Firmino vs. Depay

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

Who is better...

  • Firmino

  • Depay

  • Stewert Downing

  • MITO is a c*nt!


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Depay has a lot to learn, some of the silly flicks and decision making has to improve, but the raw talent is there, no doubt about that. The thing I like about him is his directness. When he gets the ball he looks to do something positive with it. I like Oxlade-Chamberlain for the same reason (I'm not comparing the quality, ability or potential of the two players, just their approach to the game, thought that was worth mentioning before Statto latched onto it). Contrast that to someone like Valencia who looks scared ****less when he gets the ball!

ronaldo mark II?
 
Depay is a brilliant talent - has potential to become world class. He was the player I wanted to replace Sterling.
 
22m straight up plus additional based on performances. So far he's done nothing that earns them that additional money <ok>
Agreed.

The 100% reliable Transfer League has Firmino listed at £29million and Depay at £25million.

I believe if we win everything Depay will cost us £31million.
 
22m straight up plus additional based on performances. So far he's done nothing that earns them that additional money <ok>

So you've accepted he's going to **** then by posting his cost as being £22m?
 
Last edited:
Agreed.

The 100% reliable Transfer League has Firmino listed at £29million and Depay at £25million.

I believe if we win everything Depay will cost us £31million.

So its 29 for Firmino which includes add on a but only 25 for depay and don't include the add ons.

Only way Firmino will be more expensive is if he out persons depay then <whistle>
 
  • Like
Reactions: jenners04
So you've accepted he's going to **** then by posting his cost as being £22m?

Nope just comparing like for like. Initial fees 22m v 25m and add on totals 29m v 31m

so like I originally said, Firmino was actually cheaper and will be if both hit the required targets
 
Nope just comparing like for like. Initial fees 22m v 25m and add on totals 29m v 31m

so like I originally said, Firmino was actually cheaper and will be if both hit the required targets
I posted this at the time..........

http://liverpooloffside.sbnation.co...gnificant-portion-of-firmino-hoffenheim-gross
Note the comment from Tony Barrett.

In any case the fees are irrelevant to the OP, which was about footbal, wasn't it?

So far, it's advantage Depay.
 
I posted this at the time..........

http://liverpooloffside.sbnation.co...gnificant-portion-of-firmino-hoffenheim-gross
Note the comment from Tony Barrett.

In any case the fees are irrelevant to the OP, which was about footbal, wasn't it?

So far, it's advantage Depay.

I was replying to this gem of a post though <whistle>

Firmino is older and cost more (age 24 next month, £29 mil)
Memphis is younger and cheaper (age 21, £24 mil)
Therefore, Firmino must be better. who pays more for older guys, unless they are much better.
 
So its 29 for Firmino which includes add on a but only 25 for depay and don't include the add ons.

Only way Firmino will be more expensive is if he out persons depay then <whistle>
No I was comparing the initial fees as listed by the 100% reliable Transfer League. The Firmino fee at £29million is backed up by the 100% reliable Wikipedia. The Liverpool Echo thought the fee was in the region of £30million but what do they know?
 
Can't we just all agree that Firmino now regrets not joining United, and if he had, he AND Depay would now both be the best thing since sliced bread <whistle>

EDIT: He'd still be on the bench mind, as Depay would start :biggrin:
 
They made the QF of the EL last season.

How did you get on in that again?

League 1 my arse. Bitter kopites

How many of last night's team were in the QF BTW?

[HASHTAG]#eightplayersinjured[/HASHTAG]
 
How many of last night's team were in the QF BTW?

[HASHTAG]#eightplayersinjured[/HASHTAG]

8 of the players who played last night were in the team that played in that QF

...and the other 3 were new signings

You must log in or register to see images
 
8 of the players who played last night were in the team that played in that QF

...and the other 3 were new signings

You must log in or register to see images

2 on the bench, one off injured first half, and another sent off.

So 4-5 of the QF players actually played. And saying they made the QF means they lost the QF.

[HASHTAG]#ouch[/HASHTAG]
 
2 on the bench, one off injured first half, and another sent off.

So 4-5 of the QF players actually played. And saying they made the QF means they lost the QF.

[HASHTAG]#ouch[/HASHTAG]

So 8 of the players then, just like I said?

Plus 3 new signings

Thanks for clearing that up <ok>

[HASHTAG]#ouchindeed[/HASHTAG]
 
Status
Not open for further replies.