I thought Bart was outstanding today, but I think Kelv should have 1 more season left. maybe rotate the keepers a bit more?
Maybe Bialkowski will get more games this year. But Kelvin Davis has fully earned this and has a wealth of experience
I bet the same people wanting Bart in goal, will be the first ones to say if he had a stinker against Leeds that "Adkins was mental to drop our first choice keeper!!!"
Hmmm i feel they are very similar in skill and shot stopping. While Kelvin has done nothing wrong to loose his place, i feel its probably time to focus on the younger keeper =/ purely for the fact that he is younger and is more likely to develop.
Yes, let's drop Lallana too. There is someone younger who we've barely seen play in competitive games, but he's younger, so is more likely to develop. F**k me, I am so very glad you lot don't pick the team.
It's a debate and he's going to be dropped some time. We'll presume your vote goes for Davis. Don't criticise others for differing opinions.
well thats just being stupid, everyone has different thoughts and reasons, just cos they don't agree with what you think
I think that's a bit of a daft reason to criticise him. Actually, is that a daft reason as well? Grow up CBK, let people have an opinion without labelling it as wrong.
I'm really pleased we have someone so capable to step up if called upon, but I'm with Davis. He should be allowed to lose his place, but not have it taken before it starts.
personally for experience reasons... Davis.. until a paring of centre backs have gelled and i see for them to do most of the work.. but Deff put bart in to more games... he is a class keeper... and through all his loyalty, deserves his due!
I believe this is the final year of Bart's contract? I know he has an option of another two years though....
I've always like Bart and Kelv, however I voted Bart as I see him as our future keeper. Kelv saved us so many times from complete embarrassment on our downward spiral and for that I think he's brilliant, I just hope Bart has more of a run-out, maybe blood him in with the Cups.
Davis was goalkeeper of the season in League One so why change him. The back four will be less settled if we change the keeper and I do not think chopping and changing is good for consistency. We are still on a roll from last season so don't change it. With Adkins being a former goalkeeper I am sure he knows what he is doing. Davis number one all the way, I just don't know enough about Bialkowski because I don't see him play much and I think that Adkins sees more of him than I do, so I have faith in his judgement.
Davis was amazing last year and for that reason alone deserves another go at the Championship. Of course he is not undroppable but I think he is one of the most important players in our team at the moment. Bart has been excellent when I have seen him play as well and fair play to him for sitting on our bench for so long because he could have easily got a game for half the teams in the Championship.
