Off Topic Mafia game: The island

Just vote randomly on direction, no organisation, plan or method of testing the various room theories? ..basically ignore the fact that it is in the game and is significant in Mito's rules?

fair play, Sir

Mafia would be laughing all the way to a win with that

#justsaying

 

I don't want to say but it's clear people are pushing for other directions. I suspect they are coming up with nonsense to hide their real agenda.

 

Finally people are seeing what i was on about from day dot.

 

Sorry, poor choice of words from me there. I wasn't suggesting we vote randomly, I was passing opinion on the route choices. Obviously they matter in same regard, otherwise we wouldn't be choosing each night. What I meant was, I don't think choosing "the right route" will see a mass escape prior to lots of deaths. The basics of a mafia game still apply, we need to kill the bad guys.

 

• The "Mafia" win when they are majority team left in game and no escape is possible or it is inevitable this will occur
• The "Town" wins when all bad guys are wiped out and if they escape or it is inevitable both will occur.

The 'escape' must surely be influenced by the chosen path?

If we choose the wrong options we get picked off, until the maths dictate we're ****ed. If we choose the right ones then the kills aren't actioned? And we get nearer to the exit route?

 

Whereas you are openly admitting you have an agenda to go north right?

 

Day one

Lets all go towards poisonous chemicals

Day two

Lets go the hardest route?

Seriously

 

I only disagree that there is A route. It can't be just one or there's a 2/3 chance we're already ****ed.

 

That's slightly different wording to before. Previously, you made it sound like if we were to choose the right option there would be a lovely helicopter and pilot sat waiting to fly us to mass safety

I agree that the wrong choices will see people picked off. Perhaps visiting the garden got Biscan killed for some reason?

 

Fair point.

For what it's worth I think we made the wrong choice yesterday, as I think there might have been something within the house that could have maybe helped us. I'd have certainly written that in, if it was me anyway.

 

Unfortunately we are where we are and i think people are seeing what i was on about yesterday in that we are being led in directions by people that dont want us to find clues or escape.

 

Had we gone upstairs, we'd have got an option along the lines of bedroom, bathroom or attic.

Downstairs may have seen kitchen, lounge or conservatory.

We wouldn't have got north, south or east

#hindsight

 

What i mean is..each day we have 3 rooms to choose (actual location isnt THAT important just room A/B/C, (it might/will be important in how Mitro decides what is a safe room which room is a 'death of lynch-ee room ...ie He will be giving us clues ..so we need to work out which room(s) are the safe ones which is the killing directions (for the lynch-ee)

collectively we vote for room 'A' to be be full or empty or or or some other combination of room vote distribution

IF..we get the right room combination....the escapee ..escapes. Get it wrong he dies

(If we can work out the pattern of the choices ...that will be visible on here..and the mafia will try to screw our selection up ...giving themselves away...like a 'classic' lynch vote)


that said..this is just based on my ..feel..towards the significance of the room vote...but it is there for a reason

 

I disagree with that. I think Biscan was killed because the mafia targeted him. Unless they only get kills in specific locations. I think it's far more likely that different locations will offer different clues rather than anything else.

 

I agree

 

At this stage, they could mean anything. The reality is, we're all guessing anyway. Hopefully tonight will give us a better idea.

 

Probably, though the timeline isn't so linear.

Yesterday we did an investigation of the balcony after the death of 23, then we all came together again. Then there was the lynch/escape stuff last night, and we came out into this gardens this morning.

If we chose up/downstairs, would we have gone there last night, or this morning?

 

I'd imagine this morning if we went to the garden this morning. But my honest answer is; no idea

 

If i recall nev you were adament about upstairs yesterday

There was a few

 

I was convinced that upstairs was the most likely place to find clues. I still think that might have been the case.