In France they have the most unpopular player of the year award as voted by the media, who would win that?
This for me as well. As good as Shaw is for his age Apilicueta has definitely been better and there may well be a couple more ahead of him. Baines for one if only for his goals and assists.
Marshall and De Gea are the two keepers I'm generally seeing get mentioned (and rightly so, I might add), but I'd certainly throw Speroni in there. At the other end of the scale, Krul hasn't always been too great. And Big Sam has dumped his beloved Jussi.