanding that someone could have watched him and just decided to fit him up but not acting. Equally he was in lynch last night so that would have perhaps been risky to do so as 2 people at least said he was in. as a result fit up would be mafia lead not SK led so as an SK didn't act that puts him up there... obviously medium shows how i'm not sure.
2. ACS. My only issue with ACS is he posted early he wanted to go to the park. this was not the neutral option so it gives him a problem. this would mean a purely mild read. as in its literally one post and i don't know if it was innocent opinion or a deliberate nudge from a mafia.
3. Valley for revenge... no seriously this is where it gets dodgy for me. I've very little to go on. I don't have a really hard third suspect but In fairness some guys have come off town so i want to say this. Bobby, style, Danilo, tennis, AFC. I saw some stuff that was either you don't mind getting killed for saying it or were helpful to town but some others have skirted by a bit. therefore I'm going to selected a very mild suspect in Bod.
sorry bod nothing personal but form my viewing of day one and comparing to last game you might pick up posting today and come off list but you sought to get through day one IMO.
..................................................
Again my reads are weak and i'd encourage as many to just offer something to force mafia and SKs to have to offer something.
for those lost here is the results http://www.not606.com/threads/official-dc-mafia-game.326901/page-13#post-9125211
........................................................................
Can we as town please get organised and my suggestion is like last game where we has known innocent mikey get asked all to name and give reasons.
So in this game without a known innocent I challenge the town to do the same.
1. Name your destination choice and give at least a single sentence reason.
2. Name your choice of say 3 guys and a single sentence reason why.
I see 2 people trying to have a town game here and the rest not so much.
The reaosn for doing this is so simple.
Yesterday we went along ok, some people straight out stated a direction then astro shut that completely down by saying it was suspect to state it. here's the thing. if all 20 offer a direction. the 7 remaining vanilla can still choose their own. we are not sheep.
But maybe a mafia stated the bad direction to nudge people. or just made other options sound really bad. Right now I just have a few guys who did maybe state other directions but not many. plus we don't know which one was good or bad but at least its info! shutting down info is bad.
here are mind.. without any fear of getting killed
1. Direction:
The direction
1. The Beach
2. The Beach Hut
3. The Cafe
there is literally nothing to go on in this in and of itself. They are without description.
We've already described the potential similarity to last clue.
One is a social destination. a cafe. there is a cafe in the flash. there has been countless attacks on people in said cafe. is that good or bad.. i don't know. if it follows logic yesterday (and i quote "Nothing much happens in the bar.") then we are gathered up and this could be neutral.
The beach... outdoors, by the water.. last episode of flash was the shark guy.. is there any bad character in maifa team that would benfit form beach? not that i can see. beach at night = dark = possible danger.
The beach hut. is it like the home? is it private, are people alone or in a group. what logic is at play?
so I have to be giving a guess bascially. Neutral = cafe. toss up on others. I'll say hut =good.
these are total guesses
2. Lynch
Here are my three for the lynch.
1. I checked DPP last night. He was not on thread here not posted yesterday so was inactive. As a result he would be a medium suspect with the understanding that someone could have watched him and just decided to fit him up but not acting. Equally he was in lynch last night so that would have perhaps been risky to do so as 2 people at least said he was in. as a result fit up would be mafia lead not SK led so as an SK didn't act that puts him up there... obviously medium shows how i'm not sure.
2. ACS. My only issue with ACS is he posted early he wanted to go to the park. this was not the neutral option so it gives him a problem. this would mean a purely mild read. as in its literally one post and i don't know if it was innocent opinion or a deliberate nudge from a mafia.
3. Valley for revenge... no seriously this is where it gets dodgy for me. I've very little to go on. I don't have a really hard third suspect but In fairness some guys have come off town so i want to say this. Bobby, style, Danilo, tennis, AFC. I saw some stuff that was either you don't mind getting killed for saying it or were helpful to town but some others have skirted by a bit. therefore I'm going to selected a very mild suspect in Bod.
sorry bod nothing personal but form my viewing of day one and comparing to last game you might pick up posting today and come off list but you sought to get through day one IMO.
..................................................
Again my reads are weak and i'd encourage as many to just offer something to force mafia and SKs to have to offer something.
I just want to theorise on mafia inactivity.
Possibilities (please add)
1. They chose not to act. No evidence on this possible.
1.a theory 1. they chose no action to save actions for better night
1.b theory 2. they are trying to fit up people through hiding inaction.
1.c theory 3. they are trying to fit up active players who thought they'd die. ie me as lynch target cos i called it out multiple times hoping to be investigated.. Must be said i thought i'd be dead.
2. they are hacking. - cannot tell yet.
3. They chose one of two other dead to target. Possible. BRB one target, unlikely tobes as he was lynched.. they had to know he was up and could have voted on him too.
4. they tried to recruit but failed. IBWT posted roles that cannot be recruited. If so it's likely we will see a mafia kill on one of these roles tomorrow.
We should clarify if possible if we would have been told if a recruit had failed. this is up to IBWt. we should also know if mafia can try again if they did fail. Any of this is possible
Possibilities (please add)
1. They chose not to act. No evidence on this possible.
1.a theory 1. they chose no action to save actions for better night
1.b theory 2. they are trying to fit up people through hiding inaction.
1.c theory 3. they are trying to fit up active players who thought they'd die. ie me as lynch target cos i called it out multiple times hoping to be investigated.. Must be said i thought i'd be dead.
2. they are hacking. - cannot tell yet.
3. They chose one of two other dead to target. Possible. BRB one target, unlikely tobes as he was lynched.. they had to know he was up and could have voted on him too.
4. they tried to recruit but failed. IBWT posted roles that cannot be recruited. If so it's likely we will see a mafia kill on one of these roles tomorrow.
We should clarify if possible if we would have been told if a recruit had failed. this is up to IBWt. we should also know if mafia can try again if they did fail. Any of this is possible
It doesn't say i cant, so i presume i can
Before I do just wanted to be certain i didn't miss anything
chaos if you are serious then think hard. I think the consensus is with 3 kills possible if you've a town role... well... at least leave it in doubt. you are.
as long as you do not post your own pm you can say anything you like...
but just think on.
as long as you do not post your own pm you can say anything you like...
but just think on.
If I were mafia I would have tried to recruit Tobes.
Either he is lynched and you lose a day but nothing more, or you recruit him and he's a townie with a role, or you fail and you learn one of the unrecruitables.
I'm thinking of visiting the beach. I think it could be a risky option (similarities to yesterday's destinations), but possibly more to be gained out of it than the cafe (bar).
In terms of dodgy, I'm thinking Chaos, Astro and DPP. The latter hasn't been on, Astro nailed Tobes and Chaos is just too keen.
In terms of dodgy, I'm thinking Chaos, Astro and DPP. The latter hasn't been on, Astro nailed Tobes and Chaos is just too keen.
I nailed Tobes by knowing a real vanilla would know from their PM how to vote for direction
that is possible for sure. but surely you tip the lynch to make it work. If the rules allow your recruit to come back to you.
I think yes in generally my view would be similar, that the mafia should have recruited night one. inaction as mafia in general is paid for in spades later in game.
a recruit will get you at worst a vanilla and you get to read the pm once you do. At best you hit a town role you can take over and in the middle is getting a can't recruit back so you get a target to lynch in private.
that recruit is as good as an investigation but it gives extra number..
I've tried to get some conversation going so I think this is a good idea!
Well my three suspicious are:
Chaos - reasons already given, said he voted for Tobes early on day one before disappearing until directly after nightfall where he began to post again, doesn't fit his play style and comes across like he could have teammates who had shut him up. Nothing particularly concrete but it stands out as odd to me.
DPP - only completely inactive player so ties in with being the SK.
Hmmm... Beyond that I'm not sure, ACS could be a good call as he went for a different option to the neutral one but we don't know which is bad/good yet. Not sure one comment is a good enough reason to be lynching him! But I also haven't got any other suspicions yet, everyone else has either come across like town or not posted enough to get any kind of read. So I suppose ACS is my third for now.
Directions:
In terms of the directions we don't have any wording that could potentially lead us this time so it seems a bit random to me. I like the thinking that the options match up with the options for day one and as such the cafe would be the bar option and neutral with the other two being good/bad. But then I'm thinking if the options match up each day doesn't that mean if we figure out the good option on one day we have it for every day? Seems too easy to me even though I like the theory. Also do we risk going for bad by accident in the search for good, or if we think we have figured out neutral do we just stick with neutral?