Cesar 6/10 Was excellent in January, average before that, poor afterwards. Doesn't care. Green 4/10 Cares, but makes far too many mistakes. Made some decent saves. Ben Haim 5/10 Didn't play much. Played alright for some games, not really PL quality though. Bosingwa 2/10 What a bellend. Performances were sometimes as bad as his attitude. Fabio 6/10 Seemed decent. Didn't play much. Hill 6/10 Despite all his efforts, just isn't good enough. Onuoha 7/10 Played very well in some games. Better as a CB than a RB. Samba 3/10 Started well, but turned out to be a huge disappointment. Traore 4/10 Not good enough defensively, didn't show much going forward this year. Nelsen 8/10 A pleasant surprise. Shame he left early. Ferdinand 2/10 Just an awful player. Diakite 2/10 How sure were we that he would be excellent? Big disappointment. Derry 6/10 Just what I expected. Fighting displays, lots of effort, but a lack of quality. Granero 3/10 Disappointing. Poor displays bar a few at the start. Hoilett 2/10 Awful performances. Just one of many flops. Jenas 8/10 One of the only good players in an awful bunch. Will be excellent if we can keep. Mackie 5/10 Will always give 110%, but just not enough quality. Mbia 4/10 Can't pass to save his life. Not good enough and his diving is frankly embarrassing. Park 1/10 No good games ever. Champions League winner, how? Wright-Phillips 3/10 Lacks quality, but scored my favourite goal this season. Faurlin 4/10 Not the same player as before his injury. Taarabt 6/10 Nothing new here. Brilliant on his day, non existent when off form.] Townsend 9/10 POTY. Brilliant player! Shame we can't keep him. Bothroyd 5/10 Not played much, looked decent occasionally. Remy 9/10 An excellent signing. Not many in the PL can finish like he can. His goal Vs Wigan was just magical. Zamora4/10 Got some early goals, but was played when completely crippled. Red Vs Wigan was idiotic. Cisse 2/10 Didn't care one bit. Massive let down. Hughes 0/10 What could I possibly say that hasn't been said? Redknapp 3/10 Not our saviour. Making too many excuses to buy in the summer. Beginning to really piss me off.
You're being way too generous Cesar 4/10 (the biggest of the money grubbers) Green 3/10 Bosingwa 0/10 Fabio 4/10 Hill 6/10 Onuoha 5/10 Samba 2/10 (what a disappointment) Traore 4/10 Nelsen 4/10 (sorry but he left us in the lurch) Ferdinand 1/10 Diakite 3/10 Derry 7/10 Granero 1/10 Hoilett 1/10 Jenas 5/10 Mackie 6/10 Mbia 2/10 Park 0/10 Wright-Phillips 4/10 (at least he tries) Faurlin 3/10 Taarabt 3/10 (shocking season when you consider his talent) Townsend 8/10 Bothroyd 1/10 Remy 6/10 (instinctive finisher but not top drawer IMO) Zamora 1/10 Cisse 1/10
Would agree with most of that except I would knock another 2 points of most of the players. Can you have minus scores?
Cesar 5 Green 4 Ben Haim 4 Bosingwa 1 Fabio 5 Hill 6 Onuoha 6 Samba 4 Traore 4 Nelsen 7 Ferdinand 3 Diakite 3 Derry 6 Granero 2 Hoilett 2 Jenas 6 Mackie 5 Mbia 3 Park 2 SWP 4 Faurlin 3 Taarabt 4 Townsend 8 Bothroyd 3 Remy 7 Zamora 2 Cisse 1 So many players who we know can do so much better have all been brought down by this collective malais afflicting our club...
Blimey. Not sure what to make of you guys who've gone to all the effort of marking every player. On the one hand, I want to say.. well done. That shows a lot of commitment and love to the club... or.. being worried that you may have masochistic issues and urge you to garb a beer, relax, you can't change the past.. just enjoy the good things that are in the world. So both those things, fellas. Be happy.
I'm bored...will give it a go Cesar 3 Green 5 (tries) Ben Haim 4 Bosingwa -0 Fabio 5 Hill 6 Onuoha 6 Samba 3 Traore 5 Nelsen 4 (would have been a 7 if he hadn't left us in the lurch) Ferdinand 1 Diakite nothing to go on Derry 7 Granero 2 Hoilett 1 Jenas 7 Mackie 5 Mbia 3 Park 2 SWP 4 Faurlin (we let him go...unfair to mark him) Taarabt 4 Townsend 8 Bothroyd 3 Remy 4 (but 9 for the goal against wigan and having the ability that no one else has to score a penalty)...but if found guilt I want him never to play in a hoop shirt again Zamora 1 Cisse -0
I'll reluctantly give the whole lot of them a big collective ZERO. They're lucky I'm in a good mood or it would have been -5 to each and every one of them.
You would be better marking the players under the 12 games of Hughes then see what effect Harold had on them
Dave............we were heading the same way under Hughes mate. 4 points was all he could get FFS!! He played players out of position and in the wrong formations, time and time again. Harry has been no better!
