Mafia XI - An Unknown Evil -GAMEOVER Town/Anarchist Victory!

Such a hard role to play like a townie tbh, town went mad at gerrez early on and that kinda screwed us lol

#rad
Good fun though!

 

Then why haven't you even tried to down him then? If you can't win unless he dies then surely your prime objective should be to kill him? Then you can't lose?

When the reality isyou've been doing the polar opposite. You patently don't want to see him swing and vice versa


Also a game plan that requires 2 townies to take each other out?

#soundslegit

 

Seems like a good point to join in with a list. Not sure how helpful it will be....

(pasted AFC's post as a template so some bits will be left the same)

RHC - Not played enough games with him to know his style. The ones I have he hasn't posted much and ended up being a passenger on the winning team.
Mito - Playing his usual analytical game. My read is town (but not 100%). Was surprised at him going No Lynch last night as he usually goes with what is in front of him. However, I think I understand why he did it.
Gerrez - 100% suspicious but not 100% guilty. Everything in my head screams he is guilty but still get a nagging feeling in my gut that not everything is as it seems. Would have voted for him if the early votes had been on him rather than AFC. At this stage I think we need to see either him or AFC hanging from a tree (based on whichever is more likely to be lynched)
JPF - High Priest of the Occult Brotherhood of the Skull - dead, but interesting the wording of his death, I think his teammates know there own roles but don't know who there teammates are.
astro - hasn't actually contributed much of use but has posted fairly often, this is usually how suspicious people play, be noticed but don't help or draw attention. One to watch. Also, thought I spotted an early link between him and JPF - tho this is based on instinct more than evidence. Also obsessed with Derek!
Neville - 100% innocent. Not claiming a special role.
Tobes - Not sure. Getting both town and evil reads off him. Seems very defensive of ACS.
Bod - very very quiet compared to usual. Think there may be a reason for this and it may not be his own choosing.
Style - early activity, has since gone quiet, did seem to be siding with some of the newkie people early, suspicious!
AFC - 100% suspicious but not 100% guilty. Everything in my head screams he is guilty but still get a nagging feeling in my gut that not everything is as it seems. Voted for him because the early votes had been on him rather than Gerrez. At this stage I think we need to see either him or Gerrez hanging from a tree (based on whichever is more likely to be lynched)
Lucaas - Caught between a rock and a hard place on this one. Seemed to be suspicious of the same people I was. The assassination attempt and bodyguard raises questions. Need to learn more before deciding
Obi Wan - A bloody headfuck as usual initially I thought he was a definite bad guy but his posts today have given me a strong townie read. Leaning towards innocent.
IBWT - Got a very strong town read yesterday, followed by an evil read today. Another I'm not sure about.
Valley - Think he is probably innocent (but not certain)
ACS - As hard to read as ever. Known bad guy killed but not known what side he came back to life on. Suspect evil but not certain. Claims to be invincible but not sure that is true.
Tennisball - leaning towards innocent, but he is hard to read. Always plays the same sort of game and makes good points. However, for now I am assuming he is on our side.
Magic- has he even posted?
Mikey - leaning towards innocent. He has never lasted long enough in games I've played for me to learn how he normally plays.

 

Because knowing each other is innocent helps the town. The medium knows who we are so that's three known innocents once the medium reveals himself (no, I'm still not asking the medium to reveal himself dudes. He needs to remain hidden)

PS...yet more persistence from Tobes on this subject too

 

We did both try and take each other out lol but then you were going to kill us both and that's just a massive town fail so we switched tact and instead tried to become a couple of known townies. I've genuinely been trying to play in the best interests of the town, from the moment I started a post saying I was putting my town hat on and said I did infact know what gerrez was doing and he was innocent. I just couldn't help myself enjoying watching him squirm at the start lol

#rad

 

I'm thinking Tobes shouldn't be the person to rival me on votes, the more I think about it the more I think he could just be a bad townie...

I vote Lucaaaaas

Who protected him? Don with a bodyguard is a possibility?

 

So even though you know you have to kill him to somehow 'win', you're going to convince people not to kill him because it helps the town?

Depsite you doing **** all but confuse the town with your lies and subsequent desperate back peddling apology, that was based on nothing but trying to save your own skin at the expense of what was best for the town?

#soundslegit

 

And yes I realise that puts me even further ahead lol, only way I don't die today is if townies wake up so I'm going to vote for someone I think I should vote for rather than follow the crowd. #dude

 

Jesus H Dude Christ, how many times. Change the bloody record

If you look back at yesterdays comments, you'll see I said no lynch early on.

Maybe you should look at yourself and question why you immediately presumed guilt (I'm talking about your second vote for me) once the surfer words were pointed out to you! Same goes for everyone else.

AFC and I were deliberately hand picked by Milk for these roles because we are both active, there was no way we'd go unnoticed whilst using those words and we both have a reputation for avoiding the lynch.

 

I've not presumed anything.

You told a pack of lies, which when exposed as such, you posted an 'apology' and a nonsensical explanation of your supposed role.

You said afc was guilty, then back tracked, you said there was a reward for the task and then back tracked. Why the **** wouldn't anyone think you were guilty ffs?

What's preposterous is that you're trying to make out that my apportioning guilt given YOUR actions and what else we've got to go on, is somehow outlandish

 

if one of you does is the other actually any use?

 

Leading towards just lynching us anyway even though it looks like we are probably town? IBWT still on my suspicious list! #dude

 

More you both could be honest from first post, we'd leave you to it and concentrate on the game. Instead you've both come up with random stuff and distracted us from looking elsewhere.

 

Not at all. You've read my post totally wrong there.

Byway i I was asking gerrez

 

Admittedly going for killing each other early on was probably a bad move lol but it was hilarious!

And the role we have meant we were always going to get lots of attention and have to get ourselves out of trouble.

As a town you can listen and stop wasting time trying to kill townies. Townies who by the way are currently more use than any of the rest of you as we know each other's innocence and the medium will know we are innocent.

#wakeuptown
#dude

 

@Gerrez

if if we kill one of you, are you of any use to the town other than being just a normal town role?

 

No voting movement, no alternative option to me being put forward and no-one anywhere near me on votes.

I'd say the bad guys are pretty happy with the current situation

#typicaltown
#dude

 

I've been busy at work today so been reading through the thread whenever possible but haven't been able to post as much as I'd like.

The bodyguard role really threw me, as it's different to previous games.
We've had:
A) a Doctor role for town that can save someone from being killed (this player could choose someone to protect)
B) a Private in the zombie game that protected the Scientist if he was attacked (this player could not choose, it was automatic)
C) I can't recall a mafia saving role, we've had immunity from investigations but I can't remember a role that blocks a kill, perhaps in one of the games I didn't play?

If the bodyguard was assigned to Lucaaas like (B) above then Lucaaas has to be someone important, either an evil Don type role or an important Town role like Medium etc.

If the bodyguard could choose who to protect then they're either in an evil team together, or the bodyguard is town aligned and chose to protect Lucaaas. There has been speculation regarding the "Assembling of the team" for JPF which made me think they were recruiting members, but two evil guys in a team protecting each other goes against this theory so inconclusive at this stage which one it is. Other question that other guys have asked too is why Lucaaas was protected, someone obviously thought he was going to be targeted, mito's posts sum up these ideas...

 

Cheeky ****

 

We will learn plenty tonight if you go - though I accept it could be bad news. Out of the two of you I'd have preferred Gerrez up for lynching just because I think that would teach us slightly more and because he has been less consisitent in his story. Plus I have a feeling that we may well see no lynch tonight, even if it isn't voted for.