Kyle Walker

So, a very exciting player who did well for Villa anytime I seen him. Especially going forward.

What does everyone else think? Can we see him starting above both Charlie and Hutton? In terms of Hutton, he could have a great performance like he did against Wolves, but also get forward way too much and cut into space that's meant for Lennon, maybe Walker might have the same issue and get us caught out sometimes? Working with Lennon is also something that Charlie can do very well.

Essentially, who should we get rid of and who should start? I think we could get good money for either Charlie or Hutton, but would you actually want rid of them?

 

Not Charlie, massively underrated in my opinion

And I was excited by Walker, but now you mention it, he might cause Lennon the same problem that Hutton does. Corluka and Lennon is a fantastic combination I believe

 

Second'd, Triffic.

Charlie is far superior to Hutton.
Walker will have his work cut out to try and beat him to a first team place.

 

Walker is automatic first choice at Villa. He's already stated that's he's happy there, but would come back to Spurs if we play him. The guy obviously wants to play. And, unless Harry is going to make him first choice, he sounds like he'd prefer to stay where he is.

 

Corluka is class, bit slow but reads the game well and much better than Alan 'White Cafu' Hutton.

 

Defo keep Charlie, if only for the reason that one of Luka's reasons for being happy at spurs is that he's here. Second to that he's a lot more reliable than Hutton, who I think should be shipped out. Then we can rotate between Charlie and Walker depending on the opposition with Kaboul as an option if (as inevitably will happen with our injury record) they both get injured.

 

SDCA's got it about right, in my opinion.
Corluka as first choice, Walker as back-up and in the cups, with Kaboul mainly used as a centre-half and in emergencies and Hutton sold on.

 

Walker - Still abit suspect defensively imo PNP, agreed going forward, got goals in him too. Needs to curb the urge to get forward, getting caught positionally when I've watched Villa, and as said, could hinder Lennon. Admittedly I haven't seen every performance, but thats how I see it. Hopefully, we might try it in the friendlies.

 

imo he should replace Hutton,but the combo is Charlie and Lennon,the only downer there is Charlie has'nt any pace